Re:A SvelteKit template for building CMS-free editable websites
by vcryan on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @02:59PM
(#35458887)
I think this pitch overstates the problem with CMSes. It seems for many organizations, their CMS is working well for them. Not saying this doesn't have benefit, but, as for me, I rather like my CMS and don't feel like this is a big win.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:A SvelteKit template for building CMS-free editable websites
by input_sh on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @03:54PM
(#35459579)
> It seems for many organizations, their CMS is working well for them.
I hope to work in one of such orgs some day because the most common experience I've witnessed was pain.
And things don't improve when you throw more money at a CMS. There's an entire industry of enterprise CMSs (yearly license in five figures) and their users aren't any happier with their CMS than WordPress users.
Re:A SvelteKit template for building CMS-free editable websites
by _mql on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @04:21PM
(#35459848)
I'm coming from a minimalist perspective. Of course a hand-crafted site like this template doesn't cover all the enterprise CMS use cases, such as image manipulation, video transcoding etc. It's not a one-size-fits-it-all solution but for for me personally, it speeds things and gives me 100% control. I'm the person who'd rather invest in developing a FFMPEG API endpoint tailored for my application than pulling in the complexity of a CMS.
Re:A SvelteKit template for building CMS-free editable websites
by naet on Wednesday April 05, 2023 @05:24PM
(#35460561)
This is a huge step down from the experience of many CMSes. Controls are limited and don't really work for building a page. Maybe convenient for very small text edits like spelling fixes but not at all a replacement for a more in depth editing experience.
Re:A SvelteKit template for building CMS-free editable websites
by danjac on Thursday April 06, 2023 @02:27AM
(#35464889)
A full-featured CMS includes editing workflow I think: so an intern writing a press release has to have the article checked by an editor and maybe the legal department before publication, with corrections or comments included. At a pinch you could use Google Docs but that comes with more friction - hard to preview the content on the site etc and it's not so easily enforced as a locked-down CMS workflow.