Disagree. The first two objective clashes very much with each other. I have worked in teams that did that. And generally if anything non trivial is done without planning to just "make it work", it would be more often than not, ridden with many design issues which doesn't allow it to be good.
When folks have license to do good work, I usually see it going well. If they have some informed opinions & group wisdom at their disposal & which they leverage.
- My bank's website which is a decade old and has millions of users, has tons of issues. I am not even talking about UI or look. It randomly hangs, session disconnects etc.
- ERP tool of one of my previous org sucked, even though used by 10s of 1000s of people and having dedicated team in maintaining.
- One team that I worked with has no proper staging environment, and it would have required synced deployment of dozens of services with many teams working with different language and config. And just this simple task couldn't be completed even with push from upper management, just because of complexity.
Making it work means you start with barebones, just to have a proof of concept that runs, is accessible, is secured, even if you have to click things together and manually ssh into EC2s to launch code. Once you have everything working, then the bigger design should be a lot clearer, in terms of what you have to do to make it good.
Anecdotally, everytime someone tells me Kubernetes is overkill and then follows your approach. In a year they end up building the capabilities that come out of the box with Kubernetes, and of course they aren't as well thought out. Because they were done adhoc and as needed.
Absolutely painfully boring stack. I’m working at a place now with that stack and we haven’t had a single page in over a year now and we do 5 deploys a day ish.
1. Make it work
You can go from out of the box Debian listening on 22/80/443 directly on internet to WAF, intrusion detection, encrypted overlay networks with CA hierarchy and offline route keys, encryption at rest, elaborate IAM, hardware signed commits, full supply chain audits with every dependency vetted and vendored, multi-access-level logs, mandatory spyware on all corporate gear, and so on and so forth. For most businesses it's more of the former than the latter, and there's definitely no such thing as categorically "secure".
This is often from organizational or project management mis-coordination than technical choices the developers are fully aware of. Like a system’s owners not prioritizing putting events of interest into a message queue and insisting upon polling for the information on one end. And an offshore operations team saying learning how to support AWS Lambda/Azure Automation/GCP Cloud Functions is an added cost scope to the contract. So the developer is backed into a corner to run cron/SystemD-based polling off a small EC2. Thousands of decisions like this add up fast, and take a major executive committee commitment to root out tech debt and prevent new tech debt from accumulating to unsustainable levels to prevent cloud initiatives from sinking beneath a mire of expensive small decisions in pursuit of new accomplishments. It is a tough balancing act.
A much better approach is "1. Make it work 2. Make it good 3. Make it fast". Your initial prototypes need to define the core functionality, and then you incrementally build stuff on top of that.