News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by daydream on Thursday March 30, 2023 @08:49PM (#35380911)
Tube amps are used in both creating music (guitar amps, bass amps, etc) and listening to music (hifi preamps, power amps, etc).

Tube amps used in creating music usually have a distinctive sound. Fender Twin Reverb and Ampeg SVT are but two of the many tube amps with a distinctive sound. Solid state amps typically have a very different sound.

Yes, there are digital amp simulators and yes they are very good nowadays. But lots of musicians want the real thing.

That may not appeal to you, and you may dismiss it, but that’s the case. People generally aren’t buying an expensive tube guitar amp because they think they’re rare - tube amps are not hard to find. They’re buying them because they like the sound.

Tubes in hifi equipment is a whole other ballgame. No comment on that one.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by wilsonnb3 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @09:58PM (#35381440)
> They’re buying them because they like the sound.

You’re giving guitar players too much credit, they are only one step below “audiophiles” in their love for snake oil and marketing.

Tube amps persist mostly because guitar players instinctively turn their nose up at solid state, due to tubes having been the state of the art when the first generation of world famous electric guitarists was young.

Bass players are slightly better, mostly because an SVT head weighs 80 pounds and nobody wants to lug them around.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by temporallobe on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:37PM (#35381773)
I use both solid state and tube amps, and for vastly different use cases. I use a small 7-watt tube amp for my studio setup, and it does has a much different feel and tone than any of my emulators or solid state amps. Although amp sims and cab IRs are getting incredibly good these days, there’s just that inimitable magical spark that tube amps have. There’s also nothing quite like a maxed tube amp, which has so-called power amp distortion.

On the other hand, tube amps are a PIA and are prone to having those delicate tubes shake their innards apart if jostled the wrong way, not to mention their backbreaking heft. Therefore I use a solid state/modeler amp on stage, because of far better reliability, weight reduction, and versatility. Now there are even pedal amps, with class D power amps built in, so guitarists need only bring their pedalboard and maybe a cab. But when it comes to recording, most studios are still gonna prefer genuine, preferably vintage, tube amps.

Nobody really gives a shit about your tone on stage anyway.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by billjings on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:48PM (#35382295)
Guitar tone is built on breakup, and solid state did not break up like tubes. Not for a long time, at least - arguably FET transistors do a good job, but you still don't get the sag that a tube rectified AB amp yields when cranked.

The only reason that solid state is now catching up to tube nowadays is that:

* Front of house tech and home recording has made riding cranked amp tone live in a live environment a hassle, both technically and in terms of achieving the sounds that are being recorded

* Solid state can credibly emulate tube tone now (this has happened on things like tube compressors, too)

Having said all that, any time spent in the guitar pedal market (particularly around dirt boxes) will convince anyone that guitarists are indeed, as you say, total suckers for snake oil and marketing. :)

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by coldpie on Friday March 31, 2023 @09:22AM (#35386766)
> You’re giving guitar players too much credit, they are only one step below “audiophiles” in their love for snake oil and marketing. Tube amps persist mostly because guitar players instinctively turn their nose up at solid state

I agree with you, but I think solid state amps have only been "good" for the last 5-10 years, which is a pretty short time to change everyone's mind, habits, and equipment. So be gentle :)

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by dataviz1000 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:17PM (#35381614)
I was reading a Wall Street Journal article about Taylor Swift's wealth today. The journalist pointed out something interesting, one of the biggest sources of income for Taylor Swift is vinyl record sales. She sold close to a 1,000,000 vinyl records of the Midnights album in 2022 each costing around $27. Moreover, vinyl record sales have increased year over year for the past 17 years. I suspect that the people who are purchasing Taylor Swift vinyl records might also be interested in purchasing vacuum tube preamps.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by Clamchop on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:45PM (#35381829)
Some, maybe. But I think most buyers won't ever own a turntable.

Vinyl records are merch and you don't need any reason to buy one beyond wanting a keepsake with more interest than a poster.

I think there's something to be said about the overlap of Taylor Swift fans with audiophiles, too.

Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by analog31 on Thursday March 30, 2023 @11:49PM (#35382303)
Can't easily copy a vinyl record.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by nl on Friday March 31, 2023 @12:24AM (#35382526)
I know a bunch of teenage kids who buy vinyl. They get them for the atheistics and as a objet d'art, and tend to listen to the music more via spotify than using the vinyl.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by dataviz1000 on Friday March 31, 2023 @05:08PM (#35393686)
Reading further, only half the people who buy vinyl have a record player.
Re:One Man’s Quest to Revive the Great American Vacuum Tube by jpmattia on Thursday March 30, 2023 @10:44PM (#35381826)
> Tube amps used in creating music usually have a distinctive sound. Fender Twin Reverb and Ampeg SVT are but two of the many tube amps with a distinctive sound. Solid state amps typically have a very different sound.

It's worth noting: The nonlinearities in the tube amps are very different from the solid-state amps. So the right thing to compare it to is one of the newer digital sims with an appropriate IR response, scanned over different input strengths to simulate the nonlinearities.

And I say this as someone with a 70s vintage Fender Twin Reverb: The emulators are really good.