While that may be true to some extent (especially with the more popular stocks like, let's say... Tesla, the P/E ratio is through the roof, although it got a bit better in the last year or two), but I feel that stocks that pay dividends do have actual gains - in the form of dividends.
I personally prefer dividend stocks, because with the growth stocks you have to sell to get any profits or anything back, and I don't like to sell. Also, when the stuck is moving down, they usually still do pay dividends, which allows you to buy more of the stock at an even lower price.
In my opinion, it's much harder to inflate the price of the stock through the dividends, because those actually affect the company. They need to have that money to be able to pay it out to the shareholders.
Why?
Share buyback instead of dividends has almost only advantages. It's more liquid, more tax efficient.
> it's much harder to inflate the price of the stock through the dividends, because those actually affect the company.
What do you mean "inflate"?
> They need to have that money to be able to pay it out to the shareholders.
But it's the same during a buyback...
It also doesn’t help that DCF calculations are incredibly sensitive with respect to interest rates that had for some time been historically low.
It might be easier to calculate these days, but my findings from years ago informed me that these issues were beyond reading financial reports.
There’s a bigger problem of there simply just not being enough attractive companies at even fair rates.
Statistically, you can only buy earnings at so high of a price to meaningfully make a worthwhile return, and for a while now, those prices have been too high in comparison to the risk free rate.
I’m sure this has since changed due to current interest rates, but I haven’t bother to look simply because of the first problem.
It’s people repeating this idea that math has suddenly changed within the last 20 years or something that is ridiculous.
The field of finance studies how to value various assets, beginning with fixed cash flows over time, and then introducing things like risk.
Would you spend one US dollar to make a million a year? Of course, but what such investments would ever exist?
And so instruments which bare gains over time have some value, which is calculated by the means of cost of investment to returns over time.
If there are a market of such instruments, they can and will be in competition with each other.
This "things are only what people value them at" stuff is for the birds. Those other people you're talking about are actually calculating their investments. Others with such mentality will follow, not knowing what they're doing, and taking missteps when the goods are already gone.
What you think is "accepted by everyone else" is what you're seeing at face value. There are reasons behind actions. Those actions in and of themself have no meaning without context.
The mathematics of investment have never, ever changed in any meaningful way. The history of debts, interest rates, and returns have always fluctuated, but the math hasn't.
Anyone suggesting otherwise is uninformed.
There is no math that claims the price of a stock should be some form of discounted future cashflows since at least the 90s.
Since then, all models have been multifactor ones, with fundamentals (quality, value) being only one fragment of the market, sector and country residualized stock returns.
What `epups` is explaining to you is the basis of behavioral economics, which is the de facto current leading theory since its foundations were Nobel prized 20 years ago...
There's too much money in the game. There's more capital invested than there are things to invest in at a reasonable rate of real returns. It needs to be clawed back but it's hard an unpopular to do. What we effectively need is a temporary effective progressive wealth tax that alters the exponent of wealth distribution, and that tax just needs to go "nowhere" instead of being reinvested in government programs. Carefully though because such an action has lots of side effects. The problem is whenever you propose such a thing there will be a long list of people with a long and varied list of reasons why this or something similar is insane. It is A) complicated and B) poorly understood so the discourse is usually just useless, which is reason #1 why it is hard.
He doesn't do anything in private as Berkshire has so much money all their moves are public and well known. The advice is true but fits another era, read his autobiography.
> People are searching among the crumbs now.
Yeah, the cigarette butts. He had ~$10 million by age 30. Incidentally he amassed this as the the son of a congressman, had a rich auntie, and was in very good social standing in a small wealthy town (Omaha). And it was 1960.
By 1960, Buffett operated seven investment partnerships. He asked one of his partners, a doctor, to find ten other doctors willing to invest $10,000 each in his partnership. Eventually, eleven agreed, and Buffett pooled their money with a mere $100 original investment of his own.
I remember him taking about discounted cash flow calculations and what maybe, supposedly, he and Munger use as the discount rate, but as soon as you apply this calculation to all 3000+ publicly traded US securities, you find that most of them are completely overvalued and have been for years. You can adjust the discount rate, but it doesn’t help in practice.
Anyone with a computer and the patience to parse financial reports can do this, so of course people have done it.
The problem is there aren’t many good investments actually there anymore. Period.
If you’ve been investing the last few years and have made returns as all of us collectively have, you know those returns definitely aren’t coming from real gains.
They’ve almost entirely been speculative returns.
I was so jaded calculating this stuff and seeing marketable securities histories across various sectors that I came to realize all the free lunch has already been eaten.
People are searching among the crumbs now.
It’s just entirely an entrenched practice. There’s too many people in that game.
I’m also a fan of the textbook guidelines from Security Analysis and The Intelligent Investor, but of course using those specific measurements also yield nothing worse investing in at the present date, and haven’t for years.[1]
Everything is way more expensive than it should be valued at, and I suspect a part of it, too, is simply that a majority of shares are on the market and have no reason to be sold lower than what inflated values are presently passing for.
It’s like owning a house knowing people need a place to live.
People need securities for retirement. There’s only also many that exist.
[1]: https://www.andrewmcwatters.org/personal-finance/#investment...