News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by the88doctor on Monday April 03, 2023 @02:43PM (#35429210)
The thread author said Firefly was only trained on properly licensed photos which definitely supports the hypothesis that it sucks because it is doing things legally. Unfortunately that seems to make it suck even when the prompt does not reference any protected IP (e.g. the woman in red in a crowd example).
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Robotbeat on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:35PM (#35430021)
Learning off of works of other artists is not illegal.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by rondini on Monday April 03, 2023 @03:50PM (#35430246)
I think that the law is woefully unequipped to handle this situation, but there is definitely an ethical concern over training your models on copyrighted work. Adobe isn't going to scrape images off of social media to train their image generator and that will always put them behind companies that do. I can't say whether that's fair but I have very little faith that regulators will understand this issue enough to find a solution.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by jonny_eh on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:09PM (#35430521)
We don't know that yet, we may find out soon.

https://vox.com/recode/23580554/generative-ai-chatgpt-openai...

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Robotbeat on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:15PM (#35430605)
Exactly, so insisting on it being illegal now is inaccurate. You can bet that companies which have access to massive IP stockpiles, like Adobe, will absolutely be pushing things in a direction so that anything you see or hear cannot be used for inspiration without a hefty fee which is at their sole discretion.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by _coveredInBees on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:21PM (#35430708)
The correct interpretation is that relying on tools like MidJourney can be a liability for the exact reason that this can go any which way and the legality issue is rather gray. So the point still stands that many companies would rather have a more clear-cut tool like Adobe Firefly without having to worry about potential liability.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by sebzim4500 on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:22PM (#35430715)
I doubt Adobe has a serious lobbying presence. It's Disney you've got to watch out for, but hopefully they are distracted arguing with Florida about whether gay people exist.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by ftxbro on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:20PM (#35431446)
> I doubt Adobe has a serious lobbying

It depends what you call "serious" but on their government relations page https://www.adobe.com/about-adobe/government-relations.html they say "Adobe discloses information on our federal and state lobbying activities. Our most recent federal lobbying disclosures are listed on the U.S. Senate lobbying disclosure database and U.S. House lobbying disclosure database."

If you look at the forms on those databases you can see that Adobe has a "Policy, Government, and Ethical Innovation team in Washington, D.C." which I guess is what they call their lobbying crew.

> It's Disney you've got to watch out for

Probably most lobbying efforts would be considered 'not serious' if the standard is Disney!

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by waboremo on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:09PM (#35431326)
Yes, but leaning too hard in the other direction (that all these models do is "learn" therefore it's ok to duplicate) would negate a whole lot of protection artists (and in general individuals) get regarding their creative works in the digital space.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Robotbeat on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:01PM (#35433616)
These models do not duplicate except in corner cases where the training set has massive persistent patterns (like a watermark) or if there's massive duplication in the data set (especially happens with famous artwork already in the public domain). This is not an intentional thing, and in every case is actually counter-productive to the functioning of the model.

If you used a really cleverly and exhaustively and iteratively prompted midjourney image to recreate a copyrighted painting, that WOULD be duplication, just like a physical artist can paint a copy of a copyrighted painting by hand.

Duplication is the end result, not the intermediary. That's why transformative collage is fine.

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by blibble on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:47PM (#35431045)
it's not learning anything

if you turn the temperature value down to zero it will produce the same thing every time given the same input (in the same way zlib or jpeg will)

it's a lossy compression function that is implemented using a neural net

copyright isn't removed if I take someone's existing image and re-save it as a jpg

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by alxhill on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:17PM (#35431409)
This is false and represents a poor understanding of how these models work - they do abstract concepts and no you can't trivially get training images out.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by blibble on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:23PM (#35431484)
it's exactly the argument that the court cases against training on copyrighted works without permission are using

if the courts agree and this is ruled to be infringement then we'll left with products with level of quality we see here

meaning the technology will be an economic dead end

here's to hoping

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Robotbeat on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:13PM (#35433697)
Copyright is about copying. It is not about observing. Reading a copyrighted book isn't infringement. Writing out copies of it is, even if you don't use a computer or anything.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by DiscourseFan on Monday April 03, 2023 @11:13PM (#35434518)
>they do abstract concepts

I don't think, given that we don't even have a particularly full understanding of how human conceptual logic functions, that we can claim that even AIs are using it as well. It's only "abstracting" in the sense that it has labeled one million objects in its training set with the word "tree," and fuses many of those images together to form a general picture dependent on specific parameters made to limit its set (oak tree, winter tree, etc.)

But that is different from me or you using the word tree, which is just a signifier among signifiers, it stands for nothing but a negation of the very thing it points to in a certain set of symbolic relations. Humans communicate in the order of symbolic structures, our minds function much more like LLMs, creating multitudinous pattern relations. What you call "abstract concepts" are of a secondary order imposed to create rigorous exactitude overtop the riddled mess that we call the human psyche.

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by RC_ITR on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:13PM (#35432049)
Ok, so let's assume it's using a Visual Transformer architecture, since AFAICT, we don't know.

What the model does is turn the picture into numbers in a clever way (embedding).

Then, the model compares the relationships between all the embedded tokens (self-attention).

Then the model does the fancy linear algebra stuff we've come to know and love (feed forward neural network).

What you're basically getting at with your temperature comment is "rather than having it semi-randomly pick one of the top n options that the feed-forward network recommends for which pixel goes where, we can always have the model simply choose the top answer each time."

That is not "we can make it reproduce training images"

The point of embedding is to see multiple examples of similar images and generalize from them. The process in and of itself breaks the ability to re-create a photo, unless the training set is very skewed.

If that's the argument of legal cases, they are likely to fail or win on ignorance.

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by blibble on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:21PM (#35432126)
> That is not "we can make it reproduce training images"

didn't say that, all I said is it's a deterministic lossy compression function of the inputs (unless randomness is deliberately introduced)

and as such it should be treated the same way as zlib or jpeg for copyright purposes

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by f_devd on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:36PM (#35432301)
> deterministic lossy compression function

This would only be true if it didn't mix or 'forget' any of the training data for each prompt, and only then for the exact same inputs of the training data. That is a lot of qualifiers that aren't practically applicable.

Slight side note: a deterministic lossy compression function should not always be treated the same as jpeg/zlib, as hash functions are technically also in that category.

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by RC_ITR on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:35PM (#35432271)
I think you're really stretching the definition of deterministic here.

For example, switching training order of images has a known impact on outputs, but I don't see the equivalent in traditional compression.

I agree with you that it is computer code that runs on circuits (and is therefore deterministic in a very loose sense), but it is fundamentally incorrect to compare it to traditional image compression.

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by pertymcpert on Monday April 03, 2023 @06:55PM (#35432505)
Those are two orthogonal concepts. The temperature has nothing to do with whether it's a lossy compression function.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Robotbeat on Monday April 03, 2023 @09:09PM (#35433672)
Copyright doesn't have anything to do with determinism. It existed in a pure analogue world before computers and if you had implemented your neural net in a fundamentally non-deterministic way (such as an analog neuromorphic neural net of some sort), it wouldn't make any difference one way or another. A human artist with no computer whatsoever and only their brain and basic writing (or painting) implements can break copyright just fine by writing out (or painting) copyrighted works from memory, then distributing them. It's the PRODUCTION side that is the copyright infringement, not the observing side.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by avisser on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @08:18AM (#35438396)
I have no idea why your replies seem to think you're being outrageous. I've seen the image from one of the AI services that is a very clear almost-reproduction of a Getty Images photo.

I wouldn't want to be the defense's lawyer when that image gets shown to a jury.

https://www.theverge.com/2023/2/6/23587393/ai-art-copyright-...

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Robotbeat on Monday April 03, 2023 @08:49PM (#35433533)
The human brain is a lossy compression function implemented with a neural net.

Making absurd arguments is fun!

(The reason this is absurd is the number of parameters in the model is incredibly small compared to the size of the training set. You wouldn't even have enough bits per training image to keep a unique identifier for each training image, let alone a compressed representation. And to the degree there's redundancy in the training set, this is undesirable, actually counter-productive to the functioning of the model.)

(In a way, the human brain is actually more capable of copyright infringement since the number of parameters in the human brain is about 4-5 times that of a typical image generative AI neural net, and we're trained on a smaller and less generalizable data set. Humans can and do make copies of things from memory, which generative AI massively struggles with and can only do for corner cases.)

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by mcv on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @03:38AM (#35436330)
No, but reproducing them is, and that's clearly what MidJourney is doing. MidJourney did a fantastic job on the Deadpool, Mario and Pikachu images, but those are clearly copyright violations.
Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by Terretta on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @04:44AM (#35436829)
Fictional character protection is complex, backed by franchise money generation machines.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_protection_for_ficti...

Arguably, however, (a) not all fictional characters are copyrightable in the first place, and (b) fair use still exists.

Adobe Illustrator should not prevent an artist from drawing Mickey Mouse using the software. Nor should MidJourney.

If Disney has a problem, they can go after the human using the tool.

Re:Adobe Firefly vs. MidJourney AI image generation by mcv on Tuesday April 04, 2023 @05:03AM (#35436956)
Sure, you could argue the violation is in the publication, not the creation. So to what extent are these online tools publishing them? You can generally reproduce someone else's IP for your own use, but can you give it to one specific other person? Does it matter whether it's a computer or a person that's giving it? I'm sure this question will employ a lot of lawyers.