Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:33AM
(#35611423)
Why should it be impossible to think of a brighter future? Maybe humans should be living like gods, not worried about diseases, the environment, etc. Maybe humans should strive to become the dominant species in the universe? Why should the current "protestant work ethic" (in a Max Weber sense) guide us - hedonism might also have something to each us.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by rayiner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @07:52AM
(#35612742)
We tried hedonism as a guiding principle over and over in the 20th century. Whereas Protestant work ethic gave us america, hedonism gave us the aids epidemic, over 100,000 drug overdoses annually, a generation of men that have opted out of adulthood, and the need to import people from non-hedonist countries just to keep the population stable. Enjoy your antibiotic resistant STDs.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:31AM
(#35613111)
What do you define as hedonism and its philosophical roots/components?
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by cheeseomlit on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:46AM
(#35613258)
Epicureanism perhaps? The hedonist mindset is certainly not novel to the 20th century as that poster seems to imply- Though I largely agree with their characterization of it, as its popularity seems to accompany periods of societal decline- Though whether it is a cause or a symptom is hard to say
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:53AM
(#35613329)
I would find it hard to draw a line from classical Epicureanism towards social decline or simply map some hedonistic periods of the 20th century onto it.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by cheeseomlit on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:06AM
(#35613469)
The line would be overly broad and blurry, to be sure. But I think Voltaire's maxim has some sense to it- "History is only the pattern of silken slippers descending the stairs to the thunder of hobnailed boots climbing upward from below." The rise and fall of great societies frequently parallel this general difference in temperament- The prosperous fruits of stoic labor create a lavish environment for their successors, in which they languish in indolence and allow the foundations built by their ancestors to crumble for want of diligence and prudence.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:31AM
(#35613754)
The problem is, that it is so much in the interest of those in power and with means to promote "stoic labor".
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by rayiner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @10:48AM
(#35614734)
Maybe, but it’s also in the interest of ordinary people. Look what that attitude did for countries like Singapore, Korea, and Japan. It’s easy to rile people up for redistribution. It’s much harder to create a culture oriented towards building.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:04AM
(#35614932)
I am not talking about redistribution or riling people up, but I don't see building and some forms of hedonism as fundamentally incompatible.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by rayiner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:10AM
(#35613512)
I think if you’re talking about social change that happens at scale, people are not necessarily following a specific coherent philosophy. But hedonistic values were widely adopted in various contexts in the mid-20th century. For example the sexual revolution and free love movement of the 1960s: https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna19053382. These attitudes are also prevalent in terms of messages given to young people regarding vocation (“follow your bliss,” etc.)
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @09:36AM
(#35613813)
What is the net social negative then? How do we know, given that counterfactuals are not readily available. What philosophy (in a broader sense) should people follow? Do we want forever a society where people need to do "shitty jobs", for example, to satisfy some philosophical need for "suffering"?
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by rayiner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:00AM
(#35614885)
You’re right, we don’t have any easy counterfactual. But we can draw inferences from observations and conduct thought experiments. If we dropped some people from San Francisco off in the hostile desert of Utah, would they be able to create thriving cities like the Mormons did? If we dropped them off in the frigid plains of Illinois, would they be able to create Chicago? If you dropped them off in the mudflats of Singapore, would they be able to turn it into the modern and wealthy city it is today?
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @11:30AM
(#35615333)
Not sure why building cities in the Utah desert matters today. The question is much broader, I think: without some of the 1960s hedonism, would we have had some of effects of counterculture that manifested in tech? Would we have had more wars like Vietnam? How would society look like?
You can, of course, say you want a different society - but that is a different take, really.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by rayiner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:50PM
(#35619911)
I come from a poor country. I want people back home to act like the Mormons, not like people in San Francisco. And America exports its culture all around the world. Moreover, I don’t think a hedonistic, individualistic culture is prepared to tackle the challenges we face (like climate change) nor to take society to the next level.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by FredPret on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @02:10AM
(#35624802)
I also came from a poor country that could use a big dose of Protestant work ethic. If you have $0, getting an extra million is the biggest of deals for your happiness.
But once you are rich and you’ve got snowballing wealth, maybe a change of perspective is in order. You won’t find as much meaning in going from $5m to $10m as in 0-$1m for example.
Not that laziness is the answer, but you need a new motivating principle.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by RandomLensman on Wednesday April 19, 2023 @03:54AM
(#35625542)
The 20th century had some large-scale "experiments" with non-individualistic society models - they were not pretty.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by anovikov on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @01:48PM
(#35617309)
Signapore is a terribly bad example. It's geography meant it was a ready source of money. Barring an absolutely terrible level of mismanagement, or chronic worldwide economic depression, there was no way it won't become rich.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by rayiner on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @04:59PM
(#35620069)
There’s nothing magic about the geography of Singapore, which is self-evident from a map. Singapore was poorer than Malaysia when the two countries split.
The notion that the economic fate of countries is outside their control is incredibly pernicious. Britain went from being a backwater that was almost a millennium late to the Bronze Age to the greatest empire in the world.
Re:Make the future bright again: On building a new philosoph...
by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:10AM
(#35612910)
> We tried hedonism as a guiding principle over and over in the 20th century.
[citation needed]