Especially with the existence of that last category, it's tough going for someone who's genuinely curating book selections, perhaps even reading the books and providing good advice about them, when a lot of their competitors in the space are just algorithmically throwing together lists of books based on keywords. To a quick glance (the kind you normally get from search-engine visitors), it's hard to differentiate yourself from them. It might be possible to more slowly build up a fanbase of regular readers, though. Some book blogs have done that, which is not exactly the same format you're talking about, but has some similarities.
It really doesn't matter anymore. Both Amazon and Apple are destroying this idea because they own the hardware and the software. What disturbes me is that no one has come up with a proper solution similar to public libraries.
Maybe they'll come around in time and open the market to everybody. Then there could be competition on ebook readers.
I'd love to switch to ebooks completely, but I still can't stomach the fact that I don't own the ebooks I "buy", and that I can not just read whatever I want on my reader (at least not without a lot of hassle). Or even switch readers at will - these days buying an app or an ebook is essentially just cementing the vendor lock in, which is of course intentional.
As for money in the affiliate program, I have a small web site where I tested it, and I realized it sucks: if somebody buys a book through my link, I get perhaps 1 to 3€ (Europe here). But only a tiny fraction of visitors clicks, and a tiny fraction of those buys anything. Meanwhile, every click on an Adsense ad gets me 10 to 50 cents... Adsense wins easily.
The only times it seems to be effective is if people click on your Affiliate link and then go on to buy expensive stuff like iPods or TVs. A friend of mine told me he was making money for years because of a a comment on some discussion board recommending some cheap cable (forgot the details). People who bought the cable also bought other more expensive tech stuff... In any case he said the discussion board people have caught on and now insert their own links.