Re:Make Something Wonderful – Steve Jobs in his own words
by chrisweekly on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:19PM
(#35529032)
Good points.
Nit / correction (for helpfulness not pedantry)
tenant: renter or occupant vs tenet: guiding principle
Re:Make Something Wonderful – Steve Jobs in his own words
by kitsunesoba on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:56PM
(#35529691)
Nice catch, fixed.
Re:Make Something Wonderful – Steve Jobs in his own words
by sangnoir on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:46PM
(#35529496)
> Most people I think aren't opposed to well designed UI that incorporates a central tenant of Jobs', which is that design is functionality and not purely visual
Jobs loved skeuomorpism, which isn't inherently bad, but having iOS UI elements reproduce the stitching from seats in his private jet skews close to "purely visual". Also, the (early) iOS date picker was unforgivable - I assume Jobs was aware of its existence & approved of its rubber-stamp-like, user-hostile skeuomorphic design
Re:Make Something Wonderful – Steve Jobs in his own words
by kitsunesoba on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:57PM
(#35529710)
Extreme skeuomorphism I would agree is purely visual, but I think there’s a lot of functional value in buttons looking like buttons and other visual indicators of function.
There's a fair chance I've misread the situation, but I don't think it's good taste and style is what's being pushed back against in these situations. It's all of the other things that so often get bundled with glossy UI — aesthetics-above-all-else design, UI as branding, gratuitous amounts of badly written analytics JS added by non-engineers, NIH syndrome, trend chasing, etc.
Most people I think aren't opposed to well designed UI that incorporates a central tenant of Jobs', which is that design is functionality and not purely visual, but this is staggeringly unusual to the point that something idiosyncratic but simplistic (like the HN UI) is a safer bet.