> It sounds like the truth is whatever a human judge can be convinced into deciding is true.

I mean, that’s literally the judges job. It’s why they are called a judge. They make a judgement as to where the truth lies, and where the law lies (except for issues that are delegated to a jury, in which case the jury is responsible for determining the factual record).

But, yes, judges make judgements and a lot of the “well, technically” semantic games that people play will be met with an annoyed scowl and a negative opinion (but, critically not all semantic games; there are some semantic differences that are of critical importance to a judge)