There is a phenomenon in history where people have identified with their artifacts: in the machine age humans were seen as but advanced machines, in the computer age we became advanced computers. No doubt there is now a budding trend to see us as hardly anything more than advanced LLMs...
None of these perspectives were ever totally wrong however, only somewhat reductionist.
I also think we're more than just a LLM, but not for the hardware in the brain, it's the rich environment and efficient body shape that helps us develop that edge. We can be more than language models because we learn from our own experiences in the world and society.
I expect future AI agents will also be more than LLMs, they can get agentified, embodied and embedded. They can have feedback loops to learn from. Access to experience is the key to being more than "just a LLM".
For others like me who have an issue with that mindset it's not a problem: dogs have a fantastic sense of smell, and octopuses may well be more intelligent than most us in some aspects. We don't need to be the best at everything to have value in ourselves, as humans.
The main problem we should be focusing on (beyond letting AI fulfilling it's full potential as a useful tool) is how to prevent some future AI to also inherit our selfish conceit which might give it the idea that humans are actually an impediment to its own development.
I get where this is coming from, but as someone who recently did an extensive systematic literature review: you benefit from doing the work, not from getting an automatic summary. It's the little details you keep stumbling upon, that make you think "Wait a second!", that are really important. You miss them the first 100 times you come across them, but by the 101st time, you have learned something.
LLMs can help with those early reads and save some time and get you into the deep reading sooner with more context. If during the deep reading you would normally jump back to a previous section to check something, it's likely faster and easier to just have a conversation with the paper (enabled with an LLM). The same would be true for that final read where you're doing logical checks.
If you use an LLM to give you a summary and leave it at that, you'll have done the equivalent of the first pass through a paper. That could be enough for you to know you want to filter it out and not do a deep reading, but you'll lose the benefits of the deeper reading. It seems like there are clear benefits and areas where LLMs can help improve that current paper reading process but if you skip (instead of just replacing with a more efficient LLM alternative) major parts of that process you'll get less out of it than you would without skipping those steps.
But having an extensive summary or table of contents generated for you to begin your review? Priceless and would have saved me so much time especially on the junk papers. There was a demo recently at work where they built a pipeline to do literature reviews (topic was not scientific, more data analysis) and generate a report. It was genuinely incredible.
It's because it shattered every AI engineer. The work they were previously doing was over night made irrelevant.
Hyped, feared, praised, mocked. Whatever bias it ends up with depends on which part of the Internet gets added to the training corpus. Reddit, Twitter, YouTube transcripts, news articles, HN, academic papers - they all have a different range of viewpoints, and a different typical take on LLMs.
It's going to be interesting, to say the least.
- conducting literature reviews (stay sane while researching LLMs!)
- Talking to textbooks / AI teaching assistants
- language learning with a companion tailored to your level and interested
LLMs are so hyped and written about these days that it would be hilarious if the next version of GPT trained on todays internet would be biased towards praising itself