I would think that there is approximately a 50% chance of most stocks beating the market on any given day though.
If you send a bunch of e-mails saying "${ticker} will go up more than the market tomorrow, I'd recommend you invest and hedge with a bet against the market" for a variety of random tickers, I'd guess around half of them would pay off.
The reverse also applies a.k.a. everyone could make money in the past few years.
Not that it's particularly easy to do, but if you took out an equal weighted short position on the $SPY while going long on some ticker, it would pay off if that ticker outperformed the market.
I'm not sure how else to explain this but please ask again if you feel like this isn't making sense; any failure here is mine, not the thought experiment's. This is an extremely well-known thought experiment. This wasn't thought up by anyone here.
Its amazing to see the people that won on the previous Nth rounds believe that their next tip was a "sure thing".
Say you have an email list of 100000 investors, you ask ChatGPT to produce 100000 predictions and send these out to each investor.
Assuming ChatGPT is as good as a coin flip, 50000 investors receive good predictions. The next week you have ChatGPT produce 50000 predictions and send them out to those winners, you now have 25000 who have gotten two good predictions.
Rinse and repeat four more times and congratulations, you now have a client list of over 1500 people who have received six weeks of good predictions and are ready for you to manage all of their wealth using these insanely accurate AI predictions.
[1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/business/2004/06/20/a...