News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by phamilton4 on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @09:38AM (#35260812)
Honestly, look on ebay for used Lenovo ThinkCentre M/P "Tiny" or Dell Optiplex "Tiny" computers. They can be purchased by the lot for most of them as businesses get rid of the old ones.

I use 4 Lenovo M910x's as a kubernetes cluster and home lab. Have them all connected with a netgear switch. The whole setup costs about the same as a single new quality work station. Each has: i7 8700 (6c - 12t) 32gb memory 1TB SSDs <1L case they're practically silent. easy to find parts, they even use lenovo laptop chargers. if one dies, I can easily purchase + replace in a few days.

You can even go cheaper if you don't need the absolute fastest cpus. Some of these older tiny computers can be purchased for around 100 bucks if you look for them. It has worked like a charm for me. Not sure how much horsepower you really need, but this is a cheap way to build a home cluster. I think they hover around using 40w most the time, so power isn't really too big of a cost either.

Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by marktangotango on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @10:13AM (#35261296)
This is the way. I spent a fair bit of time on using cheap chinese SoCs networked on a pcb. At one point you could get 32bit arms with 512mb of ram and 10/100 eth phys for like $.50 in bulk, that can run linux (not easily) (allwinner). But it would take an aweful lot of those to match the performance of an i7. And 32 vs 64bit is a problem.

The "gang of arms" lives on though in Ampere and graviton2 and the like.

Not knowing what the workload is, it's hard to beat consumer gpus for performance and price.

Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by nosebear on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @10:47AM (#35261850)
>I use 4 Lenovo M910x's as a kubernetes cluster and home lab.

Just asking out of curiosity: Why not a Ryzen 16-Core CPU + 128GB RAM and then VMs / containers everywhere? To me that seems much less hassle than having to pet four machines, as I am way too lazy to write automation stuff for myself. Also such a setup setup needs less space and probably less power.

Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by solomatov on Sunday March 26, 2023 @09:42AM (#35314356)
>Just asking out of curiosity: Why not a Ryzen 16-Core CPU + 128GB RAM and then VMs / containers everywhere?

It will be harder to simulate failure there to see how the system behaves in such a case. You could just remove ethernet cable or remove a power cable, and see how it reacts.

Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by jawmes8 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:44AM (#35270885)
Happen to have a write up on this? It sounds really cool. I’m in the process of retiring old machines for a client and I was thinking of doing that.
Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by ghoul2 on Thursday March 23, 2023 @02:14AM (#35271027)
I have been wanting to do something similar. But there's a snag:

How do you tell which of these available boxes has Intel AMT (or its AMD equivalent) fully enabled?

No listing reports this, and sellers seem to not be able to answer the question either.

How did you figure that out? Or are you managing without remote management? If so, how?

Re:Ask HN: How would you build a budget CPU compute cluster ... by sokoloff on Saturday March 25, 2023 @10:11AM (#35302792)
Worth noting that a lot of the ultra-tiny PCs have laptop CPUs, which aren’t as fast as the equivalent desktop part.