> 2019, the city proposed opening a homeless shelter in the area, and residents protested, arguing that the facility — which eventually did open — would be detrimental to public safety.
> Opposition to the shelter gathered momentum after a woman trying to enter her condo building was attacked that summer by a man suffering from mental illness, one of many seemingly random assaults that occurred in succession as the pandemic emptied public spaces.
> But a bodega owner in the area said that crime seemed to be rising, and that at night, the neighborhood became a backdrop for drug use and occasional sideshows.
> San Francisco recorded 56 homicides in 2017 before some violent crimes dipped during the pandemic; in 2021 and 2022, the homicide count was back up to 56, according to data from the city’s Police Department.
It’s not exactly Portland or Chicago, but I think it is reasonable for people in SF to say the status quo is unacceptable.
Progressives tend to systematically underrate crime as a problem because it “magically” went down for so long after the 90s. Incidents like this remind people that crime is real, and not just imagined by the Fox News, and that the victims are real, too.
Anecdote, I spent some time wandering around east palo alto (at the time, was the murder capital). It didn't feel particularly bad, but the data said otherwise.
You can't trust random people's perception of safety. You can't trust the data either.
In San Francisco, that bargain is unraveling.
The Bay Area has always been particularly badly segregated. Palo Alto is wealthy and posh, East Palo Alto is a dump. San Jose boasts huge tech companies while East San Jose is full of gang fighting. I grew up in one of these violent areas of the Bay (starts with East but that's all I'll mention publicly) and the gap in resources is huge. Bad schools, poor libraries and community spaces, poorly maintained parks, unsafe neighborhoods, no pedestrian affordances, high speed badly maintained roads, the list is endless.
The Wire is a great show that goes into some of the politics and challenges of America's containment style of policing.
Everything is spot on. The Bay Area, but especially SF has a very incestuous and parochial political culture due to how historically NorCal was a backwater compared to LA, OC, and SD.
That said, a lot of Old Money also moved away to Marin, LaMorinda, Alamo, Danville, Hillsborough, and Woodside in the 70s-90s.
Human brains are also wired to pay more attention to anecdotal data than statistics.
Wat? Who are you imagining is the winner and who is the loser? The guy that wanted to get married, and his partner who didn't?
Letting one dramatic headline make you so emotional that you ignore larger trends in data is such a choice. It's not required.
And as far as culture wars go, when it comes to something like gay marriage I get it, there's a policy winner and loser there.
But what's the point of pretending cities are more dangerous than they are? The people there know the true level of safety, and how it differs from the performative outrage discourse.