News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Whale-Oiled Machine by hinkley on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:09PM (#35250073)
The fact that engines are designed so that coolant and lubricants can mix has always left me a bit suspicious of planned obsolescence.

I think realistically it’s a limitation of the casting process, but it is to me the dumbest part of internal combustion engine design. Point the channels in two different directions on the casting, and only a cracked block should allow them to touch.

Re:A Whale-Oiled Machine by sidewndr46 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:14PM (#35250163)
but that is unrelated. Automatic transmission fluid isn't circulating through the engine on any vehicle by design that I have seen.

Plenty of vehicles with a standard gearbox just use the engine oil as the transmission lubricant. In motorcycles this is called "unit construction". I've heard of some older Saabs that did this as well.

Re:A Whale-Oiled Machine by hinkley on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:11PM (#35251037)
> The resulting corrosion allowed mixing of oil and coolant.

Why is that unrelated?

Re:A Whale-Oiled Machine by sidewndr46 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @03:38PM (#35251408)
because the mixing the article talks about it transmission oil and coolant.

When a passageway cracks in a cylinder head & engine oil becomes "milkshake" that is the mixing of engine oil and coolant. Two separate kinds of oil in different places.

Re:A Whale-Oiled Machine by mech987 on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @04:01PM (#35251723)
You should watch videos on how hard head gaskets are to design if you want an idea of some of the engineering involved- I think "engineering explained" did one recently on youtube.
Re:A Whale-Oiled Machine by hinkley on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @02:06PM (#35264864)
What I’m saying is, should we still be building engines that rely on “the” head gasket to keep fluids separate?

An engine cylinder at a minimum must deal with: lubrication, fuel, and gasses. The exhaust manifold deals with half of the gases. I can’t recall if common rail injectors are still technically part of the head (I can find pictures where the CRI system sits on the head, with separate gaskets, but I’m not a mechanic).

With modern manufacturing would we not be better off splitting these tasks up so that only a cracked engine block can mix fluids. Not a torn gasket, not a warped head, not a thrown rod (though rods are going away too).