News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by str3wer on Saturday April 01, 2023 @04:42PM (#35403875)
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by MuffinFlavored on Saturday April 01, 2023 @04:50PM (#35403938)
> He was never prosecuted for causing harm or bodily injury and no victim was named at trial.

didn't he pay for a would-have-been hit to get somebody killed but it was actually an FBI agent (aka he got set up and fell for the trap)?

> Ross was not convicted of selling drugs or illegal items himself, but was held responsible for what others sold on the site.

isn't that arguably worse? he helped people in a lot of countries break the law (created a place where illegal sales can be facilitated)

it isn't like he moderated them off the platform. it was almost exclusively the entire purpose of the platform.

Judge : Unfortunately for you, the line you crossed was real and the plants you brought with you were illegal, so your bail is twenty thousand dollars.

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0221027/characters/nm0528147

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by CommitSyn on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:37PM (#35404346)
He was never prosecuted for it. AFAIK they didn't even really bring it up.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by xapata on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:51PM (#35404466)
Isn't that a common theme for certain kinds of criminals? I remember reading that organized crime bosses are often prosecuted for tax fraud rather than the violent crimes they're also (presumed) guilty of.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by adastra22 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @01:51AM (#35407596)
It was a major factor in sentencing, which is the issue at stake here.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by CommitSyn on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:42PM (#35413764)
I guess I have to look into it more, because I didn't think you could be sentenced for something you weren't convicted of.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by adastra22 on Sunday April 02, 2023 @02:51PM (#35413837)
He wasn’t sentenced for it, but rather it was mentioned as the reason for the maximum punishment being doled out for the nonviolent crimes he was convicted of. Which, yes, is still extremely suspect because he never got his day in court to address that allegation, and I think his appeals are based more on altering that prejudicial sentencing rather than the conviction itself.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by SamPatt on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:51PM (#35404460)
>didn't he pay for a would-have-been hit to get somebody killed but it was actually an FBI agent (aka he got set up and fell for the trap)?

I don't know, did he?

The government dropped those charges, and then when his defense team tried to present evidence defending him from those allegations (note that two federal agents eventually went to jail for their corruption during this case) the judge wouldn't allow them to present their evidence.

Basically, he never got a chance to defend himself from that allegation. Yet it was used at his sentencing to show he deserved life in prison (for non-violent crimes).

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by mike_d on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:03PM (#35404570)
> for non-violent crimes

I get that a lot of people like to smoke weed and maybe do mushrooms at Coachella, but not all drugs are the same.

Silkroad and other darknet markets sell everything from date rape drugs to fentanyl. Framing it as facilitating a harmless or victimless crime is disingenuous. Not to mention the ancillary services that often pop up like counterfeit documents, money laundering services, guides and tools for scamming people, and other crap.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by SamPatt on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:30PM (#35404801)
Silk Road had rules against selling certain things, which included tools for fraud.

Drugs shouldn't be illegal. Prohibition has always failed.

Regardless, he didn't commit violence. The distinction between violent and non-violent crime is a meaningful one, and I strongly oppose his life sentencing.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by mike_d on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:49PM (#35404971)
> The distinction between violent and non-violent crime is a meaningful one

Consider someone who knowingly brokered a sale of baby formula that they knew was tainted with rat poison and killed dozens of children, would you consider that a non-violent crime that deserves leniency in sentencing?

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by vitehozonage on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:32AM (#35408410)
Silk Road would not allow such a product
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by Genbox on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:16PM (#35404685)
> isn't that arguably worse? he helped people in a lot of countries break the law (created a place where illegal sales can be facilitated)

The logic is not sound.

1. If someone started selling drugs using someones GitHub/GitLab issue tracker, would the project owner be accountable? I understand that Ross was likely well aware about the drug sales on his website, but saying someone is facilitating the activities because they own the place is not a great argument in isolation.

2. What is illigal is very different different from country to country. A majority of the sales on Silk Road was marihuana, which is now legal in a 21 US states and decriminalized in 10 others. There are countries where it has never been illigal. Personal posession of AR-15 is legal in the USA, but illigal in a lot of other countries. Suffice to say that it is pretty subjective.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by nimbius on Saturday April 01, 2023 @04:54PM (#35403963)
"Ross was not convicted of selling drugs or illegal items himself, but was held responsible for what others sold on the site."

Ultimately the sentence reflects the governments urgent, non negotiable and final position as arbiter of trade in its capitalist economy. Without this stringent check the market would be free to sell everything from bootleg kidneys to child slaves.

This sort of libertarian absolutionist malarkey is how we wound up with Bolshevik terrorist attacks and pinkerman slaughters.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by deadletters on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:05PM (#35404058)
What is a pinkerman
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by lockhouse on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:14PM (#35404134)
I think they were referring to the Pinkertons.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinkerton_(detective_agency)

They have a colorful history of at one point being hired guns and were used by companies to violently end labor strikes.

Interestingly enough the Pinkerton agency still exists.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by kadoban on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:46PM (#35404414)
> Interestingly enough the Pinkerton agency still exists.

They're still scummy union-busting pieces of shit as well.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by deadletters on Monday April 10, 2023 @12:56PM (#35514421)
I think you mean Pinkerman
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by jmainguy on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:12PM (#35404108)
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by deadletters on Monday April 10, 2023 @12:57PM (#35514424)
That says Pinkerton not Pinkerman
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by xapata on Saturday April 01, 2023 @05:53PM (#35404480)
In a weird way, a skim of your comment reads as the opposite of what I think you intended, after I read it twice.
Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by acapybara on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:11PM (#35404642)
GPT-generated comment.

These aren't supposed to be on hn.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by bdcravens on Saturday April 01, 2023 @06:57PM (#35405027)
He (or his admins) created the categories, many of which have the reasonable assumption of illegality. You can't claim plausible deniability for your users selling cocaine when you literally created a category called Cocaine.

https://astr0baby.files.wordpress.com/2017/09/sr-01.png

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by KyeRussell on Saturday April 01, 2023 @07:20PM (#35405218)
One has to be the most deranged and deluded sort of idiot libertarian to think that Ross doesn’t deserve to rot away in prison.

It’s not a matter of how one feels about drug policy or even financial / identity fraud.

He wasn’t just a kid that helped people sell drugs online.

Anyone that begins to spout this BS I assume either doesn’t know the full extent of the Silk Road story (which is inexcusable given its immense media coverage) or is a sheltered “you should just be able to do anything mahn” haven’t-really-thought-about-it-for-more-than-one-second libertarian.

Re:U.S. Government Sold $216M of Seized Silk Road Bitcoin Th... by vitehozonage on Sunday April 02, 2023 @04:39AM (#35408450)
I know about it deeply and would say you are the one that doesn't know enough about it you actually believe the propaganda I can only assume you are talking about