News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by JohnFen on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:34PM (#35426822)
AR and VR are inherently antisocial technologies, though. They both isolate you from the world.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by PretzelPirate on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:38PM (#35426913)
I use VR primarily for social interactions. Not everyone I interact with loves in the same city as me, but we regularly play VR games to maintain a social relationship.

Thats not being antisocial at all, and I don't replace in-person social events with virtual ones anymore than someone who jumps into Fortnite with their friends on Friday nights.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by JohnFen on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:46PM (#35427050)
Well, yes. I also have online-only friendships, too. using VR in the way you do makes sense.

What I'm responding to is the idea (mostly from the likes of Meta and various hard-core advocates) that VR will become ubiquitous. That means it replacing actual in-person communication.

Reducing everyone to a datastream is an antisocial tendency. If that's done as an alternative to not interacting with someone at all, it's the more social alternative. If that's done as an alternative to interacting with people in the real world, that's antisocial.

It's a bit like using video conferencing. Many workplaces are continuing to use video conferencing in the office even when everyone is in the office. That's an antisocial use. Using it to bring people together who cannot be physically together is a pro-social use.

AR/VR is designed to separate you from the physical world and reduce everything to a datastream. That's what I meant by "antisocial". But I did ignore a couple of tons of nuance in saying that.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by alasdair_ on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:48PM (#35427112)
AR can also lead with more engagement in the world. Remember when, for a moment, Pokemon GO had groups of complete strangers walking outside together and sharing an experience in the real world?
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by Pulcinella on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:53PM (#35427210)
The major AR part of Pokémon Go is the geolocation features of Pokémon and game locations in the real world. Most players turned off the AR camera mode after about 5 minutes or so because it makes the game more annoying to play and uses more battery power.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by barbazoo on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:05PM (#35427429)
BC, Canada, occasionally I still see people meet up trying to catch em all. Although I don't know how much it is really meeting up and how much is having to be in the same location because that's where a particular pokemon is. Obviously I have no idea how any of that works but it's fun to imagine.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by fossuser on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:51PM (#35427182)
Not only that - the UX does too. Instead of looking hunched over at little glass displays you're looking at the world and interacting with it more directly.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by JohnFen on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:06PM (#35427438)
> you're looking at the world and interacting with it more directly.

Only sorta. What you're really doing is taking the real world and reducing to an electronic simulacrum of the real world.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by fossuser on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:51PM (#35428330)
Not if the AR is really good, probably better than what it will be initially. I’m not talking about AR goggle pass through.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by JohnFen on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:25PM (#35430754)
How is it possible that it's not a simulacrum of the real world? It seems to me that how good it is doesn't actually enter into it. You're still putting a physical barrier between you and the world.

We see this happen even when AR isn't involved. Just looking through a window introduces a separation between you and the real world. That separation matters a whole lot to people, and changes how people think about, perceive, and react to what they see.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by fossuser on Monday April 03, 2023 @04:36PM (#35430903)
When you look through your eye glasses are you seeing a simulacrum of the real world?

If it’s the same, but you can do hand gestures to interact with UI that appears and disappears does that change things?

Maybe you think so given your example of a window. Indoors is still the real world to me.

It’s adding a software UX layer on top that could be more natural than the UX via small displays.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by subpixel on Monday April 03, 2023 @12:54PM (#35427215)
For pokemons.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by polar8 on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:02PM (#35427370)
So are iPhones, but they're also tremendously profitable.
Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by throw7 on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:12PM (#35427556)
The way Cook describes AR is not something I want ("dropping the digital world into your reality").

I just want better devices that help or augment my current senses (like with current things like sunglasses/hearing aids/etc things like: I have astigmatism and a reduction of headlight "starring" would be welcome. A zoom feature for reading small print. (my eyes suck can't you tell? :) Thermal scan and enemy detection a'la predator.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by entropea on Monday April 03, 2023 @01:43PM (#35428131)
I disagree. I started playing VRChat during the pandemic and it made me find a VR 'underground' EDM rave type group that I've spent thousands of hours with. Events in a AAA game studio level map are held every other weekend. Now I do side work with that same group that runs a 350+ person in real life VRChat rave in multiple cities every few months where tens of dozens of my VRChat friends show up and we spend a weekend together. VR has done the opposite of make me antisocial.

As a natural introvert, it is one of the best things to happen to me, and the most social I have ever been in my life.

Re:Apple's Tim Cook says AR and VR headsets are for connecti... by outworlder on Monday April 03, 2023 @05:01PM (#35431225)
Odd, given that teenagers will often go to a friend's house to play.