The shift to remote work has enabled replacing most of those effectively virtualized staff with AI agents that never sleep. Their takeover won't put those people back in offices, it obsoletes them to unemployed couch-potatoes. Likely notified of their new employment status via AI agent on a Zoom call....
During that time period (beginning of time to now), things actually have fallen apart, many times.
So what? What you say would be true even of all the predictions were right, but just 1% less in magnitude. It's setting an unreasonably high bar.
A lot of people don't want to think about the harm that their enthusiasms could cause, and are eager to discredit anything that isn't a rose-tinted assessment because it's a threat to their fun or ambition.
AI will be great for those who already have money, and they'll be the ones writing the history of its effects.
I’m not being dismissive of your fears here. It’s not like what people are talking about is impossible. But there isn’t much you or I can do about it at the top and generally the economy doesn’t crash a la 2007 every time a big shake up happens. So if you’re really concerned about it, do the best you can to insulate yourself from it and inform yourself about the possibilities to a reasonable degree. But we can’t sit here and agonize over every potential doom and gloom situation that could happen on any given day, especially when tons of times what people talk about on HN, the news, wherever, never come to pass or are not nearly as bad as predicted. It’s just no way to live.
Often the companies buy property themselves, to use (since rents have been so high in he last decade or so). I don’t think banks are over-represented as owners, at least where I live. But I might be wrong.
Why is it that US banks are owning so much commercial real estate?
If the holding company can't rent out the property, at some point they stop being able to service the debt. This leaves the banks with a lot of illiquid assets and bad debt...
So when cap rates double the implied value of the building falls by 50%. Effectively the building goes from being valued at a P/E of 50 (cap rate 2%) to a P/E of 25 (cap rate of 4%).
So the halving of the building's value, as cap rates move in response to interest rates, may mean that a 50% LTV loan is now underwater. Especially if the building is unoccupied or may soon be unoccupied.
But the looming CRE crisis isn’t making it into the mainstream consciousness, even though its big driver (WFH and its ramified impact) is being well reported on.
Most of the entities on the hook for paying back the bank are commercial real estate development firms. As such they often have a mixed portfolio of residential (think apartments), office, retail, and entertainment properties. Offices are further divided into small business, professional services (doctors, dentist), and general office space. Unless their portfolio is extremely focused and not diversified, then they'll be alright.
Fortune 500 companies also aren't letting go of their iconic office buildings, as the building itself is an icon for the company.
Given all these factors, I think the idea that commercial real estate is going to crash and burn and that the banks are going to be left holding the bag are being quite a bit overblown.
The CRE bubble is going to burst in the next 18 months as the 5-year commercial office leases signed in 2017+ are all going to come to an end, and the banks will be realizing these losses starting now and the next few years. Its going to get ugly soon.