Re:Strong Opinions Loosely Held Might Be the Worst Idea in Tech
by cool_dude85 on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:00PM
(#35605775)
How sure are you of this opinion?
Re:Strong Opinions Loosely Held Might Be the Worst Idea in Tech
by Spivak on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:28PM
(#35606134)
Well yes because doing that substitution changes the meaning -- you're saying something fundamentally different in the latter article. It's no longer a piece about how a particular aspect of tech culture which got a foothold among the majority (white men) where that behavior not only doesn't reflect poorly on them, where a black man might get called aggressive and woman might get called bitchy, but is actively rewarded because that confidence is, sometimes mistakenly, used as a proxy for competence. And taken from a systems perspective this aspect of culture accidentally and through no ones fault created a prisoner's dilemma that forces group decision making to a local maximum instead of a global one. To write the same article about black people it would require a very different history and cultural context.
Re:Strong Opinions Loosely Held Might Be the Worst Idea in Tech
by DiggyJohnson on Monday April 17, 2023 @05:24PM
(#35606804)
Is the meaning changed so much as to make it acceptable?
I take your point about "that substitution changes the meaning", but I strongly disagree that it changes it enough to make the substitution unacceptable and the original acceptable.
I'm pretty sure that if the author had put "black" instead of "white," this article wouldn't have even been linked here. It's fashionable to openly express anti-white bigotry these days.