I got it from my notes for an unrelated project. You can't find it because I wrote the notes. But this shouldn't matter. As long as the points are correct, you getting schooled by an AI is irrelevant to the conversation at hand.
>It’s disingenuous to make an overly general statement and then immediately dismiss any counterexample to that overgeneralization by saying “there are always exceptions”.
No it's not. General truths exist. You must dismiss exceptions to get at the general truth. Otherwise we'll be mired in details constantly.
>Denmark is a market economy.
I never said it wasn't. I said "closest" to a socialist economy.
>A common misconception. In reality, they are market economies that combine a dynamic free market economy with a generous welfare state.
No misconception made here. You are putting words in my mouth. I said it was closest to socialism. And it holds true. A generous welfare state is closer to socialism.
>The Heritage Foundation publishes an “Economic Freedom Index” that ranks countries by “economic freedom”, according to their own conservative, pro-free-market point of view, and they rank Denmark and Sweden as more economically free than the United States
That's bullshit. The heritage foundation is a conservative think tank with a biased agenda. How about getting a study from an unbiased source. "Economic Freedom Index" << don't fall for that.
Check out which countries rank the highest for food regulations: https://www.fooddocs.com/post/food-safety-standards
The US isn't even on that list because we've lobbied the hell out of those laws to be lax af.
Not to mention labor regulations, mandatory five week vacations? Paternity leave? Unheard of in the US.
Just use some common sense before trusting some "Freedom" Index from a politicized foundation.
>So then how do you explain the regulatory crippling of nuclear power?
It's an exception. I mean I literally gave you tons of examples how the US fails to regulate things. The ratio of failures to successes is what matters here. And the failures outnumber the successes by a huge amount. I only copied a fraction of my notes. Would you like more?
The points don't specifically pertain to the US and have enough garbage weasel words that they don't even rise to the level of "correct". I'll make another comment that goes through them though.
> General truths exist. You must dismiss exceptions to get at the general truth. Otherwise we'll be mired in details constantly.
You can't just handwave away complexity. It's entirely possible for the US to have too little regulation in some fields and too much regulation in other fields.
Your claim is that it's impossible for the US to erect regulatory barriers for AI. Whether or not the US, in general, has more or less regulations than other countries isn't sufficient to make that case.
> The heritage foundation is a conservative think tank with a biased agenda.
I never claimed otherwise. But why would a conservative think tank, which favors less business regulations, not even put the US on the top ten list of most "economically free" countries if the US is so underregulated? Why would they prefer the regulatory environment in Denmark and Sweden over the regulatory environment in the United States?
> Check out which countries rank the highest for food regulations
So when I bring up examples they're "exceptions", but while you bring up examples, they're examples of the rule. When I cite sources that do an overall survey of a country's regulatory environment, that's "biased", but when you cite a source that makes their money by helping companies comply with food regulations, that's just fine.
> Not to mention labor regulations, mandatory five week vacations? Paternity leave? Unheard of in the US.
Yeah, there are some places where the US has more regulations and some places where the US has less regulations.
If we're talking about regulating AI, I think nuclear energy regulations are a much more analogous case than vacation and paternity leave.
> It's an exception. I mean I literally gave you tons of examples how the US fails to regulate things. The ratio of failures to successes is what matters here. And the failures outnumber the successes by a huge amount. I only copied a fraction of my notes. Would you like more?
I can run ChatGPT myself, thanks. Why don't you try thinking for yourself and considering the possibility that your presuppositions are wrong?
I didn't handwave anything. My answer is sufficiently complex with multitudes of counter examples to your point.
The whole thing with the massive list of examples is to illustrate a general point on the lack of business regulation overall in the US.
I literally stated it's the ratio of failures to successes that matters here. If I can produce 30 examples of the US failing to regulate and you produce one, that speaks to an overall generality that eclipses your example.
The arena of scientific validation is hard to establish here. Neither of us can paint a picture of the entire domain of every single failure and success of regulatory laws in existence for the US. So given the nature of this debate just list as many general examples as possible.
You have nuclear power as one, that's it.
>I never claimed otherwise. But why would a conservative think tank, which favors less business regulations, not even put the US on the top ten list of most "economically free" countries if the US is so underregulated? Why would they prefer the regulatory environment in Denmark and Sweden over the regulatory environment in the United States?
Don't know. The motivations of such groups are complex and multifaceted. Following some breadcrumb trail to get at the root of it is too much effort. I only know that this group is biased and not a neutral party. There's no point in vetting a known compromised source. Pick a valid one.
>So when I bring up examples they're "exceptions", but while you bring up examples, they're examples of the rule. When I cite sources that do an overall survey of a country's regulatory environment, that's "biased", but when you cite a source that makes their money by helping companies comply with food regulations, that's just fine.
Yeah you cited one bogus example from the heritage foundation. All my examples are real. Unlike yours.
>I can run ChatGPT myself, thanks. Why don't you try thinking for yourself and considering the possibility that your presuppositions are wrong?
Highly disagree. Your answers are inferior to anything chatGPT can come up with so obviously you likely can't run it yourself.
Your list produces nothing of the kind, as I tediously went out of my way to demonstrate.
> I only know that this group is biased and not a neutral party. There's no point in vetting a known compromised source. Pick a valid one.
You haven't provided any valid sources yourself.
> Highly disagree. Your answers are inferior to anything chatGPT can come up with so obviously you likely can't run it yourself.
Well, that's just your opinion, and it's an opinion that reflects more on your poor judgment than on me.
This: https://futureoflife.org/open-letter/pause-giant-ai-experime...
will never happen. No pause will occur. I'm right and you will be wrong.
If it does happen then I concede that you're right. If it doesn't then it reflects poorly on you.
No that is you. I've remained calm throughout this discussion. When have I made it personal? You're the one who made the initial comment "reflects poorly on you" so I reflected right back. It wasn't personal at all because what you said is factual. What you and I say here indeed does reflect on who you are. I don't take it personally and neither should you.
So let's see how this plays out with actual evidence. Nothing can be proven, but an actual data point is the furthest it can go. I'll keep this as a foot note on some date many years out on my calendar. Let's wait several years and see if there's ANY meaningful regulation on AI. That letter is the beginning push FOR regulation. The start of absolutely nothing in my opinion. When that date arrives I'll contact you here on HN, Phil Welch.
I don't want to ban you, so would you please review https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to the rules properly from now on? We don't want this sort of tit-for-tat spat in which people abuse each other.
It’s disingenuous to make an overly general statement and then immediately dismiss any counterexample to that overgeneralization by saying “there are always exceptions”. I could just as easily say the United States is chronically overregulated and your list of examples are the exceptions.
Where did you get that by the way? I can’t find any exact phrase matches online, and the writing style and overall glib superficiality reminds me of ChatGPT output. I’m not going to waste my time rebutting machine-generated garbage point by point, especially when half of it is meaningless weasel language about what “critics argue”.
Ultimately it doesn’t matter because if there are exceptions either way, then it’s still possible AI will be regulated.
> You kidding? Scandinavia is more or less a collection of countries closest to socialism.
A common misconception. In reality, they are market economies that combine a dynamic free market economy with a generous welfare state. Wikipedia even specifically lists as a characteristic of the “Nordic model”, “Little product market regulation. Nordic countries rank very high in product market freedom according to OECD rankings”(https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nordic_model). It also mentions this quote:
The Heritage Foundation publishes an “Economic Freedom Index” that ranks countries by “economic freedom”, according to their own conservative, pro-free-market point of view, and they rank Denmark and Sweden as more economically free than the United States, both in the general index and in the more specific index of “business freedom”, which seems to be the measure relevant to regulatory burden in particular (https://www.heritage.org/index/)> Given the sheer amount of counter examples of lack of regulation. It's pretty much safe to say that it's highly unlikely AI will be regulated in any meaningful way.
So then how do you explain the regulatory crippling of nuclear power?