We didn’t mask and isolate because 0.3% of Americans died. We did it so that only 0.3% of Americans would die.
I’m not sure how the response to the drug epidemic and the infectious respiratory pandemic could be ‘consistent’.
With respect to how the drug epidemic and the pandemic are compared: my point was that a majority of people were compelled to comply in the case of the pandemic for the greater good, so it is not unreasonable to compel a small minority of people to comply for the greater good. In both cases, those who are compelled to comply are theoretically receiving advice and services that are for their own good according to science and common sense.
I also recognize that “homelessness” is a catch-all phrase that is abused, and that roughly half of the homeless are not suffering from mental illness or drug addiction. So the solutions to these problems are distinct.
My only appeal to those reading this is to consider the big picture and to consider solutions that are best for all of society. This is a democratic approach.
Are you equating wearing a small piece of cloth -- something all of us are already legally required to do outdoors -- with jailing and forced treatment of the homeless?
The GP's question was obviously baiting but also follows logically.
The vast majority of homeless are not homeless by choice. Homeless people turn down shelters because shelters aren't homes, and are often legitimately worse than being outside. Programs which have offered the homeless real homes, with privacy, the ability to safely store belongings and keep pets, and the ability to decorate, cook, and sleep in quiet, have not had any difficulty filling those homes, but these programs are few and far between (none exist in the US, that I know of).
The solution to homelessness is homes, period. Not shelters, homes. Nothing else will work. Mental health treatment is utterly ineffective when the patients are suffering the ongoing trauma of homelessness, and any system which places mental health as a prerequisite to having a home will not work.
As such, whatever forceful mental health treatment you're proposing as a solution to your fear of the homeless, is not going to actually solve your problem. If the homeless are removed from the streets and forcibly medicated, they'll end up in the same spot doing the same thing as soon as they're dumped back into the world without any real help.
If you actually want a solution that works, you're going to have to grow a little compassion and start trying to actually help the homeless instead of only thinking about how to keep yourself safe from the homeless.
I keep hearing that homeless avoid shelters because of how dangerous the people are there[1]. And that’s a legitimate point. But then people completely wipe that point from their memory when they say “Just move these people to apartments, there will be no problem.”
If other homeless are saying that many of these individuals are too dangerous to be around, we shouldn’t be surprised if people who live in apartments feel the same way.
[1] https://www.npr.org/2012/12/06/166666265/why-some-homeless-c...
From your [1].
The reasoning is that dangerous people exist in homeless shelters NOT because those people are homeless, but because people can exist who want to take advantage of homeless people, whether those people are homeless themselves or not.
Your conclusion that homeless people living in apartments can cause the same reaction based on their previous homelessness and no other quality isn't a logical one.
Well, I didn't say that. That's part of the problem but it's not the whole problem.
In the interview you quoted, the word "dangerous" is used once:
PIRTLE: Part of the reason was, you know, the paranoia and the fear of large groups of people that comes along with schizophrenia, but part of the reason was, and I think this is more generally the case with people, is that you hear a lot of terrible things about shelters, that shelters are dangerous places, that they're full of drugs and drug dealers, that people will steal your shoes, and there's bedbugs and body lice.
And yeah, unfortunately a lot of those things are true.
It's a bit of a stretch to call that evidence of your position, but I'll grant the point and move on I guess.
The interview also says:
PIRTLE: Oh yes, there's - I don't want to say that all shelters are like that. There's a lot of very good shelters in this country. But there are a lot of big warehouses that are just places where we stick people at night and we really don't have any regard for how they live there.
...and:
PIRTLE: I spent most of my time homeless out on the street. It wasn't until the very end of my homelessness that I ended up in a shelter. And I found out that a lot of what I was afraid of was true. I never found out what a body louse was until I got into the shelter. You know, I had my shoes stolen, just like people said you get your shoes stolen, although I will say that there were three people in the shelter who offered to give me a pair of shoes after that happened.
So there is a sense of community there. I don't want to give the impression that everyone in the shelter is bad. But you have a lot of people with a lot of problems, and so when you cram them all together, you just have one big problem. That's why I'm a big fan of smaller, scattered-sized shelters, where people can get more focus on what they need to get help.
Note that the "danger" here isn't "you're going to get murdered", it's theft--a predictable consequence of not having any place to store your personal belongings when you can't actively protect them.
And then there's this part which bears reiterating: But you have a lot of people with a lot of problems, and so when you cram them all together, you just have one big problem.
Do you see why maybe putting people into apartments might actually be a partial solution to this problem?
And you'll note, I'm not actually saying we put them in apartments right next to pre-existing tenants. My actual suggestion would be to build new housing, and repurpose or rebuild unused office and retail space. There's clearly a shortage of housing, and that shortage is being maintained because it serves to inflate housing prices, making a few people rich. If there's anything there should be an excess of, it's basic needs like homes.
So it starts to sound like you're responding to a straw man argument I didn't make, based on an interview that you read very selectively.
If you're familiar with the situation, you know that homeless frequently talk about the dangerous nature of shelters as a reason why they don't want to stay there. I hope that any discussion about the issue would at least be aware of that. The article I picked was just the first one that come up on Google in case people were new to the situation and didn't know much about it, but there are plenty of others you can find with even a quick search:
> Likewise, respondents said they found it hard to coexist with others battling mental health issues at the shelters and that it sometimes led to issues such as fights, which made others feel unsafe.[1].
**
> But shelter beds seldom keep pace with need. And some people, like Carver, avoid shelters even when they are available. They say they feel unsafe and uncomfortable in the shelters, or they impose rules they can’t follow.[2]
**
> They refuse to go back because they feel unsafe in them. Whether due to mere paranoia caused by an individual's unfortunate battle with mental illness or is a legitimate take on the reality of the conditions within the homeless shelter itself, the feeling of unsafety is as real as it gets. Some individuals site witnessing violence, drug solicitation, or theft as reasons it is unsafe to stay.[3] __________________
> And you'll note, I'm not actually saying we put them in apartments right next to pre-existing tenants.
That's the way it is being implemented cities trying the "housing first" approach, though, and with predictable results (long time residents having to move as there's a sharp increase in crime and violence in the building).
[1] https://www.desmoinesregister.com/story/news/local/des-moine... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/society/2022/nov/02/unhoused-peo... [3] https://caufsociety.com/why-the-homeless-refuse-help/
If you're familiar with the post you're responding to, you know that I didn't disagree with that. How many times are you going to continue accusing me of this straw man argument? I've already told you that's not what I'm disagreeing with.
You go on to quote a bunch of support for my assertion that shelters aren't homes. People herded into warehouses like cattle and forced into close proximity with no privacy get into fights? Why is that surprising to anyone?
> > And you'll note, I'm not actually saying we put them in apartments right next to pre-existing tenants.
> That's the way it is being implemented cities trying the "housing first" approach, though, and with predictable results (long time residents having to move as there's a sharp increase in crime and violence in the building).
There are a bunch of reasons why that's happening: among them a refusal to re-purpose office and retail spaces which would be farther from existing residential areas, and intentional poor implementations of these programs by political interests so they can say they don't work.
Failures of a poor implementation vaguely related to what I'm actually suggesting, aren't actually criticisms of my suggestion.
From what I've looked up, places with much more established shelter programs and capacity than SF have fewer problems than SF. It makes zero sense to refuse to even start there. Personally, I would start with shelters and with programs to try to prevent homelessness in the first place; the input funnel is the key variable here, because as you mention, everything else becomes much harder after that.
No. Free basic homes for everyone is exactly what I want.
> It is ludicrously easy to attack politically otherwise ("you're working two jobs to make rent for you and your family, and now they want to give these people a free home that's new and nicer than your crappy old apartment!"), and you know the American right would rip it to shreds, given they already see social security/medicare as too expensive.
Easy attacks have easy solutions. Nobody should have to work two jobs to make rent, and tiered aid should exist for people who aren't already homeless such that that isn't necessary (in addition to addressing income disparities). Nobody is proposing we give the homeless free new homes and give the barely-homed nothing.
> there's also the issue of "they don't wanna do things that way, so we're gonna give them nicer things; meanwhile, all the rest of you should keep following the laws kthx."
I'm not even sure this narrative is coherent. Is the implication that the homeless are lawbreakers and therefore deserve to be punished... with homelessness?
> We need to figure out how to reintegrate people into society without giving up on the ideas of that society in the first place.
No, we don't. Which idea exactly are you talking about? If there is some idea of our society that is opposed to the idea that humans deserve to have their basic needs met, I'm pretty on board with changing the idea of our society.
> From what I've looked up, places with much more established shelter programs and capacity than SF have fewer problems than SF. It makes zero sense to refuse to even start there.
Who's refusing to even start there? You won't hear any perfect solution fallacies[1] from me.
But I'm fully on board with imperfect solutions when better solutions aren't available, but your post seems to be arguing that we shouldn't even try the better solutions, because people might object. It's a weird circular argument: we're opposed to trying giving people homes because people might be opposed to it? We need to change minds, which is why I'm having this conversation.
I have seen protestors who draw a line in the sand at "free good housing for everyone" (sometimes piling on even more things like "abolish capitalism" for even less feasibility) and fight against any solution short of that. And the only people who would win, politically, from that are the right-wingers who want to deploy cops against the homeless and push them out of town and out of sight. Enough people start to lose patience with the lack of action that they vote with the assholes since nobody else is trying anything.
It's not all the way there, but look at the last mayoral election in Los Angeles: two candidates who were both fairly pro-police and pro-shelter and pro-encampment-clearing, despite the efforts of the more radical protestors. If those efforts were to get blocked by protests from the left, I think people would only swing further right on that issue, since both of the final candidates were already far more active on the issue in their platform than in previous elections.
So let them complain! Might as well try and do the things we want to do. They'll find something to complain about, regardlessly. A certain tan suit comes to mind.
I have a 70 year old family friend that owns a farm, 4th generation of his family to own the farm. it butts up to the Freeway. His farm is less than 1/4 a mile outside a large (~200k) city limits on the west coast.
He has an encampment of 30 or so homeless people living on his land. (A spot set aside for nature by the county, so its wooded, not actively farmed). this is about 200 yards from his house. In a typical day, 15 or so semis' and old motorhomes pull over along the freeway offramp, to buy/sell meth. They cut down the trees, set fires to warm themselves, wander trough his property, have stolen countless tools, scrap metal, diesel fuel, etc from him. Basically a large tent/tarp city, with human waste, needles, stolen bikes/cars, (well, stolen everything) Its also caused a huge influx of rats, coyotes, and other scavengers.
The County Sheriff has told him they no longer respond to trespassing and vandalism calls, and to just file a report. (they are overwhelmed with them) His 68 year old wife will no longer ride her horse on that half of the farm, she is scared of them, and if their dogs charge at her horses again they might spook them and cause her to get really hurt.
One time, before they said no more trespassing calls, the sheriff did tell them to leave, they moved their camp from the trees, to right alongside the freeway, which is owned by the state dept of transportation. they couldn't do anything then, since it was state land, and they moved back the next week.
once they do clear out, because its private property, he is solely responsible for the cleanup costs, including the human waste, needles, stolen abandoned cars, etc. He could also be fined by the state for cutting down trees, etc, in an area that is supposed to be set aside for nature. (even though he did not do it)
I understand your ideas, And I am all for building them all homes. I am all for compassion, empathy, and helping out those that are less fortunate, and need help. But if it was funded, today, 100%, that would be 12-18 months to build the homes.
There are solutions that need to be done now. And there are solutions that need to be done long term as well. We should be doing all the things, not just waiting for the one perfect thing to be put in place.
All I'm doing is addressing the only solution which is actually going to solve the problem in the long run. There remains a persistent refusal to talk about giving homeless people homes. Literally not a single response to my post has seriously engaged with the idea.
Somewhere around 53% of homeless people are employed, part or full time.
40% of people were employed in the same year they became homeless.
Definitely feels like a safety net issue and not a "homelessness is entirely a mental illness issue".
https://bfi.uchicago.edu/insight/finding/learning-about-home...
This one is close to what you're describing:
https://www.lihihousing.org/tinyhouses
(Consider donating!)
These tiny house villages are real tiny homes, providing privacy & dignity.
And you're right about people preferring anything over a shelter:
"Some of the people we spoke with told us that if given a choice between staying in a nearby homeless shelter or spending their nights in a tent, they will choose the tent" (https://www.krem.com/article/money/economy/boomtown-inland-n...)
A tiny house in a small-by-design village is a better solution than a tent in a large encampment or shelter.
I'm going to do more research on their finances, but if nothing bad comes up I'll probably move a bunch of my donation budget to them.
https://www.huduser.gov/portal/pdredge/pdr-edge-inpractice-0....
Nonsense. Absolute, utter nonsense. I'm not sure why we are all of a sudden rewriting history.
100% of Americans were asked to comply with a range of public health directives. Actual enforcement and compulsion of the public ranged from non-existent (In most of the country) to symbolic (In a few coastal cities).
A significant fraction[1] loudly, and very prominently refused to comply. They got their way.
An even bigger fraction complied in an incredibly half-assed manner. As of today, a mere 16% of the US population has had an updated booster vaccine. Only 70% of the population has completed the first vaccination series (But hey, 81% got their first shot, so at least that's something...)
[1] Much of that same fraction, of course, has no issue with inflicting involuntary mental health treatment - because it's directed at other people.
Because history was being re-written in real-time, so people stopped being compliant.
People started the pandemic voluntarily washing products they brought into their homes for crying out loud. Your facts agree: 81% got the initial vaccine, because people thought it would mean something.
This seems a bit of a rewrite itself. A large portion of the american work force was told get in line or find a new way to feed and house your family.
Some people like to helpfully point out that's technically not forcing anything, but it's certainly a little bit more than politely asking.
Homeless people are rarely dangerous. They don't want trouble because they know the moment that happens the cops will descend on them for a bit of fun. They are easy prey for others.
It's also disingenuous to suggest that mental illness is the sole cause of homelessness, or that mental illness can always be alleviated with meds. Neither are true.
Wages in comparison to the cost of living is an issue we also talk about, but we never connect the two.
But some-as much as 45% of the adult population-felt very uncomfortable with having to comply, for whatever reason. But the rule was firm, and those who wouldn’t comply were shamed for their obstinance.
Over the same period, roughly 0.1% of the population died from drug overdoses, and roughly the same number are homeless with mental illness.
As a society, and morally and ethically sound individuals, we have to be consistent about what is best for public health.
Dangerous people living in squalor on public streets using dangerous drugs or failing to take the necessary medications to alleviate mental health disease is a public health problem-not an individual rights matter. It’s not fair to the people having to live near them, and it’s not fair to our society.