Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by coding123 on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:04AM
(#35520686)
Most scams seem to be chinese, indian these days. If there is a precedent that we can stop such out of country scammers, then vast swaths of the "scamming market" go away overnight.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by picture on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:10AM
(#35520725)
How do you know that the scammers are chinese or indian? Most stuff on amazon are just drop ship straight from aliexpress, but what information do you have that tells you who is doing the dropshipping?
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by Fatnino on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:45AM
(#35524383)
You can glance at a listing and just know it's Chinese. They use an odd font for English and do this thing where they make text headers by surrounding words with square-round brackets that nobody outside of China uses.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by gscott on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:24AM
(#35520814)
The ftc gets keep the money they collect. They can't collect anything on chinese companies so best to go after American ones only. I was shopping for outdoor fireplaces on Amazon and looking at the reviews. Interesting that the reviews were for slitherin house harry potter banners rather than the fireplace I was looking at.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by explaininjs on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:49AM
(#35520982)
It's a joke, I wasn't the downvoter. The joke being that's the mechanism that would need to be in effect for dividing fine by market cap to make any sense.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by costco on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @11:56AM
(#35526989)
Given that total FTC spending is only $400 million wouldn't it be pretty easy for a group of like minded businessmen to exhaust their litigation budget?
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by drstewart on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:31AM
(#35520859)
No, but we should arrest Telegram employees for any terrorist plots that are coordinated on their platform (and any other encrypted communication apps) for allowing that behavior
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by cycomanic on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:35AM
(#35520887)
There is a significant difference though. Amazon is not just providing a communication platform, they take a significant cut of the money being made here, so I would argue they are an associate to the fraught (let's not even talk about all the other ways that they are often part of the deal).
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by threatofrain on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:48AM
(#35520971)
There is no requirement that we create a sweeping policy which unites both Amazon and Telegram into the same regulatory conversation.
But you would have us think that if we're not willing to make the policy tradeoff of privacy for terrorism mitigation on Telegram, then we also ought not make the tradeoff of higher regulatory burden for consumer confidence in big marketplaces.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by heavyset_go on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:56AM
(#35521014)
If Telegram management were knowingly letting terrorists plot attacks on their platform, they should definitely be held accountable.
Similarly, if Amazon management were knowingly letting scammers scam innocent people on their platform, they should definitely be held accountable.
We're at a point where you can use free automation to tell if an Amazon listing has fake reviews, yet Amazon sits there with their thumbs up their asses as millions of people are harmed by blatant scams on their platform. You can even report obvious scams and Amazon does nothing about it.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by josephcsible on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:09AM
(#35520716)
When you get caught committing fraud to help sell something, the fine should be 100% of the revenue earned from selling that thing for the whole time you were committing the fraud.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by LegitShady on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:37AM
(#35520907)
when you get caught committing fraud for big dollars like that, people should go to jail. Personal culpability will be more of a deterrent than corporate liability. The people who made that decision should be facing jail time.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by parineum on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:33AM
(#35521215)
> Personal culpability will be more of a deterrent than corporate liability. The people who made that decision should be facing jail time.
I'm not certain that this is not already the case. At the very least, it is the case for more serious crimes. It is, however, pretty difficult to prove.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by heavyset_go on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:53AM
(#35520997)
I wish there was a way for them to go after Amazon for running a service with the intention of it being abused instead of hiding behind S230 and blaming users for the blatant scams they do nothing about even when they're reported to them.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by heavyset_go on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:03AM
(#35521787)
I've actually been doing exactly that for more than 3 years[1].
Looking at that post, it is still the case 3+ years later that it is nearly impossible to report fraudulent listings and sellers to Amazon as a customer. It's literally easier to contact the FTC about it.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by BonoboIO on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @12:59AM
(#35521029)
Not mentioned in the article, but it’s not uncommon that companies bribe Amazon employees to look the other way or help committing these frauds. Some people told me that they even protect you from being downranked.
They created variations of their best selling products so their new selling products get on the same page as the old ones. You have to look twice at the review for which product it is at the bottom.
It is still fraud and should be punished, but fining this is like a police officer fining you for parking on a disability spot, while a murder is happening 20 feet away.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by thaumasiotes on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @01:47AM
(#35521312)
Amazon itself is much worse about this practice than I assume The Bountiful Company was. They "unify" reviews for different DVD and Blu-Ray releases of the same film; they unify reviews for different translations of the same book... it's completely absurd.
Go to Amazon's page for any media item such as a movie or a TV show, and you'll see that all of the reviews take pains to indicate what product they're actually talking about, because everyone recognizes that all of the reviews are mostly displayed on products they're not related to.
This article explained the concept of the fraudulent behavior pretty well. But it didn't give even one example of two products that were inappropriately variated. As far as I learned from the article, the company being fined never did anything wrong!
> Later in 2020, Respondent began selling a new Nature’s Bounty Zinc Gummies product to Amazon for sale on Amazon.com. In August 2020, before the launch of the Zinc Gummies product, the Ecommerce Customer Development Director, wrote in an email:
>> [m]oving forward we are going to launch skus with variations that make sense: i.e. Zinc gummy with zinc tablet – gives the strongest opportunity to win from day 1 – gives relevancy, page 1 view, ... increased Conversation, and sales. We are seeing success with this strategy ....
> Respondent requested that Amazon create a variation relationship including Zinc Gummies, and two of Respondent’s established products, Nature’s Bounty Calcium Magnesium & Zinc caplets and Nature’s Bounty Zinc 50 mg caplets. The products had different formulations, including different amounts of the main ingredient or additional ingredients. The Zinc caplets were Amazon.com’s “#1 Best Seller in Zinc Mineral Supplements.”
So the theory seems to be that by listing their different zinc products as variations of each other, someone was getting defrauded.
But I don't see why "40mg zinc" caplets and "50mg zinc" caplets shouldn't be considered variations of each other (different amounts of the main ingredient!), and I also don't see why "40mg zinc" pills shouldn't be considered variations of "40mg zinc" gummy candies (different additional ingredients!). I don't see a big problem with the fact that Tylenol comes in a variation that includes a sedative ("Tylenol PM" - different active ingredients!). How is this different?
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by subroutine on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @03:51AM
(#35522128)
Imagine if they actually think that!
It's such a wild claim. It would be impressive if 99% of reviews were authentic. But they are saying 99% of their most popular products do not have a single unauthentic review.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by Fatnino on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @08:41AM
(#35524341)
I bought some shoes on Amazon. They were ok, nothing special, a few complaints. 8-9 months have passed and the shoes are on their last legs. I hop on Amazon to shop for similar but better shoes.
While I'm there, I figure I might as well leave an authentic review on the previous pair of shoes now that my use of them is complete.
I can't find any way to leave a review.
Anyway, I find it highly dubious that 99% of the reviews on Amazon could be authentic.
Re:FTC fines supplement maker $600k for 'review hijacking' A...
by subroutine on Tuesday April 11, 2023 @02:11AM
(#35521437)
Tactics like bait & switch, abuse of variations, and rebranding are so rampant on Amazon I wonder why Bountiful piqued the FCC's interest.
Every Amazon search is riddled with products gaming the platform. I just ran a quick search for "oscilloscope" and found 29 listings for the same 2 products...
Nature's Bounty, owned by Nestle (with a market cap of roughly $339 billion; https://stockanalysis.com/stocks/nsrgy/market-cap/ ), has to pay $600k, or .00017%, for scamming consumers.
Also, dividing a fine by market cap makes no sense.
I think this is the right amount to avoid that question.
But you would have us think that if we're not willing to make the policy tradeoff of privacy for terrorism mitigation on Telegram, then we also ought not make the tradeoff of higher regulatory burden for consumer confidence in big marketplaces.
Similarly, if Amazon management were knowingly letting scammers scam innocent people on their platform, they should definitely be held accountable.
We're at a point where you can use free automation to tell if an Amazon listing has fake reviews, yet Amazon sits there with their thumbs up their asses as millions of people are harmed by blatant scams on their platform. You can even report obvious scams and Amazon does nothing about it.
I'm not certain that this is not already the case. At the very least, it is the case for more serious crimes. It is, however, pretty difficult to prove.
Looking at that post, it is still the case 3+ years later that it is nearly impossible to report fraudulent listings and sellers to Amazon as a customer. It's literally easier to contact the FTC about it.
[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22388067
They created variations of their best selling products so their new selling products get on the same page as the old ones. You have to look twice at the review for which product it is at the bottom.
It is still fraud and should be punished, but fining this is like a police officer fining you for parking on a disability spot, while a murder is happening 20 feet away.
Go to Amazon's page for any media item such as a movie or a TV show, and you'll see that all of the reviews take pains to indicate what product they're actually talking about, because everyone recognizes that all of the reviews are mostly displayed on products they're not related to.
This article explained the concept of the fraudulent behavior pretty well. But it didn't give even one example of two products that were inappropriately variated. As far as I learned from the article, the company being fined never did anything wrong!
The complaint ( https://www.ftc.gov/system/files/ftc_gov/pdf/the_bountiful_c... ) is more detailed, but it doesn't seem to make the case that there was a problem:
> Later in 2020, Respondent began selling a new Nature’s Bounty Zinc Gummies product to Amazon for sale on Amazon.com. In August 2020, before the launch of the Zinc Gummies product, the Ecommerce Customer Development Director, wrote in an email:
>> [m]oving forward we are going to launch skus with variations that make sense: i.e. Zinc gummy with zinc tablet – gives the strongest opportunity to win from day 1 – gives relevancy, page 1 view, ... increased Conversation, and sales. We are seeing success with this strategy ....
> Respondent requested that Amazon create a variation relationship including Zinc Gummies, and two of Respondent’s established products, Nature’s Bounty Calcium Magnesium & Zinc caplets and Nature’s Bounty Zinc 50 mg caplets. The products had different formulations, including different amounts of the main ingredient or additional ingredients. The Zinc caplets were Amazon.com’s “#1 Best Seller in Zinc Mineral Supplements.”
So the theory seems to be that by listing their different zinc products as variations of each other, someone was getting defrauded.
But I don't see why "40mg zinc" caplets and "50mg zinc" caplets shouldn't be considered variations of each other (different amounts of the main ingredient!), and I also don't see why "40mg zinc" pills shouldn't be considered variations of "40mg zinc" gummy candies (different additional ingredients!). I don't see a big problem with the fact that Tylenol comes in a variation that includes a sedative ("Tylenol PM" - different active ingredients!). How is this different?
Since when does Amazon respond with dad jokes?
Over 99%? Who are these people that see that??
It's such a wild claim. It would be impressive if 99% of reviews were authentic. But they are saying 99% of their most popular products do not have a single unauthentic review.
While I'm there, I figure I might as well leave an authentic review on the previous pair of shoes now that my use of them is complete.
I can't find any way to leave a review.
Anyway, I find it highly dubious that 99% of the reviews on Amazon could be authentic.
Every Amazon search is riddled with products gaming the platform. I just ran a quick search for "oscilloscope" and found 29 listings for the same 2 products...
https://www.amazon.com/hz/wishlist/ls/3RJY10Y7MQVK0?ref_=wl_...