News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Cigna Saves Millions by Having Its Doctors Reject Claims ... by resoluteteeth on Saturday March 25, 2023 @05:04PM (#35307332)
That just shows that the us has good medical treatment for people with essentially infinite money who don't have to worry about cost or insurance coverage so they can bypass the kind of issue the article is talking about entirely.

For normal Americans who actually have to worry about these things, healthcare in the us is a nightmare.

You can't just ignore insurance and judge the us healthcare system based on the best hospitals and doctors when most Americans aren't going to have access to that.

Re:Cigna Saves Millions by Having Its Doctors Reject Claims ... by cscurmudgeon on Saturday March 25, 2023 @08:54PM (#35309381)
> That just shows that the us has good medical treatment for people with essentially infinite money who don't have to worry about cost or insurance coverage so they can bypass the kind of issue the article is talking about entirely.

No, that shows that even in places with public healthcare, there are issues.

Universal public health care is not the utopia that its proponents religiously advocate for.

> You can't just ignore insurance and judge the us healthcare system based on the best hospitals and doctors when most Americans aren't going to have access to that.

Most Americans have insurance. You can't ignore real data. Are you from the US?

https://sgp.fas.org/crs/misc/IF10830.pdf

Only roughly 8% are uninsured.

> , healthcare in the us is a nightmare

Compared to the rest of the world? It is not.

US is not the top, but within the top 20.

https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/best-heal...

Re:Cigna Saves Millions by Having Its Doctors Reject Claims ... by resoluteteeth on Saturday March 25, 2023 @09:34PM (#35309712)
> Most Americans have insurance. You can't ignore real data. Are you from the US?

If you're judging the quality of healthcare based on whether people from the US have insurance or do not have insurance it shows that you're fundamentally failing to understand the type of problem the article is discussing, which in this case is specifically that insurance is broken and insurance companies will refuse to pay for treatment even when people have insurance. The people having Cigna refuse to pay for medical treatments as in the article obviously have insurance or they wouldn't be dealing with Cigna in the first place, so I'm not sure how "real data" on the percentage of americans who are insured could possibly refute that.

> Compared to the rest of the world? It is not.

This type of comparison also completely ignores the problems with health insurance that are causing people to avoid getting medical care in the first place or becoming bankrupt afterward.

Your original comment was responding to an article about one of the massive problems with health insurance in the US by pointing out that certain rich individuals from other countries choose to get treatment in the US as if this negates the premise of the article.

You are making a mistake that many americans appear to make: yes, if you completely ignore costs and problems with health insurance and have infinite money, you can get top notch medical treatment in the US.

However, my point was that the article is identifying a type of problem with the health insurance system that effectively makes that fact irrelevant.

It doesn't matter if the US theoretically provides the best treatment in the world to some people the health insurance system is now so broken that a huge percentage of the people can't afford medical treatment even with health insurance (which is absolutely going to be the case for most americans on bronze/silver health insurance plans).

This isn't a point you can respond to simply by noting that surgeons and hospitals are capable of providing some of the best medical treatment in the world.

The reality is that once you factor in the insurance system, and not just healthcare providers, the US health insurance does not look so great anymore. This is a problem that may be difficult to capture in terms of statistics on quality of care but it is a huge problem that is affecting a large percentage of americans.