Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video]
by jcranmer on Monday April 17, 2023 @10:49AM
(#35601606)
It's permissible to create a copy for personal use, so long as you don't distribute the copy. Copyright is primarily about distribution of copies, not the making of copies themselves.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Right but that's a small fig leaf for the people who get sued over this who very much are going beyond personal use. Circling back to it's fine to make a policy argument but dumb to flout the law.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video]
by bdowling on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:57PM
(#35603450)
No, copyright law is about the exclusive right to make copies, among other rights. In US law this is 17 USC 106.
The reason making a single copy for personal use is generally considered permissible is because: (1) it may be fair use under 17 USC 107, (2) the copyright owner will probably never find out, and (3) even if the copyright owner found out it probably won’t sue over one copy.
Didn't the DMCA make bypassing copy protections illegal?
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video]
by brokenmachine on Thursday April 20, 2023 @01:42AM
(#35636793)
ROMs don't generally have copy protection though, do they? I guess arcade ones do.
No, but usually the physical media (DVD / BluRay / Cartridge) does. The issue comes in how do you legally create the Rom without bypassing copy protections.
Re:Nintendo Is Taking Down My Videos [video]
by Mindwipe on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:08PM
(#35603580)
Not in all territories it isn't.
https://www.gov.uk/government/news/quashing-of-private-copyi...