News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Shields Up by jaredwiener on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @09:57PM (#35255736)
You can follow the Sagan Standard (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sagan_standard)

"Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence."

Re:Shields Up by timr on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:00PM (#35255760)
Definitely, but I put this in the "listen to all sides and think for yourself" bucket, which is (sadly) not something most people are willing to do.

If we could just get people who aren't informed to recognize that they're not informed and not have an opinion, that would be a huge win for civil discourse.

Re:Shields Up by chowells on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:03PM (#35255795)
I don't have time to listen to 1000 dumb ideas per day. I have a life to live. Also, I don't want my brain to get infected with whatever got Joe Rogan. I'm fine only caring about news after it's mainstream knowledge. Or even never; most news isn't worth the time it takes to consume it.
Re:Shields Up by timr on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:05PM (#35255820)
> Also, I don't want my brain to get infected with whatever got Joe Rogan.

If your brain is so fragile that it can't listen to some guy on a podcast without being "infected", then you're gonna have a hard time.

Again, I'm not suggesting blind faith in dumb ideas. I'm not suggesting that you have to be an expert on anything. I'm suggesting that you have the will to say "I am not fully informed" when you don't know the answer.

Re:Shields Up by pixl97 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:20PM (#35255948)
You already believe in hundreds of bad ideas and so do I. Feeding your brain bullshit reinforces bullshit output.

On top of that the only thing most of us can say about almost everything under your rules would answered with 'I am not fully informed', shit, humanity isn't fully informed on anything.

Re:Shields Up by timr on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @12:07PM (#35263202)
> On top of that the only thing most of us can say about almost everything under your rules would answered with 'I am not fully informed', shit, humanity isn't fully informed on anything.

Yes. Exactly.

I'm calling for more modesty, and less political vitriol driven by a fictional, exaggerated sense of certainty.

(Also, reinforcing that ideas cannot hurt you, which is an odd mental pathology that has become distressingly common as of late.)

Re:Shields Up by chowells on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:46PM (#35256152)
> it can't listen to some guy on a podcast without being "infected", then you're gonna have a hard time

This isn't what I said. I'm not even sure you can comprehend what I said. It requires broad observation-based understanding of how humans work, which you're demonstrating the opposite of. Your weird ideas about how humans work are just another set I don't need to waste my time on, so... farewell, and I hope you get better.

Re:Shields Up by juve1996 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:27PM (#35255999)
There are an infinite number of sides. You can't possibly do it all in your lifetime. Eventually you have to trust someone with something.
Re:Shields Up by mistermann on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @09:50AM (#35260960)
> If we could just get people who aren't informed to recognize that they're not informed and not have an opinion, that would be a huge win for civil discourse.

I agree, but I think this falls into the category of "we've tried literally nothing and we're all out of ideas".

If someone is sitting on a pile of $, I think something quite effective (but oh, would it be controversial) could be built.

> I'm suggesting that you have the will to say "I am not fully informed" when you don't know the answer.

"The spirit (will) is willing (well, sometimes) but the flesh is weak". Free will, heuristics, and consciousness/reality are extremely complex topics. I believe very strongly that modern day people have this ability in similar quantities to the ability of people from 50 years ago to not be racist. It is innate, second nature, System 1, outside their control.

From below:

>> Eventually you have to trust someone with something.

You have to. While this is not logically, physically, necessarily true, I think this is literally true for most people, as a consequence of the evolved nature of consciousness, combined with culturally-ingrained norms, one of which is whether philosophy was a part of the educational curriculum one was exposed to... And even then, how good one is at it, in fact (which is typically inaccessible, thus imagined/simulated).

Another:

>> To you, the danger is not knowing that there are, in fact, lizard people controlling the government. To me, the danger is in ending up spending my free time poring over fringe lizard-people Twitter.

Also simulated. Sure, it's "just snark", "speaking colloquially", {excuse du jour}, but I wonder if the mind atrophies with lack of use like muscles do.

Re:Shields Up by whiddershins on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @09:58PM (#35255750)
Unfortunately we aren’t so great at evaluating what an extraordinary claim is.
Re:Shields Up by jaredwiener on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @10:05PM (#35255818)
This is sort of why journalism is an actual profession. Editors do this, or at least are supposed to.

Listening to everything everyone says can have its upsides, but filtering out noise is not one of them.

Re:Shields Up by whiddershins on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @03:27PM (#35265969)
Thats ... why on earth would I think any of the people involved in journalism are better at this than I am? That's not remotely their job description.
Re:Shields Up by mistermann on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @09:42AM (#35260873)
> Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.

A problem: this is a razor that is useful for approximating what one believes to be true, it is not proper, strict epistemology.

Also: it only yields belief, not truth, because it doesn't even try for truth - rather, it advises against doing that.

Would be interesting to see what Carl would say in this context, as I presume he meant it in the context of science/physics, not metaphysics.

I have arguments now and then with people on Carl Sagan videos on tiktok, and it is eye opening how many science fans are utterly incompetent when it comes to epistemology and logic. With just a tiny bit of abstraction (removing the object level specifics of the claim), they are indistinguishable from religious fundamentalists in their confident incorrectness / epistemic-unsoundness.

Re:Shields Up by nradov on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @01:56PM (#35264716)
I've seen the phrase "trust the science" a lot lately, which indicates the someone fundamentally misunderstands what science actually is.
Re:Shields Up by mistermann on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @05:40PM (#35267441)
* * *