News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by qikInNdOutReply on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:33AM (#35615392)
The problem is that planetary civilization is inherantly fragile to those living up outside the gravity well. Every depressed belter asteroid-trucker with a balistics computer, can throw a garbage can at earth or mars at speed and end planetary civilization.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by philwelch on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:49AM (#35615634)
Rods from god are roughly as powerful as nukes, which is bad but a single nuke wouldn't end planetary civilization. If the belters were able to throw things at relativistic speeds you'd have a problem, but there's also no stealth in space so it's feasible to monitor space traffic around a large planet and deflect anything incoming, be it a projectile launched from longer range or an untrusted, uninspected, shady-looking belter ship.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by justinclift on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:25PM (#35616144)
The "rod from space" just need to deflect the orbit of an already existing large asteroid doesn't it?

Which would hopefully be detected in time to "solve" the problem, but still... ;)

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by AlotOfReading on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @12:49PM (#35616491)
"just" is doing a lot of work there. It's a pretty serious engineering effort to move rocks around the solar system and unless you have unlimited-energy future tech, you're probably stuck with the current paradigm of nudging things slightly to take advantage of convoluted gravity assists and small time windows to move things about. It'd be a very slow and predictable weapon that we already watch for.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by m4rtink on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:09PM (#35617584)
Anything small enough will just burn up in the atmosphere and big stuff will be easy to detect, even at the boost stage as the initial orbit change might take weeks or months possibly.

Orbitals at predictable orbits and surfaceinstallations on airless bodies might be more in danger though. There even a well targeted fast crowbar might do quite some damage.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by stametseater on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @02:39PM (#35618070)
I think rods from gods is oversold. The classic version of this is a "telephone pole of tungsten", or something along the lines of a 6 meter long cylinder, 0.3 meters across, which works out to 0.42 cubic meters of tungsten, which would be just over 8000 kilograms. If you do the math, rods coming in at orbit speeds are barely worth talking about; the actual rods from god USAF proposal had these tungsten telephone poles starting in orbit and impacting the ground at merely 3 km/s, equivalent to 11 tons of TNT.

Faster then: the kinetic energy of such a mass moving at 12 km/s, faster than escape velocity, would be 'only' 137 tons of TNT, approximately 1/15th of the 2020 Beirut explosion. Even if you throw the rods into the ground at a blistering 50 km/s, that only gives you the equivalent kinetic energy of 2.4 kilotons of TNT, or 1/6th of the Little Boy nuclear bomb.

Then there are the terminal effects; such a tungsten rod is basically an oversized armor piercing dart like tanks shoot at each other. It will drive itself straight into the ground and most of the rod's kinetic energy will be spent pulverizing bedrock and itself. Such a weapon would be great for taking out bunkers, but I think very wasteful for any other purpose.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by justinclift on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:10AM (#35625226)
> It will drive itself straight into the ground and most of the rod's kinetic energy will be spent pulverizing bedrock and itself. Such a weapon would be great for taking out bunkers, but I think very wasteful for any other purpose.

Wonder if it could be precision enough for non-military applications? eg possibly faster for deep geothermal drilling than using the existing surface based borehole drilling approach.

For military applications though, it'd wonder if such a rod (or small sequence of them) could be effective when striking geological fault lines. eg the San Andreas Fault line

Aka the old "use the terrain" approach.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by CyberDildonics on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:59AM (#35615782)
I think you're confusing reality with science fiction.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by myrmidon on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:23PM (#35616950)
This is complete BULLSHIT.

Your understanding of orbital dynamics is completely off-- "asteroids" are not a viable antiplanetary weapon and NEVER will be.

Changing the asteroid orbit costs you pretty much just as much energy as your impact is worth-- so you could just as well have launched the engine that is supposed to move your asteroid, and exploded in on-target.

The whole subplot in The Expanse only works because:

1) The drive technology violates conservation of energy and powers the impact (duh)

2) The "stealth paint" which glosses over physical impossibilities; You can't really hide over the whole spectrum (how is your "paint" supposed to deal with wavelengths that approach the object size?).

And both of the above are pure fantasy.

Better go play Kerbal space. And I seriously mean that-- it is going to give you a MUCH better intuitive understanding of orbital dynamics than school or university could ever provide.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by wpasc on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:10PM (#35618562)
how dare you besmirch the Epstein drive
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by myrmidon on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:03PM (#35619258)
Don't get me wrong I obviously liked the books enough to read them, but I still firmly believe that it is vitally important for sci-fi authors to just shut up about scientific details that our current understanding is not equipped to provide.

There are books that are WAYY farther from our current techlevel, like Murderbot Diaries or Ancillary Justice, which handle this much better. I just don't see how adding pseudoscience improves ANYTHING-- better to just gloss over it.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by fennecfoxy on Thursday April 20, 2023 @06:56AM (#35638314)
Ah, lovely to see Murderbot mentioned, I've just been re-reading it.

I think it's fine to take scifi tech with a grain of salt; most authors skip the absolute technical details so we just have to assume that things work in some way we don't currently understand. Someone did the calculation for the Epstein and it doesn't look great: http://toughsf.blogspot.com/2019/10/the-expanses-epstein-dri... but only based on the vague technical details provided in the books.

The Jean Le Flambeur trilogy is one of my favourites, it does a LOT of quantum hand-waving but the price is worth it for all of the amazing things in that universe. "This sounds so fucking cool" > "That wouldn't work irl" for good sci-fi imo. As long as they don't mess with thoroughly understood concepts and rely on "things we don't know yet".

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by stametseater on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @03:34PM (#35618908)
It's very far from practical technology, but in principle you can use pieces of the asteroid as reaction mass to 'cheat' the rocket equation. You could also modify the asteroid's albedo or use solar sails to modify the trajectory of the asteroid.

Very far from practical. Such a plot would probably take centuries at least to carry out with reasonably conceived technology.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by plasticchris on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:58PM (#35620041)
If you do play kerbal you know that getting a big circular orbit to become a very eccentric one (if you don’t care about reentry speed which is a feature here) is pretty cheap. Now just make that eccentric orbit intersect the target’s orbital path and boom.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by myrmidon on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:35PM (#35620593)
> If you do play kerbal you know that getting a big circular orbit to become a very eccentric one (if you don’t care about reentry speed which is a feature here) is pretty cheap

No its not?!

Simply getting a flyby from one planetary orbit to another is exactly the kind of expensive that I'm talking about, and thats basically what you get on impact.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by plasticchris on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @06:19PM (#35621189)
But the asteroid does not start in planetary orbit.
Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by marcosdumay on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:11PM (#35620247)
> Changing the asteroid orbit costs you pretty much just as much energy as your impact is worth

It's about momentum, not energy. Near Earth, you can get energy from the Sun quite easily, or fuel a nuclear reactor with the asteroid.

Momentum is gathered by throwing reaction mass around. And reaction mass is what asteroids are made of.

> The drive technology violates conservation of energy

Do they explain it somewhere? I always got the impression it was a kicking-ass nuclear fusion engine.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by myrmidon on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:27PM (#35620483)
> It's about momentum, not energy. Near Earth, you can get energy from the Sun quite easily, or fuel a nuclear reactor with the asteroid.

I'm not sure if you're being deliberately obtuse. Momentum does absolutely nothing for you by itself-- it does not even affect penetration depth of your asteroid.

The only thing momentum does is that it scales with speed (hint: like kinetic energy).

If you have enough fuel for a nuclear reactor to throw pieces of asteroid into space, then MAAAYYYYYBE just launch nuke at the planet?!

Because that is:

1) Easier to build

2) Simpler

3) Harder to detect

4) Harder to defend against

edit: Sorry for the tone. This whole topic just really infuriates me because I absolutely can not understand how anyone with even elementary physics education could ever defend this concept as viable...

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by marcosdumay on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @06:48PM (#35621529)
> The only thing momentum does is that it scales with speed

And mass...

If you have a fixed amount of energy, the amount of destruction you can create on your target is a complex function of how much delta-v you need. But the maximum is never on the extreme of "just emit all the energy there at once". It can always improve by adding some mass.

On those other comparisons, you probably have a point, assuming the people tech looks like the things we can imagine at realistic sci-fi.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by qikInNdOutReply on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:32AM (#35625383)
Now, this is a mature reaction to calling out handing nukes to toddlers. Well at least you took it constructive, by turning the discussion towards the material science of toddlers and societies they form. That, right here, is why we cant have nice, but dangerous things.

And remember, you got time to build up momentum, a ion drive accelerating in a spiral with swingbys, with one final push, can get you pretty high on the C if you dont want it right now.

And i was not referencing the expanse. I was referencing todays solar driven ion engines. Boring tech. Marathon tech. But given enough time it can move a mountain up a notch, without drag.

Re:Giant SpaceX Spiral Appears Amid the Aurora Lights in Ala... by myrmidon on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @12:53PM (#35630459)
> And remember, you got time to build up momentum, a ion drive accelerating in a spiral with swingbys, with one final push, can get you pretty high on the C if you dont want it right now.

No. You're not even getting close to your ion drives exhaust velocity, which is <100km/s.

So you are not accelerating ANY kind of asteroid for more than ~10km/s, because the closer you want to get to your exhaust velocity, the harder your scheme gets slapped down by the rocket equation-- "unlimited energy over time" does not even enter the equation.

So what you are left with is the option of finding an asteroid that you can get into a collision orbit with earth as cheaply as possible.

Even to just break even with the weakest nuclear weapons, you need at least 500 metric tons at 20km/s. You'll probably need something around 300m/s of delta-v (that would be a mars/earth transfer).

And this needs to happen quickly, because there is no stealth in space and everything you do can be observed and reverted (leaving aside the fact that any weapon system with a deployment delay measured in years is absurdly impractical).