News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by rqtwteye on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:11PM (#35572739)
I have seen videos where they trained dogs or had adopted rescue cats. I think a lot of prisoners would do way better if they got a chance to feel like a productive member of society. Them being firefighters in California wildfires comes to mind too.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by LambdaComplex on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:42PM (#35573168)
> Them being firefighters in California wildfires comes to mind too

Those are the ones that aren't allowed to work as firefighters once they're out of prison due to their criminal records, right?

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by anonporridge on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:48PM (#35573243)
Correct. It's not rehabilitation or job training, it's legal slave labor to do one of the most dangerous jobs we have, as explicitly allowed for by the 13th Amendment of the Constitution.

The United States still has legal slavery, just with extra steps.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by hkt on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:59PM (#35573360)
> just with extra steps

I thought the whole thing here was that for inmates, there weren't any extra steps?

I'll confess to not knowing much about this though (I'm not American)

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by hirsin on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:04PM (#35573417)
The extra steps are the ones between them being a free person and an inmate.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by anonporridge on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:15PM (#35573525)
Like making loitering a crime and then using police and prosecutor discretion to selectively enforce said crime only against poor minorities.

And like magic! You can re-enslave the people who were 'freed'.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by pb7 on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:45PM (#35573805)
Except no one is forcing them, they choose to do it because it gives them purpose.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by DangitBobby on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:32AM (#35577616)
Yes, I've heard that these positions are highly sought after and gives the _volunteers_ a sense of purpose, but it gives some people living comfortably outside of prison icky feelings about consent. I have no doubt prisoners would have some choice words for people in this comment section who would choose to take the option away from them.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by t-3 on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:29AM (#35578146)
I highly doubt they "volunteer" for a sense of purpose. It's almost certainly paid labor (albeit very cheap compared to even minimum wage), but probably relatively well-paid for a prison job and offering opportunities to obtain outside food and contraband.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by 8ytecoder on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:28PM (#35573640)
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by rqtwteye on Friday April 14, 2023 @08:20PM (#35576430)
I didn’t know that part. That’s pretty dumb. But in general I would like the idea if they could get that work after.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by capableweb on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:14PM (#35572768)
There is generally two types of prisons in the world, one is "Punish"/"Keep rest of the world safe" prisons, and the other is "Rehabilitation" prisons. The latter tries to make people be able to re-integrate after finishing the sentence, while the first doesn't care as long as they are imprisoned and kept away from the rest of "normal folks". Convincing people that rehabilitation is possible is a huge job, and I don't see that happening in the US anytime soon.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by diveandfight on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:41PM (#35573158)
Rather than types, maybe those qualities are more like ends on a spectrum?
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by rqtwteye on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:16PM (#35574868)
It's a very US thing to present issues as one side or the other, "Left or Right", "Capitalist or Socialist" with nothing between. In reality almost everything is on a (multi-dimensional) spectrum with a lot of nuance. This binary thinking is reinforced by TV and social media and is tearing the country apart.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by strken on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:00PM (#35575364)
Maybe even axes on a graph, where prisons strive to be on the Pareto front at different points.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by quacked on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:47PM (#35573227)
"Rehabilitation" is in many cases a misnomer. There's a difference between Rehabilitating someone who developed a problem and Habilitating someone who was never taught to think with a moral compass. People in the US could be convinced to get behind major prison reform if the reformers weren't so insistent on representing every felon as Jean Valjean.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by at_a_remove on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:04PM (#35573428)
I was watching an interesting video of a young woman who had just gotten a DUI. She didn't understand why it was a "thing" because she hadn't hit anyone. She managed to argue herself into two months in the county jail because she didn't understand and did not want to understand. She also tried, briefly, to make a case that she was too attractive for prison. Upon questioning, it was fairly clear that she would go on to reoffend.

I saw another video of five teens who liked throwing heavy rocks over a busy overpass. They had done this more than once. Of course, they ended up killing someone, after which text messages were exchanged with much LOL and LFMOA and HAHAHA. Apparently, they had pre-planned some kind of defense where everyone would agree that the eldest of the bunch was the only one throwing the rocks, as well. The four youngest got a year of probation. The eldest got three and a quarter years in prison. He's out and the rest are long clear of their probation.

I am unsure what could be done to rehabilitate these individuals rather than merely coercing lip service from them.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by throwway120385 on Friday April 14, 2023 @03:31PM (#35573666)
I am equally unsure. But I believe we have a responsibility to try to help the weakest members of our society become better people, and if that means locking them up for a while and trying to teach them a moral compass that's what we should try even if it's doomed to failure. It can't be any worse than what we're currently doing.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by AlbertCory on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:49PM (#35575244)
Psychopathic individuals mainly use therapy as post-graduate training in how to simulate human emotion. Just ask some shrinks. They don't learn a moral compass; they learn how to pretend they have one.

Of course, not all inmates are psychopathic, but 15-25% manifest those traits, according to https://www.apa.org/monitor/2022/03/ce-corner-psychopathy.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by strken on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:29PM (#35576152)
How meaningful is it to manifest psychopathic trait to a clinically significant degree? If you look at them, they include impulsivity, risk taking, and violence. Of course prisoners will be impulsive, take risks, and/or be violent! That's how a lot of them end up in prison! There is something of a jump from there to the pop science understanding of psychopathy.

It's not clear that everyone who displays some of those traits is going to display all the others, that a pattern of risky violence means someone is automatically beyond help, that the stats on psychopaths aren't including lots of people with other underlying problems that fully explain their behaviour, or that anyone else who goes to a therapist is doing anything radically different from simulating normal human behaviour.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by AlbertCory on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:39PM (#35576226)
> the pop science understanding of psychopathy

the reference I gave is not pop science.

Your debunking and pooh-pooh'ing is unpersuasive. This is a professional association publishing that, and they do have shrinks in prison.

"About 1.2% of U.S. adult men and 0.3% to 0.7% of U.S. adult women are considered to have clinically significant levels of psychopathic traits. Those numbers rise exponentially in prison, where 15% to 25% of inmates show these characteristics (Burton, B., & Saleh, F. M., Psychiatric Times, Vol. 37, No. 10, 2020). "

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by strken on Monday April 17, 2023 @12:48AM (#35596944)
I'm not debunking anything, I'm asking how meaningful manifesting traits to a "clinically significant" level actually is. If I shoot my neighbour's dog in broad daylight then show no remorse it's probably manifesting psychopathic traits to a clinically significant degree, but it doesn't mean it would be totally worthless to send me to a psychiatrist. It may not even mean that I meet the threshold to be diagnosed as an actual psychopath, under whatever contorted DSM-V diagnosis it currently sits.

Your reference has no bearing on the answer to that question and in fact notes that 30% of the population display some traits of psychopathy, which is the entire point here. If you squint hard enough, you can label 30% of the population as psychopaths; if you're also convinced it's useless to send them to therapy, you can use the label to deny them mental health care and stick them in prison.

I'm worried that a broad and underspecified definition of psychopathy combines with an overstated inability to treat them, in a way that is morally bankrupt and tantamount to just giving up.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by throwway120385 on Monday April 17, 2023 @01:43PM (#35604001)
I don't get it. Are you advocating throwing the baby out with the bath water? Just because the 15-25% exist doesn't mean we can't try to teach the 75% how to exist in society without breaking the rules. And it also doesn't preclude us from giving them something other than a swift kick in the ass. Kicking your ass seems to be the only thing the criminal justice system in the US does these days.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by quacked on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:54AM (#35580653)
"Two social workers walk past a man lying beaten and bloody on the ground, moaning for help. One turns to the other and says 'My God, whoever did this needs our help.'"

The weakest in society are those who are taken advantage of by the morally bankrupt, not the morally bankrupt themselves.

However, I agree that what we are currently doing is worse than almost every alternative.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by noirscape on Friday April 14, 2023 @04:05PM (#35574005)
General (not targeted) guidance counseling once they're out of prison probably would help here. Just help to get them back on their feet for the woman. Regular checkups, seeing how she's doing, giving the indication someone cares about her. This can do a lot to help someone understand what they did wrong and can help them understand that being a part of society means thinking about others as well. (Chiefly, don't do this in a way that's denigrating to her as a person.)

Involve CPS with all the teenagers.

The woman probably had other things in her life that caused her to end up with that remorseless of a personality - granted I suspect a part of this might also just be the American general tendency to take rights as "fuck you got mine", instead of "we have to share this place together", which might be hard to deal with (assuming this is US).

The teenagers probably had inattentive parents or a bad school life, which turned them to doing shit that is pretty much harassing people that eventually would get someone killed. It sounds almost certain like there's secondary circumstances involved - petty theft is usually scared out (since teenagers tend to do it because of the "taboo", the fact that most kids don't see real consequences of their actions until then and finally that it's seen as the least egregious crime that isn't like... a speeding violation or a parking ticket), but if that defense is as you say, it sounds more deliberate and more deeply rooted.

Crimes are sometimes a symptom of other things, not the cause.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by quacked on Saturday April 15, 2023 @10:10AM (#35580777)
You are clearly well-meaning, but your suggestions indicate a lack of familiarity with the mindset and behaviors of people that become chronically involved with the criminal justice system.

You are not going to teach a mindless drunk driver by indicating to them, via a state-employed official, that "someone cares about them". You're not going to convince a teenager that hurting people is wrong by having them speak to a social worker with a caseload. Children learn their moral systems from years of active and passive indoctrination into their parents' and peers' culture. If you want to reorient someone's moral compass by instilling values that no one ever taught them, and are not present in the culture in which they live outside of prison, you're going to need something a hell of a lot more potent than regular appointments with a therapist.

> Crimes are sometimes a symptom of other things, not the cause.

Chronic criminality is the result of moral systems that are calibrated and reinforced by violent and uncivilized cultures. This goes doubly for "rich" criminals, who display their immoral behavior through war and the stock market. Reforming a petty criminal or a serial abuser is as difficult as reforming a corporate executive taking kickbacks. They don't see a problem with it.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by rqtwteye on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:19PM (#35574911)
"People in the US could be convinced to get behind major prison reform if the reformers weren't so insistent on representing every felon as Jean Valjean."

It's pretty crazy to blame the current situation on reformers. In reality it's the war on drugs and "tough on crime". I know a lot of normally reasonable people who think prisoners deserve to be raped in prison and don't deserve health care.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by Paul-Craft on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:42PM (#35575795)
Right. It's well known that Nixon started the "War on Drugs" as a way to target hippies and black people. And "tough on crime" has just led to people spending more time in prison in spite of falling crime rates: https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/news/2020/oct/1/new-study-sh...
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by kevviiinn on Friday April 14, 2023 @10:07PM (#35577014)
Gotta keep those private prisons full. We need more cheap and free labor!
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by quacked on Saturday April 15, 2023 @09:49AM (#35580612)
I did not say that the current situation was created by the reformers, merely that the existing US prison reform movements lack the support they need to move the needle because they are controlled by people who are far too broadly optimistic and sympathetic to prisoners.

I view prison reform as the most important--not among the most important, the most important--step in beginning to change modern US society for the better. I know many prison activists and was raised in a culture of people who volunteered in prisons and in legal efforts to reform prisons and assist prisoners. They are too sympathetic and the way they frame their cause reduces the amount of support they receive from the general public.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by wefarrell on Friday April 14, 2023 @05:56PM (#35575322)
Rehabilitation requires education and social services and once you start providing those resources to prisoners people question the logic of giving prisoners something for free that everyone else has to pay for. Why should a prisoner get access to college classes while a law abiding citizen has to pay tens of thousands of dollars? Of course it winds up saving the state money by decreasing recidivism, but it raises inconvenient questions.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by Ar-Curunir on Friday April 14, 2023 @06:09PM (#35575451)
The correct answer, of course, is that everyone should have access to basic educational and social services. This is unpopular with many in the US.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by kevviiinn on Friday April 14, 2023 @10:06PM (#35577003)
It's a great way for capital owners to keep workers fighting amongst themselves
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by 1270018080 on Friday April 14, 2023 @07:36PM (#35576201)
A solid 30% of the country doesn't even want people to have healthcare. There are fundamental issues that make the populace irredeemable ideologically. Of course if you could reprogram that 30% we'd be okay, but, like you said, good luck with that.
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by Fezzik on Saturday April 15, 2023 @12:26AM (#35577589)
In law this is often couched as ‘retribution’ vs ‘rehabilitation’. I’ve been out of law school for over a decade, but about ten years ago pretty much all the evidence was the retributive prisons/legal systems were awful (created more recidivists, were more expensive, had more conflict between staff and inmates, etc…).
Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by saithound on Saturday April 15, 2023 @02:39AM (#35578204)
As one of the people in the camp that firmly rejects rehabilitation: if you think that it's hard to convince me that rehabilitation is possible, I have bad news for you. Most of us don't care if it's possible or not: to get us on board, you'd have to convince us that rehabilitation is _just_, which is a much harder task. "We rehabilitated your rapist and integrated them into our society" is considered by many to be an affront to the victims, and the very opposite of justice.

If you were to convince me that it was 100% possible, and the rehabilitated criminals become productive members of our society, that would make us support it less, not more.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by jon-wood on Saturday April 15, 2023 @05:55AM (#35579112)
What if we reframe this from the extreme of a rapist, where I agree in many cases retribution needs to be an element of the sentence.

How about someone who’s been sentenced for stealing, which they did in order to feed their kids? They dropped out of high school, and have never held down a steady job. Do you genuinely believe it’s better to further smack them down with a criminal justice system that will prevent them getting a job in the future, rather than having them leave prison qualified to do something productive?

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by saithound on Sunday April 16, 2023 @12:51AM (#35587363)
> How about someone who’s been sentenced for stealing, which they did in order to feed their kids?

Current valid defenses against a charge of larceny include amking an honest mistake, being mentally incapacitated, and having the intention to restore. If you believe that "immediate physical need even without an intention to restore" should be a valid defense against this criminal charge as well, I'm with you. I don't think we disagree on that. The law does, but it's much easier to convince people that certain specific acts should not be considered criminal than to convince them of the justness of rehabilitating actual criminals.

So, as far as I can tell, such examples have no bearing on the question of rehabilitation at all: why would we need to rehabilitate somebody who's not guilty in the first place?!

If somebody is guilty of a crime, however, how could eventually letting a perpetrator return to society, get a job and do something productive _not_ be a further unjust act against the victim?

Almost everybody agrees that the state helping perpetrators of a crime to get revenge on their victims would be twisted and heinous. I'm sure you agree too.

But living well is the best revenge, and that's exactly what rehabilitation is: preparing an incarcerated offender to live well (function as a law-abiding member of the society) after their release, and by that further torment their victims.

Re:Inmates in a Brazil prison shorten their sentences by wri... by jeffwask on Friday April 14, 2023 @02:34PM (#35573081)
He had a job running the commissary but even that only filled so much time. He would have loved anything that allowed him to learn a skill he could have used on release.