That said, it seems to me that we haven't reached the limits of the machine part of the human-machine moderation team. Voting up and down (here on HN, on Stack Exchange, Slashdot, etc.) is fine, but pretty rudimentary, for example. I'm wondering if there are any others experimenting with more heavily algorithmic moderation.
I wonder what approach, if any, Quora will take to the potential of meta-pollution.
As you say, it's perfectly possible to build a good community if you're willing to put some work into it. People who run community-oriented sites mostly know this by now.
But a lot of sites pick up communities accidentally. Blogs tend to have comments enabled by default. Adding a forum to a site sometimes seems like a simple idea that will make users happy. Social networking features seem like a must have for some kinds of web apps, even if they aren't the main focus. And of course, these accidental communities inevitably decay until the reek of them spreads through the whole site.
I think a lot of people are remembering that they didn't actually want to run communities in the first place. They added community features because it was the path of least resistance, and now that they've seen where it leads, they're turning them off rather than sinking a lot of effort into making them work.
I'm pretty happy with the development, personally. The communities I like are going to stick around, and as for the others, well, there are more than enough places to have flamewars already.
(Disclaimer: I turned off comments on my own blog a couple of months ago. It's made me a happier person, but I may be projecting just a bit.)
All these people here making earnest suggestions about building comunities - you really should think about what went on here. Communities occur when people have something in common they care about, I doubt historic letters was ever going to be one of those. A community of people who collect historic letters? Perhaps. A community of people who just read them from time to time? Don't be so stupid.
That said, there is a way to motivate speakers to speak well, substantially, and with respect: convince them that there's something in it for them if they do. "Reputation points" are only loosely coupled to the real prize here at HN: civil discussion between bona fide hackers about the topics we are interested in. This is very hard to find, and extremely valuable.
What people want:
What you have to do: The internet is clearly still an incredible communication platform, but it is by no means a human utopia, or even an opportunity for one. If you want to build a good community, you have to do just that. Build it. The internet is rarely going to just give it too you. And your community will without a doubt rot as time goes on if you don't pay attention.