I'm using tri-state to mean it has three distinct states. The output transistors are not connected to the same enable line. If that's wrong use, I'm sorry.
The point I'm making is that it's easy to make it so the output transistors don't fight, even if the one that's enabled gets a halfsies voltage, because the other one won't also get a halfsies voltage, it will get a pure digital off.
> Damping dissipates heat, so damping by controlling the output transistor requires a bigger output transistor. Damping the output transistor also changes the electrical characteristics of the pin.
I'm assuming it's already kind of heat resistant because it only sometimes fails when shorted with no limiter at all. And if you damp it enough you won't make much heat. But fine, let's ignore that. You already brought up just turning it off at a certain point. If that's what's needed, so be it, because that won't change the characteristics.
No magic needed to keep the characteristics the same if you're just turning it off the way it normally turns off.
But I still don't understand how a transistor with a damped input is supposed to cause voltage spikes in excess of the same transistor with an undamped input, with only the control logic changing.
If damping makes heat, how can damping it enough make less heat? Why are you assuming that it's heat resistant if this is the level where you design the amount of heat resistance it has? Who did that work? Nobody, you have to do it yourself.
There is no control logic. It's analog. Logic is digital. Digital doesn't exist until we're done.
Sorry, but I've done all I can. Good luck in your search.
Slowing the current flow without a buck converter means you're going to be acting like a resistor and turning the voltage drop into heat.
Ideally this circuit has minimal voltage drop and minimal heat. As you start damping you'll increase the resistance, creating more heat.
But the heat is voltage drop multiplied by current, so as you keep increasing resistance the power dissipated will hit a peak and then start decreasing as current approaches zero.
A transistor that's off doesn't make enough heat to kill itself.
> Why are you assuming that it's heat resistant if this is the level where you design the amount of heat resistance it has? Who did that work? Nobody, you have to do it yourself.
Because the premise is that it can survive short circuiting for some amount of time, and I want to increase that time. But also I'm willing to say "keep dropping the max current until it survives reliably, and let's see where we are at that point". I know that point does exist somewhere, even before I do any math.
> There is no control logic. It's analog. Logic is digital. Digital doesn't exist until we're done.
We can make an analog circuit output a digital decision.
The output transistor is always analog. But the already existing circuit controls it digitally, and we can continue to control it digitally if we want to.
There's no circular reasoning in "this partially analog circuit monitors a wire and outputs a digital signal based on some threshold"
> Sorry, but I've done all I can. Good luck in your search.
Cool but it feels like you purposefully ignored everything I said about keeping it simple and leaving most of the circuit unchanged, demanding I solve already-solved issues just to spite me... did you actually try to listen to me, or were you here just to come up with reasons I must be wrong?
Down below the digital level, you can't isolate decisions from each other and nothing is free.