News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by nchuhoai on Friday February 03, 2012 @02:22AM (#3546202)
> What business is Google in? If you said search, guess again.

Really? Advertising, search ... semantics. Everyone knows that AdSense/Adwords is Googles money making machine

Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by sukuriant on Friday February 03, 2012 @02:27AM (#3546211)
No, sorry. They're two very different things. Search would be, to the general public, providing answers to questions they have. No one should say search upon any analysis, though, because search in and of itself isn't likely to make money -- well, except for selling unique user's searching habits to other companies for demographics information so that THEY can create better ads.

Advertising, on the other hand, is what happens when you weight certain search results higher than others because they pay you more money, or when you, as Google does, separate out potentially interesting advertisements for you to click on.

You can run a search engine without being a business, without making money, and without having advertisements or search results weighted by how much money they gave you.

That said, how does Duck Duck Go make money?

Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by saurik on Friday February 03, 2012 @05:02AM (#3546541)
That all makes "search" an inexact answer, not an incorrect one; akin to answering "their stores" for "how does Best Buy make money?" as opposed to "selling products"; your "normal" person will just look at you cross-eyed for that correction and complain about "semantics". (That said, I agree with you that not analyzing it far enough to at least get to the also-vague-sounding "advertising" is probably not actable.)
Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by dangrossman on Friday February 03, 2012 @05:33AM (#3546599)
$11 billion of Google's ad revenue is from non-Google websites. They run the largest display advertising network in the world (thanks to the DoubleClick acquisition). Search is just one channel for their ads.
Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by bmuon on Friday February 03, 2012 @08:46AM (#3547045)
That was totally missing in the article. It'd be really interesting to see the difference between display advertising and ads in search results.
Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by saurik on Sunday February 05, 2012 @02:37PM (#3554959)
From the actual filings this article is making those pie charts with, Google reports 72% of their advertising revenue comes from websites they operate.

They also reported paying 51% (AdSense for Search) and 68% (AdSense for Content) of the fees (which they defined as the revenue) to the "Google Network Member".

Doing the math out, that would indicate that the advertising profit from their own websites accounts for 85-90% of their total profit from advertising.

In essence, the fact that they "run the largest display advertising network in the world" is actually in any way "where they make the money".

(Of course, the money they get from that isn't "chump change", and I'd even make the argument that if they didn't run that off-Google advertising network their core advertising business would have less content available.).

Re:Microsoft, Apple, and Google: where does the money come f... by rbanffy on Friday February 03, 2012 @05:12AM (#3546567)
Unless you pay for it, search itself won't be a revenue driver.