Re:Ask HN: I've built an ethical pornsite, should I make it ...
by turtleyacht on Sunday April 02, 2023 @08:40PM
(#35417087)
Er... It sounds like the comment above condones outright software theft. I do oppose that.
If an HN comment discusses an idea that could help in a personal software project, I would want to try my own implementation.
I don't mean go to the (possibly GPL'd) repo and just copy-paste everything.
At the same time, if it's my own project--even so a business plan, an investment strategy, or hardware schematic--attribute the credits, and go try it out.
The reason I'm on the fence with starting out proprietary or with the first commit including the LICENSE is that the latter is safest; and, it's easier to build with the intent to share from the start, then to clean it up later, even if it's never open-sourced.
But if it's exercise 7 of chapter 4 from a textbook, it's harder to predict a large, popular project grew out of that. Adding a license to everything seems overkill. Disciplined, but overkill.
If an HN comment discusses an idea that could help in a personal software project, I would want to try my own implementation.
I don't mean go to the (possibly GPL'd) repo and just copy-paste everything.
At the same time, if it's my own project--even so a business plan, an investment strategy, or hardware schematic--attribute the credits, and go try it out.
The reason I'm on the fence with starting out proprietary or with the first commit including the LICENSE is that the latter is safest; and, it's easier to build with the intent to share from the start, then to clean it up later, even if it's never open-sourced.
But if it's exercise 7 of chapter 4 from a textbook, it's harder to predict a large, popular project grew out of that. Adding a license to everything seems overkill. Disciplined, but overkill.