This is a fuckin dog boarding company I work for, not a bank. Because no, you can't screw your customers a half penny at a time... it's on you to fix the accounting and make it right.
The issue isn't that it was executed at a higher price than expected or that it was "rounded up" in general. The issue is that for a single completed transaction, in one place (general app UI) it is reported to have executed at one price, and in another place (the data export process) it is reported at a different price.
Which is, of course, “swordfish.”
Both are bad, one is far worse.
> There is no legitimate scenario where they would be reporting the Net Amount for the same sale in two places with different numbers.
The net amount reported in the app isn't an estimate, nor is it ever updated.
If you do the math, the amount listed in the app, according to their own report, is the correct amount. The final asset price X the final asset amount, as frozen in their long-term reports, is the amount listed in the app.
There is no hand-waving financial explanation for this discrepancy.
> Block isn't running some elaborate Office Space style scam
I have black and white evidence that they are. Stealing isn't necessarily elaborate. I'm surprised you find this hard to believe when TFA is a report about other types of fraud by the same company.
> how little techies know about banks and trading and the financial system ... There is a lot of complexity behind the scenes
Your comment is a little condescending, I don't think it's a big secret that trades get settled.
Or could it be that the number in your bank account is consistent with what the buyer/seller on the other end of the trade is getting?
There are three key numbers here: the net amount reported in the app, the net amount listed on their buried report, and the amount paid. The net amount in the app is correctly calculated according to their own report of settled asset value and amount. The net amount in this buried report and amount paid do not match that.
Since these numbers again, are not estimates and never change, including after any settlement period, there is no legitimate explanation for the discrepancy.
You mention audits as if audited companies never commit financial crime.
I noticed one day that my books were off (down) by 1 penny. When I dug into it, I figured out that Cash App is providing their customers with conflicting reports for their stock sales.
In the app, the sales report rounds pennies up, in the actual sale, whose records are only available through more complex data export process, the penny in the sale is rounded down, and they are keeping the difference.
I found the rule in the legal terms which states that the calculation in the app presented to users is the correct one, and the penny is illegally missing.
This is for every trade for every one of their users. The aggregate amount of money is huge.
Edit: I just looked back at my analysis and now remember in some cases the missing money is more than one penny. If anyone would like to contact me one on one I can provide more proof.