News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by alfor on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:45PM (#35238414)
Complex systems usually tend to equilibrium otherwise they would be in constant oscillation (positive feedback theory).

As we look back in ice cores, there is variation, but not constant oscillations witch confirm a self stabilizing system.

A few negative feedback we don’t often hear:

increase of co2 have a huge effect on plant grow especially in hash deserted conditions.

Increase in temperature increase humidity: clouds that have a huge effect on reflecting radiation (much greater than co2) increase precipitation, increase plant growth in deserts.

Not to say that we should continue this experiment, but maybe not panic either and see this as the only problem: war, famine, poverty are much more important and real immediate problems instead of projected possible problems.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by kuhewa on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:31PM (#35239067)
> increase of co2 have a huge effect on plant grow especially in hash deserted conditions.

Which might sound good for crops but of itself can destabilise ecosystems, African savannahs are already becoming scrubbier with brush and shrubs due to more CO2 enrichment for at least ~1 million and possibly several million years. That will definitely have implications for populations of animals adapted for grassland

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by wcoenen on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:03PM (#35238665)
> Increase in temperature increase humidity

Water vapor amplifies the effect of other greenhouse gases.

https://climate.nasa.gov/ask-nasa-climate/3143/steamy-relati...

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by alfor on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:12PM (#35239534)
Yes, but also with clouds that prevent radiation from reaching the ground.
Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by brnt on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:55PM (#35238546)
Im sure the IPCC authors didn't forget their climate science 101 material.

Moreover, we can tackle multiple problems concurrently, no need to make it appear we can only ever do one thing. And as it so happens, climate change tends to correlate extremely well with war and famine. It certainly appears a climate solution is going to help many other big problems along as well.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday March 20, 2023 @05:02PM (#35238661)
> climate change tends to correlate extremely well with war and famine

and migration.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by alfor on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @09:18AM (#35245694)
Does it? We have fewer and fewer death because of climate (most death of climate is because of cold) We have a proxy war in Ukraine that has nothing to do with climate We have a famine in Sri Lanka that was caused by the green movement

The narrative of climate is the cause of all problems isn’t reasonable anymore.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:45PM (#35250636)
Robust institutions disagree on whether heat or cold is more significant:

> Extreme heat and extreme cold both kill hundreds of people each year in the U.S., but determining a death toll for each is a process subject to large errors. In fact, two major U.S. government agencies that track heat and cold deaths--NOAA and the CDC--differ sharply in their answer to the question of which is the bigger killer.

https://www.wunderground.com/cat6/Which-Kills-More-People-Ex...

And while it may indeed be that cold is a more significant source of death, these numbers are hardly trivial:

2003 heatwave, Europe: 72,000 2022 heatwave, Europe: 20,000

and for the future:

> In the course of this century, the percentage of the European population dying from cold temperatures will steadily decrease, while the percentage of the population dying from heat will increase. The latter increase will start to exceed the reduction of cold-weather related mortality in the second half of this century, especially in the Mediterranean. As a result, mortality in Europe related to non-optimal temperatures will start to increase by the end of the century in a moderate scenario of climate change, and already by the middle of the century in the high-end scenario of climate change.

Derived from: Martínez-Solanas et al., 2021. Lancet Planetary Health 5: e446–54

There is no serious narrative that claims that climate change is the current cause of all problems. There is no serious narrative that can refute the obvious point that if climate chnage predictions play out, it will add greatly to all existing problems.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by revelio on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @11:58AM (#35248044)
No it doesn't, that's just people trying to tie together two hobby-horses. Nobody is migrating to Europe or America because of climate change, they're migrating because of wealth and war.
Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @02:34PM (#35250467)
If you live in an agricultural area and can't get sufficient water for irrigation anymore, the distinction between climate change, wealth and war is pretty immaterial.

Do you seriously think that if, in say 30 years, substantial chunks of the tropics-to-tropics range of latitude have become too hot/dry for mass agriculture, that people will not be trying to migrate?

I haven't seen anyone claiming that there is currently mass migration due to climate change. But I haven't seen anyone claiming that previous climate change events (anthropogenic or not) were not accompanied by mass migration (even if the absolute numbers of people were smaller due to total population)

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by revelio on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @05:39PM (#35252968)
You used the present tense in the post I replied to. But as you say, currently it's not true and there is no correlation between climate change and migration, because the climate hasn't actually changed anywhere near enough in any location to cause people to move.

> I haven't seen anyone claiming that previous climate change events (anthropogenic or not) were not accompanied by mass migration

What climate change events were you thinking of? Medieval warm period? I don't think there's any record of anything that we'd call a mass migration, any time in history beyond the past few hundred years. Not unless you count migrations that took place over tens of thousands of years as mass migration.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by PaulDavisThe1st on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @06:37PM (#35253682)
> the climate hasn't actually changed anywhere near enough in any location to cause people to move.

Where I live (near Santa Fe, NM), human civilization has moved in and out several times over the last, say, 5000 years, always correlated with the arrival of long term drought conditions. The last big movement was during the megadrought of the late 1300's, and apparently involved migrations of between 300 and 1000 miles.

Similar patterns are well known to archaeologists and anthropologists across the planet.

Also "and migration" doesn't have any tense or time context and even the GP's wording ("X tends to correlate with Y") is also largely free of any implied time period.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by brnt on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @01:42PM (#35264504)
The Syrian conflict started after 4 or so successive years of crop failures, which have been linked to desertification and climate change.
Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by revelio on Wednesday March 22, 2023 @06:44PM (#35268070)
You don't think that had more to do with ISIS than climate change?
Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by brnt on Thursday March 23, 2023 @01:31PM (#35278246)
ISIS came after the breakdown of society due to crop failure after crop failure.

Migration started end masse after Russia was invited over to kill every civilian in sight. But that is also after Assad lost the ability to control and feed the population, something he wasn't doing very well anyway, granted, but without climate change related failed harvests its hard to imagine it had spiralled out of control.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by alfor on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:16PM (#35239574)
Yes we can, but what are those problems, what is the cost involved, what are we willing to sacrifice?

There is many other goals that are largely ignored because "climate" is very very popular.

I like the work of Bjorn Lomborg on that front. When we rank the problems and solution climate is not at the top.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by alfor on Monday March 20, 2023 @06:18PM (#35239604)
The IPCC authors are financially rewarded to continue to push in that direction.

Most of them have made career in that field, where a few decade ago there was barely any financing available for climate.

Those that challenge the current orthodoxy are pushed aside and cast out.

This is not science, it’s religion.

Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by imtringued on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:55PM (#35240624)
IPCC is absurdly conservative. If you have an issue with their numbers then you‘ve fallen for pseudo science.
Re:IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’ by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday March 20, 2023 @04:56PM (#35238567)
> clouds that have a huge effect on reflecting radiation

My understanding is that clouds are inside that part of the atmosphere in which radiative forcing has decreased. This means that while they may reflect radiation so that it does not reach the ground, they do not stop (all) the energy from being trapped within the atmosphere.

> war, famine, poverty

All actual problems that will result from significant climate change, not distinct from climate change (even though they may exist for other reasons too).