I prefer to repeat to myself the mantra of: "Time in the market beats timing the market."
People thought they could beat the market by timing buys of stocks that were likely to become part of indexes.
If there was any alpha in this practice, it’s been sucked out of the market at this point. The anticipation of this has already been priced in, so there’s no remaining advantage in trying this strategy.
I'm also guessing that many have algorithms that check for stocks that fulfill the criteria to be added to the index.
I think but am not sure that the economy can expand by shifting more “income” from capital to wages which would be bad for stocks. Think 1950s.
If the expanding economy is caused by a lot of disruption from new businesses it could also be bad to hold indices weighted towards incumbents, this seems the most likely to happen of the three cases. The disrupters don’t necessarily need to be big, just enough of a threat that investors think future growth or earnings of incumbents are threatened.