News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by systems on Sunday April 09, 2023 @01:31PM (#35504726)
why would anyone want to use PL/Rust over PL/PQSL?

what is the use case?

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by mkl95 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @01:37PM (#35504776)
> PL/Rust is a loadable procedural language that enables writing PostgreSQL functions in the Rust programming language

Use to write PostgreSQL functions in Rust. Also

> The top advantages of PL/Rust include writing natively-compiled functions to achieve the absolute best performance, access to Rust's large development ecosystem, and Rust's compile-time safety guarantees.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by systems on Sunday April 09, 2023 @01:52PM (#35504906)
As someone who have done a lot of database development, none of these sound advantageous

Using a text oriented language like Perl with a good regexp engine might

DB performance, comes from indexes , table partitioning and in-memory tables and to compile query execution plans, so you save some time the very first you run a procedure

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by ixfo on Sunday April 09, 2023 @02:27PM (#35505165)
Doing in-database computation can be very advantageous for some applications, and writing those functions in Rust would be fantastic for some uses, not least for the library ecosystem. I did some work on video similarity search with in-DB search which would've certainly benefited.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by ttfkam on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:19PM (#35506566)
DB performance also comes from size efficiency of user-defined data types, user-defined operator functions (typically for use with those user-defined data types), etc.

Smaller, more efficient types directly translate to less disk usage and smaller indexes, both of which measurably improve database performance.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by pjmlp on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:07AM (#35509876)
I assume PL/pg is not behind the curve in relation to PL/SQL and T-SQL for UDTs.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by doctor_eval on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:26PM (#35506635)
> DB performance, comes from indexes , table partitioning and in-memory tables and to compile query execution plans, so you save some time the very first you run a procedure

The network round trip to the database can also be a pretty significant performant penalty, especially when iterating over large sets.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by samanator on Sunday April 09, 2023 @03:06PM (#35505488)
A crucial facet of optimization for computational triggers in PostgreSQL pertains to the implementation of event triggers, which enable operations to be executed in bulk (per DML statement) rather than on a per-row basis. It appears that, at present, PL/Rust has not incorporated support for event triggers. According to the documentation:

> Event Triggers and DO blocks are not (yet) supported by PL/Rust.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by ttfkam on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:16PM (#35506548)
Event triggers fire on DDL changes, not DML. You're thinking of statement-level triggers.

As far as event triggers and DO-blocks, that omission seems fine to me. Especially DO-blocks, which are essentially an inline code, one-off escape hatch in the middle of other SQL. Rust would not be helping any performance-sensitive critical paths in those cases.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by doctor_eval on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:25PM (#35506627)
True, but it’s sometimes useful for experimenting, REPL style.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by samanator on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:52PM (#35506818)
You're right! My mistake. I was thinking of statement triggers.

https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/sql-createtrigger.ht...

> The REFERENCING option enables collection of transition relations

I don't see any examples of statement triggers...

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by ttfkam on Sunday April 09, 2023 @10:51PM (#35508705)
https://stackoverflow.com/a/72397774

Note the use of new_table and old_table as aliases. Instead of single records in NEW and OLD, you can select against new and old sets of records.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by samanator on Wednesday April 12, 2023 @03:44PM (#35545649)
I understand, and I've used the old and new table aliases. But I meant that I don't see a way to use those in the PL/Rust docs.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by pjmlp on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:05AM (#35509867)
Stored procedures are compiled to native code in any respectfull RDMS (Oracle, SQL Server, DB2,...), and I assume same applies to PostgreSQL.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by tempaccount420 on Sunday April 09, 2023 @03:01PM (#35505439)
PLPSQL is an awful language for anything less than the highest level glue code
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by cobythedog on Sunday April 09, 2023 @03:11PM (#35505531)
Can you give some examples of why you think this? I'm sincerely curious as someone who uses PLPSQL nearly every day and knows it is not perfect, but surprised to hear it is "awful".
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by ttfkam on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:20PM (#35506585)
I concur. Pl/pgsql isn't exactly elegant to be sure, but if you're already in a set-oriented mindset but need to add a sprinkling of imperative logic, it's well suited to the job.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by asah on Sunday April 09, 2023 @06:49PM (#35507237)
no seriously, PL/pgsql is pretty horrible and obscure. But aside from subjective comments, there's very few algorithms available for it, approximately 0% of engineers know it and it's not taught in school, has little tooling compared with a first class programming language, you can't run pl/pgsql code outside of PostgreSQL, and (tell me when to stop)

PL/PGSQL is fine for "a bit more than a SELECT statement" and for very simple algorithms of <50 LOC. Anything more and please use a first class language like plrust, plv8, etc.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by ttfkam on Sunday April 09, 2023 @10:47PM (#35508683)
The decision between pl/pgsql and something like plv8 isn't LOC. It's whether the solution best fits a set-oriented model or a procedural model. Both are valid, just different use cases.

There are a lot of cases where plv8 will thrash back and forth between the internals of Postgres and C and its v8 engine. These are usually the cases where set theory dominates the solution space.

On the flip side, if you're doing a lot of filter/map/reduce on large JSON payloads, plv8 is demonstrably better than pl/pgsql.

Right tool. Right job.

Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by pjmlp on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:08AM (#35509883)
The same engineers that use to rave about NoSQL a couple of years ago?
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by danielheath on Sunday April 09, 2023 @10:02PM (#35508426)
Rather than "Awful", I'd say it's showing its age.

The things I notice when working in PLPSQL:

  * Ample boilerplate that needs to be correct when it could be inferred.
  * Lack of a language server (doesn't help that PLPSQL is often embedded in strings in other files)
  * Papercuts like procedures vs functions having different call syntaxes
  * No/limited support for encapsulation
  * No/limited package management
  * Most new languages have syntactic sugar, like implicit returns / everything is an expression
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by doctor_eval on Sunday April 09, 2023 @05:28PM (#35506649)
I don’t think it’s awful but it’s a bit verbose. But are there any other trusted languages that are as directly connected to SQL?
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by pjmlp on Monday April 10, 2023 @03:08AM (#35509879)
Nah, it does the job.
Re:PL/Rust 1.0: now a trusted language for Postgres by zkirill on Sunday April 09, 2023 @09:25PM (#35508206)
Wouldn't it be easier to write and run unit tests in Rust?