News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by throwaway2056 on Friday April 07, 2023 @02:59AM (#35478928)
This.

Plus: people here calling for Raspberry or Synology do not know 'average' users

- People dont know what is ethernet

- Most people cant navigate GUI of synology or other stuff

- Some of the hn gurus need to work as CS for a week. People get confused what USB-A or USB-C cable.

- For hn-gurus with Rpi/nextcloud: These products are sold to average joe that has no clue about tech.

- for average joe people, google is internet, facebook is family and whatsapp is chat.

- The sales guy that sold it just works for commission. Capitalism.

- Same is for WD. They sold the product for $100 8TB so that is the quality one expects.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by quaintdev on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:04AM (#35478953)
Then we need to work on it to make self hosting as ubiquitous as a TV. Imagine a future where all your photos, videos stay at your house on a box and others who have access can view them from anywhere.

The corporations are working in direction where this is never possible but given how they all deal with data this is the only future that will be secure and makes sense.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Dalewyn on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:38AM (#35479149)
>Imagine a future where all your photos, videos stay at your house on a box and others who have access can view them from anywhere.

We are slowly working towards such a future and common users by and large will appreciate it, but it's not going to be the future most tech nerds envision it to be.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by copper-float on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:10AM (#35479395)
What are you referring to?
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Dalewyn on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:19AM (#35479448)
Basically: Convenience and customizability are mutually exclusive.

We as tech nerds value our ability to power user, but this is quite simply at odds with the interests of common users.

Things like further and further abstractioning of file systems, further and further integrations of operating systems with online accounts and other internet services, further and further "appliance"ing of computer systems, etc.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by lolc on Friday April 07, 2023 @05:56AM (#35479947)
In what ways will the average homebox be more secure than the average cloud hosting?
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by autoexec on Friday April 07, 2023 @08:13AM (#35480772)
> In what ways will the average homebox be more secure than the average cloud hosting?

No third parties will be automatically rummaging through your files and using it to stuff a dossier with details about you to sell or exploit for profit.

The webserver in your living room will only host your personal files, so it isn't a single target that can grant a hacker massive amounts of valuable data from hundreds of thousands of users at once if they can manage to get in. If a hacker takes the time to break into your server, they maybe get a handful of baby photos and MP3s, but before that they'd have to somehow know about and find your server specifically in the first place.

When your server gets hacked, you aren't going to pretend it isn't happening, or lie to yourself about what happened, and you won't have to spend days wondering what the impact to you was, and you won't bend over backwards to try to downplay that impact for the sake of your shareholders.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by fauigerzigerk on Friday April 07, 2023 @08:54AM (#35481084)
>The webserver in your living room will only host your personal files, so it isn't a single target that can grant a hacker massive amounts of valuable data from hundreds of thousands of users at once if they can manage to get in.

Just because it's not running under a single domain doesn't mean hundereds of thousands of users can't be affected by a single vulnerability. If everyone was using Nextcloud on Ubuntu and a vulnerability is found somewhere in that stack then attackers could easily scan the internet for unpatched installations. Happens all the time with corporate IT.

Also, people don't just store family photos and MP3s. They also store intimate photos, financial data, company data, health data, scans of passports and other official documents, utility bills, plenty that can be used as proof of identity and proof of address. If you had access to the contents of my hard drive you could easily impersonate me in almost every context.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by autoexec on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:07PM (#35485696)
> Just because it's not running under a single domain doesn't mean hundereds of thousands of users can't be affected by a single vulnerability.

That's fair, although it's much easier to find a heavily advertised corporate network and scan that than it is to scan the entire IPv4/6 space looking for a particular vulnerable server (which isn't to say that it doesn't happen). One advantage you have with a home server too is that hackers can't create legitimate accounts on your server to poke around and look for holes.

> They also store intimate photos, financial data, company data, health data, scans of passports and other official documents, utility bills,

People do have those things on hard drives, but I don't think most people would put that on their living room webserver. At least I don't think that was what was meant by "Imagine a future where all your photos, videos stay at your house on a box and others who have access can view them from anywhere." I assumed that "box" was a separate web/file server specifically designed and used for sharing your personal files and not the same device people would use to pay their bills and store their nudes. Keeping those two things separate would certainty be good practice!

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by fauigerzigerk on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:08AM (#35491521)
>People do have those things on hard drives, but I don't think most people would put that on their living room webserver.

I was thinking of self hosted replacements for things like iCloud, Google Photos or OneDrive. People use cloud services to access, share and upload their files from all their devices wherever they may be.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Dalewyn on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:32AM (#35479109)
>People dont know what is ethernet

Correction: People don't know what is computer.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by justsomehnguy on Friday April 07, 2023 @03:20AM (#35479045)
> Most people cant navigate GUI of synology or other stuff

Sad non-average user noises.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by eitland on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:03AM (#35479339)
Question is for each of us who are experts in the field: do we continue to encourage this trend or do we encourage people to learn?

I grew up in a time and an environment where I felt everyone taught and everyone shared.

It feels like more and more everything is made harder despite everything really being more accessible than before - if you only know.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Dalewyn on Friday April 07, 2023 @04:26AM (#35479493)
It's not even a question because this has played out time and again: The commons value simplicity and convenience, and products will naturally gravitate towards such offerings over time as technologies evolve.

I firmly believe that "appliance" computers like Macbooks, Chromebooks, game consoles, and smartphones are the future and ultimate destination of personal computing. Much as I hate to say it: Fucking nobody cares about being a power user, about messing with their computer. For the commons, a computer is merely just another appliance and tool to serve and enable bigger interests, a means to an end.

We should also remember that, eventually, the time will come when we become the technologically illiterate luddites, unable to "get" the new fangled tech that the youngsters will immediately master as they point and laugh at our seeming ineptitude.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by freehorse on Friday April 07, 2023 @05:00AM (#35479672)
> Fucking nobody cares about being a power user, about messing with their computer.

No, people care only to have somebody that cares around, so that they can solve their issues. Do you think people with macbooks etc never encounter issues with software/hardware and all just work automatically always without having to care about anything? This is an illusion, and in the end of the day you (or someone) has to put the extra work.

It is similar to what happened to electronic and other devices through the years, everything becomes more user friendly but also more complex and opaque the same time, so younger generations were getting more and more clueless how these devices worked. I do not know how things will go now, but I see the same trend as computers, I do not see the older generation becoming technologically illiterate luddites (ok I do mot use tik tok so maybe that makes me one) as much as I see that the the big part of the younger generations not knowing much more than touching stuff on a screen. I do not see that the proportion of more technically adept people increased at all. But yeah, maybe there is some new neurotechnology thing or whatever at some point that changes things, but not something I see with present tech.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by throwaway2056 on Friday April 07, 2023 @05:52AM (#35479918)
> Question is for each of us who are experts in the field: do we continue to encourage this trend or do we encourage people to learn?

This is will not happen. Every other tech fellow I speak to (working in SAP-/Oracle/google/type Giant to a startup) tells me that I just do it as I need $$$. Done. As long as they can afford/get the appropriate help. They dont care about average joe that knows only bestbuy or google photos.

> Do you think people with macbooks etc never encounter issues with software/hardware and all just work automatically always without having to care about anything? Thi

The advantage is that with macbooks/chromebooks/windows (even ubuntu to some level) is that you can google and get some info. Worst case I have seen customers in Apple Store - with a old (i.e) 2 year old macs - asking the Genius to please copy everything to their new device.

With Raspberry or WD - one cant do it. (Sure there are some Linux User Groups where an old fart will do it for a beer but most people dont know this)..

It is a difficult challenge, ideally: one gets some kind of govt authorisation for a FAAANG-account - and it will get backup up with FAANG for some $/month. And one can produce some govt ID to restore it. Of course it has other issues - but for average Joe whose privacy is already lost - they would be too happy to just to get their wedding/holiday pics back.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Karunamon on Friday April 07, 2023 @08:57AM (#35481108)
That last statement is not necessarily true. Becoming technologically illiterate, outside of bona fide medical problems like Alzheimer's making it impossible to think, is a choice. Say no to becoming that person.
Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Dalewyn on Saturday April 08, 2023 @04:20AM (#35491570)
I say no to becoming that person, but I can see myself becoming that person (like most people who came before me) because I simply do not have the time, money, nor energy to chase after and learn everything in the world.

I have had the fortunate pleasure of interacting with many genuinely intelligent, skilled, wise people, but it wouldn't surprise me if those same people couldn't understand computers or whatever new fangled tech that comes our way. I don't necessarily blame them either, lives are limited and they spent what they have in places they felt were worth it; we can't have everything.

Re:Western Digital cloud services down for 4 days by Karunamon on Saturday April 08, 2023 @06:43PM (#35498377)
Nobody, least of all me, is asking you to chase after and learn everything in the world. The word used is "literacy", not "proficiency". You only become illiterate (again, barring actual impediment) by outright rejecting the opportunity to learn, and that is something chosen.