News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:My Emacs eye candy by femiagbabiaka on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @12:55AM (#35624373)
The extensibility and customizability of Emacs typically means that bad UX is user error. There is a barrier to entry, but if you don't want to go past that, it's no big deal. I'm not sure that's the editor's fault though.
Re:My Emacs eye candy by illiarian on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @01:48AM (#35624678)
If you need to overcome a barrier and extend/customize to reach a good UX, that is the program's fault (applies to any program, not just emacs)
Re:My Emacs eye candy by usr1106 on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:12AM (#35624817)
I don't think good UX is a universal concept. People have different preferences. On my desktop I don't want click to type. But still many seem to prefer just that. I want a trackpoint, many are happy with touchpads.

(Of course some implementations can be classified as just bad UX...)

Re:My Emacs eye candy by illiarian on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:27AM (#35624906)
> I don't think good UX is a universal concept.

There are some more-or-less objective criteria we can apply. From "how many actions it takes to achieve something" to accessibility.

Re:My Emacs eye candy by nequo on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:45AM (#35625031)
Emacs is not terrible for accessibility. This is Parham Doustdar talking about how he uses Emacs as a blind developer:

https://emacsconf.org/2019/talks/08/

Re:My Emacs eye candy by noctuid on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:15AM (#35627741)
> how many actions it takes to achieve something

This is not really objective because you also have to take into consideration how intuitive/simple the UX is. Given 100 related actions, clicking through a logically grouped nested menu or multiple pages to do something is going to require more steps but be something anyone can do. Memorizing and using keyboard shortcuts for all those actions will be more efficient, but isn't something someone could immediately do. There is of course an in-between where you can have menus to display available keyboard shortcuts, but some (most?) people will still prefer a GUI/mouse-based approach. There is no one-size-fits-all approach.

Re:My Emacs eye candy by llanowarelves on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:44AM (#35625021)
Where is Xah Lee when you need him? His critiques of Emacs on this are spot on, imo. Helps that he backs up his claims (scattered around his site) with data and usability research.

"If emacs just use standard keys for open close save, cut copy paste undo, users will double in 1 year."[0]

[0]Emacs Modernization: http://xahlee.info/emacs/emacs/emacs_modernization.html

Re:My Emacs eye candy by distcs on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @06:22AM (#35626429)
Good UX is very subjective though. I mean for me the Emacs looks by default and how it allows me to customize it the way I see fit is good UX. Others don't see it as good UX.

Can I customize the status bar to include my contextual information with a single line of code in VS Code? Perhaps not. So VS Code has bad UX for my needs. But many consider VS Code to have good UX.

Re:My Emacs eye candy by govolckurself on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @07:45AM (#35626968)
Are our expectations so low now that developers can't be expected to put in a little effort to learn a text editor? Look, I promise I'm not the smartest guy, but I ground out a few weeks of memorizing key bindings like ten years ago, and that was basically it. M-x apropos and Google fill in the rest of the gaps. I truly don't understand why stuff like this seems to be so hard for people. My hunch is that they just don't want to put in the effort. Which is fine! But please just be honest about it.
Re:My Emacs eye candy by noctuid on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @09:05AM (#35627645)
Customizability is Emacs' selling point. A higher level of extensibility necessary means a higher learning curve. I'd call it a learning curve rather than "barrier": it's certainly not difficult to make Emacs look good. Most people don't care how Emacs behaves OOTB because they want to customize every aspect of it. You might say it should look or behave better by default, but I'd rather the base stay consistent and simple (it fits the use case better). There are plenty of starter kits/distros that look good OOTB for people who want a better default experience.