News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @02:40AM (#3537099)
At best, forcing developing countries to adhere to our labor standards would create a privileged labor aristocracy, leaving the poor majority no better off.

I'm tired of this apologist bullshit. It's been showing up in HN articles for weeks now.

Yes, I understand the concept that the standard and cost of living are lower in China. I understand that it may be better to have children working than starving on the streets. I understand that rural farm life in China is terrible.

That is absolutely no excuse for keeping people in near-slave conditions. That is no excuse for allowing people to be maimed (by machinery and by non-stop repetitive, back-to-back 12 - 16 hour shifts) with no compensation. That is no excuse for allowing people to be blacklisted if they make any complaint about working conditions.

Apple is now sitting on $100 billion and still telling us that their products could never be manufactured in the US. Hilariously, one reason they cite is that you can't find a fab plant right next to a glass plant. Guess what? Build them both in the US, pay reasonable US wages, and provide reasonable US working conditions.

If Apple's success requires that 8,000 people be put instantly onto production lines for insanely long shifts, day after day until their bodies fall apart, then their products should not exist.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by AllenKids on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @04:46AM (#3537333)
It's all so emotional isn't it?

If you rage harder maybe our Chinese people's life would magically become better.

Or in fact you do not care as long as your shinny new toys are isolated from the poverty and suffering of the rest of the world and manufactured in your sunshine and rainbow and god's chosen America.

Apple's success enabled Foxconn and other suppliers to employ literally millions of Chinese people, millions of otherwise poorer people to each send home $3000+ dollers per year.

It's ugly, it could be better, some aspects of the factory life need immediate improvement even by Chinese standard, on humanitarian reasons alone.

It has nothing to do with Apple's 100B reserve. It's not that Apple can not afford it. It's my country, China, with its vast under educated labor surplus can not afford the US dream, can not abandon low value add manufacturing industry.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @01:45PM (#3539309)
Or in fact you do not care as long as your shinny new toys are isolated from the poverty and suffering of the rest of the world and manufactured in your sunshine and rainbow and god's chosen America.

Instead of being a dick, why don't you read what I've written more closely?

Manufacturing in the US is just one option, which I suggest because they insist that they can't possibly do anything to improve labor conditions at the Chinese factories.

China, with its vast under educated labor surplus can not afford the US dream, can not abandon low value add manufacturing industry.

Nobody is saying China should abandon its manufacturing industry. People are saying that labor conditions should be better. This can be done without destroying China's manufacturing sector.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by AllenKids on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @02:48PM (#3539567)
I'm an asshole, not a dick. Mind you.

Apple can and is trying to improve the labor conditions at its supply chain. That's the whole point of its annul report. Foxconn is trying too. Those companies' primary goal is money, suicide workers cost a lot of money. Bad PR cost a lot of money.

What's impossible is suddenly western standard living, what's impossible is immediate strict labor law enforcement, what's impossible is working condition the same level as in the US.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @03:51PM (#3539865)
What's impossible is suddenly western standard living

Why do you, and others, keep bringing this up as if anyone asked for that?

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by AllenKids on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @05:33PM (#3540400)
Because in almost every article about Chinese Labor practice it was filled with details describing how horrible those dormitory livings were, using colorful words like slave-labor, soul-crushing etc.

But to a lot of Chinese people, living in the complex certainly is not nice, but not unimaginably horrid either. I spent half of my college years with 7 other dudes in a room about 130 sqft, for example.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Thursday February 02, 2012 @03:53AM (#3542003)
I think you need to read more about the conditions at Foxconn.

In college, you weren't doing mind-numbing 12 - 16 hour shifts, the same actions day after day after day until your body failed. You weren't blacklisted for complaining to whoever ran the facility. You weren't maimed by machinery and subsequently completely ignored.

There is a lot to be done that has absolutely nothing to do with a "western standard of living".

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by JanezStupar on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @04:45AM (#3537332)
But this kind of a mechanism is what allowed Europe and Japan to rise after destruction of WW2.

Both my parents were working in worse conditions as these Foxconn workers (I know that these are some of the better jobs in China) through 50's and 60's.

When you're poor only hard work, smarts and luck can help you out. The harder you work, the smarter and luckier you are - better the odds.

Look how much these (Foxconn) wages have risen in last 5 years - 100% if I'm right. On the other hand Foxconn is already working on increasing the automation of their pants.

Be careful. Road to hell is paved with good intentions.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @01:13PM (#3539163)
That argument has no merit. The United States kept slaves for 150 years. It doesn't mean that we should tolerate it when another nation repeats the same mistake, particularly when a US company is funding them.

Look how much these (Foxconn) wages have risen in last 5 year

Everyone is obsessing on wages. Let me state yet again: I don't care about wages, so long as their livable in the region. I care about working conditions.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by JanezStupar on Thursday February 02, 2012 @04:22AM (#3542044)
I strongly advise you to leave whatever comfortable western nation you are living in and go on a walkabout for a while.

Hell, you are free to go and build a company that will do better.

What you lack is the perspective of these workers. Foxconn assembly job is an opportunity equivalent to a Ivy League diploma for most of these workers.

They have no intention to work this job 10-20 years. This is Chinese rural equivalent of doing a startup. Work for 2-3 years, build a nest egg, go to school/start your own business.

And working/living conditions are actually pretty good for Asian standards. No chemicals, clean environment. Yes hours are long, labor is hard, but the pay is phenomenal.

Let me finish with an anecdote. My neighbors grandfather was a emigrant miner for twenty years. He always told his wife, that when he made enough money, they would return to home country and she would never have to work. They did and bought a property with some land. One day they were working in the field and the wife complained that he promised she wouldn't have to work. He paused, looked her in the eye and said: "Honey, this is not work."

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by MarkMc on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @06:58AM (#3537564)
I don't understand your argument. I agree that Apple could move production back to the US and still be quite profitable. But wouldn't that mean that thousands of Chinese workers would be worse off?
Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @01:38PM (#3539279)
That's not what I'm saying at all. Those are simply two options. The option to produce in the US is followed naturally from their own claims, and is countered by more lies and rationalizations.

Hippie: "Hey Apple, why don't you require that suppliers improve labor conditions in their factories?"

Apple response 1) "We can't pay Chinese workers what American workers make!"

Hippe: "Okay, fine, but I wasn't talking about wages. I was talking about labor conditions. Stop working people on ridiculously long shifts, doing the same thing day in, and day out, until they're maimed. Stop blacklisting people with valid complaints."

Apple response 2) "We can't raise wages, that would create a local aristocracy!"

Hippie: "Again, I'm not talking about wages, so long as they're livable in the region. I'm talking about labor conditions. Also, what exactly would be wrong with a local aristocracy? Management always says that a rising tide lifts all boats as it pays itself a healthy bonus, after all."

Hippie: "Okay, Apple, since you refuse to pursue reasonable working conditions in China, why don't you manufacture in the US, according to US standards of pay and treatment?"

Apple: "Oh, no, no, we couldn't do that! The US doesn't have the manufacturing ability. We need a fabrication facility next door to a glass facility!"

Hippie: "You have $100 billion. You can build both in, say, North Carolina."

Apple: "No, no, American workers don't have the work ethic that is necessary to produce Apple products. Besides, China educates the mid-level engineers that we need to manage factory floors."

Hippie: "By work ethic, you mean the ability to rouse 8,000 people from corporate housing and immediately put them to work on back-to-back 16 hour shifts, all because you couldn't get your engineering spec done in a reasonable time? And wasn't I just reading about how there are a large number of unemployed, middle-aged Americans who have experience managing factories floors, who can't find work because such factories no longer exist?"

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by dgregd on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @03:20AM (#3537182)
"That is absolutely no excuse for keeping people in near-slave conditions."

Sure, just few clicks in Foxconn payroll system and problem solved. But Chinese don't want to do that because they are evil.

Sorry for this harsh comment. I'm from post communist country and I'm also tired of that kind of thinking.

IMHO the real reason why people support the idea of Apple boycott is that 8000 high wages engineering jobs has been moved to China. But it more political correct to talk about poop labor standards, etc.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @03:49AM (#3537245)
But Chinese don't want to do that because they are evil.

No idea what you're talking about with that line.

This isn't simply about pay. It's about terrible working conditions. It's about the fact that Steve Jobs told Obama that his products could never be produced in the US because, apparently, his products require horrible working conditions in order to be produced.

Frankly, I could care less what they get paid, so long as it's a livable wage in their region. What I care about is that employees are not stuck doing the exact same thing, day in and day out, until they're maimed by machinery or repetitive stress injuries. I care that people have a way to air their grievances without fear of blacklisting.

8000 high wages engineering jobs has been moved to China

They have? The 8,000 I read about were assembly line workers, not engineers.

As for moving jobs overseas, I take issue with Apple claiming that they have to due to a lack of manufacturing facilities when they have $100 billion in the bank.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by coob on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @04:24AM (#3537296)
> It's about the fact that Steve Jobs told Obama that his products could never be produced in the US because, apparently, his products require horrible working conditions in order to be produced.

Except if you read the bio, that's apparently not the reason he gave. It's because there are far more mid-level engineers over there. Not quite degree standard, but good enough to oversee production processes.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by dgregd on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @06:04AM (#3537469)
Copied from the nytimes article.

"Apple’s executives had estimated that about 8,700 industrial engineers were needed to oversee and guide the 200,000 assembly-line workers"

"Mr. Saragoza, an engineer, quickly moved up the plant’s ranks and joined an elite diagnostic team. His salary climbed to $50,000. He and his wife had three children. They bought a home with a pool."

"The worker, Lina Lin, is a project manager in Shenzhen, China"

"Mrs. Lin earns a bit less than what Mr. Saragoza was paid by Apple ... She and her husband put a quarter of their salaries in the bank every month."

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by ralfd on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @10:45AM (#3538382)
The crucial bit in the NYTimes article:

> The company’s analysts had forecast it would take as long as nine months to find that many qualified engineers in the United States. In China, it took 15 days.

Nine months vs 15 days.

Also many didn't get the point from the article, that the benefit in producing in China isn't any longer low cost labor, but because it is so big and the whole world produces there it developed enormous long-term advantages in flexibility and infrastructure. Like the silicon valley attracted and fueled programming jobs/companies, just because other computer firms are nearby. The hundreds of factories/suppliers in China, the short distance to high-tech firms in Taiwan, South korea, Japan etc, make it a hub to which manufacturing gravitates.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by georgieporgie on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @01:55PM (#3539356)
the benefit in producing in China isn't any longer low cost labor, but because it is so big and the whole world produces there it developed enormous long-term advantages in flexibility and infrastructure.

From the same article:

People will carry this phone in their pocket, he said. People also carry their keys in their pocket. “I won’t sell a product that gets scratched,” he said tensely. The only solution was using unscratchable glass instead. “I want a glass screen, and I want it perfect in six weeks.”

(later)

In mid-2007, after a month of experimentation, Apple’s engineers finally perfected a method for cutting strengthened glass so it could be used in the iPhone’s screen. The first truckloads of cut glass arrived at Foxconn City in the dead of night, according to the former Apple executive. That’s when managers woke thousands of workers, who crawled into their uniforms — white and black shirts for men, red for women — and quickly lined up to assemble, by hand, the phones. Within three months, Apple had sold one million iPhones. Since then, Foxconn has assembled over 200 million more.

So, because Apple engineers did a shoddy job designing their screen (which scratched in Jobs' pocket), a relentless pace was set over six weeks to put in new glass.

How does HN feel when their boss says, "oh, hey, you know that six month project we've been working on? Yeah, we're going to have to change this, this, this, and this, oh, and we still have to meet next week's deadline. See you over the weekend."

Why is it acceptable that Apple's shortsightedness "required" these insane working conditions?

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by hahainternet on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @03:19AM (#3537178)
I agree entirely. I wish I could pen a stronger endorsement.

There's a not so subtle undercurrent of privilege that runs through a lot of the apologist postings and it drives me mad.

Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by mike_esspe on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @03:07AM (#3537158)
Do you think this 8000 workers would be better of unemployed?
Re:The Apple Boycott: People Are Spouting Nonsense about Chi... by LearnYouALisp on Wednesday February 01, 2012 @03:11AM (#3537168)
"Unde non sequitur..."