News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by nostrademons on Monday April 17, 2023 @11:54AM (#35602583)
The article makes an interesting case for the possibility that South Korea's military dictatorship intentionally created low-fertility policies that can't be reversed. But reading the description of what's going on, I can't help be reminded of John B. Calhoun's work on the "behavioral sink" [1], where he basically created a utopia where rats had everything they needed for survival, they multiplied exponentially, but once they reached a certain critical population density, they ceased to be interested in reproduction and instead exhibited a bunch of socially pathological behaviors. Within 3 generations, no further rats were born.

South Korea is a densely populated country, as is Japan (another country often cited as having an aging, low-fertility population). And people tend to move out of dense metropolises like Manhattan or SF to have children. Maybe there's something inborn to humans that causes us to seek space and resources, and if those are not available, to not have kids?

[1] https://vocal.media/geeks/the-true-history-behind-the-secret...

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by pm90 on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:23PM (#35602986)
I don’t believe its density as much as costs and impact on lifestyle.

Make daycare, child health services and great schools universally available and cheap/free. Make it feasible and safe to get kids around dense cities quickly (excellent transit options). I suspect under these circumstances more people would be open to the idea of children.

As it stands today, having children places an unbearably high social and financial strain on people. Suburbs have been just one solution to the problem but there are others.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by dmm on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:26PM (#35603037)
> Make daycare, child health services and great schools universally available and cheap/free.

That is probably a good idea but there are places where daycare is free and there's no evidence it makes a difference.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by ElevenLathe on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:29PM (#35603071)
The childcare is free, but what about the rent?
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by jebagu on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:36PM (#35603166)
Finland challenges this line of reasoning. Wealthy, safe, some of the best social benefits in the world for raising children. What one would think of as the the ideal situation for having children. Their birth rate is tanking.
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by ertian on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:42PM (#35603258)
This might be affecting the number of children a couple has (probably is, in fact), but I doubt people factor it in to their decision to have a kid or not. I had absolutely no idea what day care or diapers cost before I had a kid. It's hard for me to picture a young couple approaching it that way.
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by bluGill on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:56PM (#35603436)
> As it stands today, having children places an unbearably high social and financial strain on people. Suburbs have been just one solution to the problem but there are others.

Yet Suburbs are the only ones I see that work. If you are thinking about having kids in the US move to the suburbs soon. Cities are not setup for you. Schools in the city are considered bad for a reason. Even if you can afford private schools, the parks are more sculpre gardens instead of swing sets. Everyone talks about the theator scene in the cities, but most of the shows wouldn't interest a child (most are not X rated). Many cities lack cheap places to eat - $40/person isn't too bad for one person, but when you have a few kids with you that price is not affordable often. How many places don't allow kids at all - not many in the suburbs, but somewhat common in the city. In the suburb you just buy a bigger car and everyone gets around - the big car won't fit in the city well, and your other options is paying a lot more on public transit because odds are there isn't a family pass, so the big car is probably cheaper.

The above is US specific (probably Canada too). I know there are a number of people from not US reading this who will tell me how it works in their city. I hope city residents read those replies and make changes before they need them.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by unethical_ban on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:20PM (#35603707)
> the big car won't fit in the city well, and your other options is paying a lot more on public transit because odds are there isn't a family pass, so the big car is probably cheaper.

The TCO for a car is thousands of dollars per year. Granted the US only has three or four cities that come close to facilitating carless society, but in those cities, I doubt public transit costs $5000 a year or more.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by bluGill on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:00PM (#35605778)
If you are buying a new car every 3 years the $5000year price for a car is reasonable, but cars last for 15 years and so the total lifetime costs average out to less, and if you buy a used car you costs are much less. My cars are down to more like $2000/year now.

$100/month 12 month (2 parents + 3 kids). Of course it depends on where you live, but $100/month per person is a normal price for a monthly pass. If the kids are younger and riding with a parent the price is lower, but kids have places to go (particularity as teens!) without parents (which should be advantage of the city). When you consider the convenience of the car being ready to go when and where you want to go - unlike transit systems - it isn't hard to justify paying more (Read this as a rant about how useless most transit systems are in the US)

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by UtopiaPunk on Monday April 17, 2023 @02:24PM (#35604518)
North American style suburbs are artificially subsidized by cities and not sustainable for society. A series of policy decisions at all levels of government have artificially made the suburban lifestyle cheaper than it otherwise would be, but sooner or later, something has gotta give.

This is a good starting point on the subject, with many sources for more in-depth reading if one chooses: https://www.strongtowns.org/journal/2017/7/24/busting-4-comm...

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by bluGill on Monday April 17, 2023 @03:52PM (#35605665)
Strongtowns is cooking the math. Suburbs have existed for more than 100 years, and most do not fall for issues they claim.
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by medvezhenok on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:55PM (#35609425)
Suburbs 100 years ago did not have roads to maintain, communal sewers, and other amenities that we expect today. Suburbs 100 years ago were more like the dachas/summer houses people have in Russia - no running water, no electricity, outhouse instead of a plumbed bathroom, no fire/medical services... etc.

Sure, under that model they are definitely sustainable.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by bluGill on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @08:13AM (#35612929)
Over the last 100 years those suburbs have added all of your list, plus parks (which were not common 100 years ago), internet, cable tv, phone.

Which just goes road prove they are sustaining themselves.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by medvezhenok on Tuesday April 18, 2023 @05:03PM (#35620131)
That doesn't prove anything.

I could buy many things for myself by putting them on my credit card - that doesn't make my spending habits sustainable.

The whole point of strong towns is that the Government financed the projects but not the maintenance, and that the suburbs can't afford the maintenance bills (at least some of them) under the current tax regime.

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by mensetmanusman on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:48PM (#35609386)
Find a city that has above replacement levels of fertility, then define whether population sustainability is suitable for society. Thinking deeply about this may change opinions.
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by djtango on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:20PM (#35602953)
Lack a source but for many this will be the first generation in a long time where today's new parents will be unable to provide an equal or better quality of life to their children - especially in big urban centers which have seen the full effects of stratification. Space and resources are big weights in a "QoL" function.
Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by Teknoman117 on Monday April 17, 2023 @04:25PM (#35606093)
It's nutty.

I make more than my dad did when he retired, yet, if I were to have kids today I could not provide the lifestyle to them that I had as a kid. And he certainly didn't make what he did at retirement when I was a child. If I had a dual income household, there would be the money to do it, but the kids would lose out on something that I considered a crucial part of my upbringing - a full time parent.

But, the perspective here is that I (and many of the people on this site) work in one of the few remaining well paying professions, whereas my dad was in a "well paying" but not "top paying" field.

It just can't be sustainable...

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by gilmore606 on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:18PM (#35603696)
Calhoun's rat paradise experiment doesn't replicate, as Gwern helpfully discovered for us:

https://www.gwern.net/Mouse-Utopia

Re:The Toxic Reality of a Post-Familial Society by Euphorbium on Monday April 17, 2023 @03:38PM (#35605475)
Stop quoting behavioral sink, it has been thoroughly debunked. https://gwern.net/mouse-utopia