News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by ddtaylor on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:26AM (#35230016)
> “I think you could replace 99% of the uses of Curl … with like 100 lines of Python or Rust or Go”

Assuming this is the "99%" usage pattern:

    curl -O foo.txt https://example.com/foo.txt
Then, yes.
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by raincole on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:41AM (#35230137)
100 lines is such an amateur number. I can actually do this in 1 lines of shell.

curl -O $1 $2

Checkmate 100line python guy!

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by ddtaylor on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:10AM (#35230369)
It's worth noting that Microsoft actually does shim "curl" in Powershell to basically be a light wrapper around the "Invoke-WebRequest" object. Is it a full drop-in replacement for curl? Nope, but it does replace it in the simple context(s) of stuff like "curl -O foo bar"
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by raincole on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:26AM (#35230521)
Powershell is really weird in the sense that I can sometimes use Unix-like command like cp, mv, rm... I know it's probablly a completely different thing behind the curtain but it's amusing.
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by tyingq on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:34AM (#35230077)
Or, with a dependency on libcurl :)

Also, it's not immediately obvious in the various libraries how to do something right. Most python/requests examples you'll find to do that simple "download a file", for example, would run out of memory on a large file.

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by ddtaylor on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:47AM (#35230172)
AFAIK the "requests" module in python (the most popular one) doesn't actually depend on curl:

https://github.com/psf/requests

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by tyingq on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:44AM (#35230684)
Ah, that's not what I was saying, should have worded it better. The statements were separate.
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by alias_neo on Monday March 20, 2023 @07:48AM (#35230185)
In the defense of some of the particularly jerk-inducing ones, they're conflating libcurl with curl.

Sure if you want to fetch a file from the internet you could do it with one line (see the person I'm replying to);

I'd love to see the look on some of these people's faces when they find out that tool/software/whatever they use is actually using libcurl under the hood.

Good luck even getting on the internet in the first place without that router, switch, PC, modem or anything else that's also running curl/libcurl.

I don't know whether it's just my age showing, but thinking you could do anything remotely like curl in 3 days is .... well, my 1 year old probably talks more sense when he says "no".

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by ddtaylor on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:06AM (#35230343)
> I'd love to see the look on some of these people's faces when they find out that tool/software/whatever they use is actually using libcurl under the hood.

Python dependencies (does not include curl)

https://devguide.python.org/getting-started/setup-building/i...

The "requests" module in Python (does not use curl)

https://github.com/psf/requests

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by woodrowbarlow on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:36AM (#35230617)
yes, python and some other languages have more-or-less re-implemented libcurl (or large parts of it). requests is one example created by a particularly prolific author and it has been evolving for over a decade.

that's perfect evidence that, no, a common developer cannot "re-write" curl in a few days.

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by ddtaylor on Monday March 20, 2023 @09:08AM (#35230927)
Where do you draw the line then? Is someone making a 3-day project expected to re-implement everything from the ground up?
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by p00f on Tuesday March 21, 2023 @12:13PM (#35248281)
People who claim they can do it are expected to do it, yes
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by pcthrowaway on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:11AM (#35230380)
I was going through my Prius's "software license information" a while ago and I noticed the daniel@haxx email.

No way would I run software in my car that someone hacked together in 3 days.

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by ddtaylor on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:18AM (#35230436)
I think this problem is similar to the OpenSSL problem. The idea being that we have a library that has a giant attack surface because it does a LOT of different things and attackers find clever ways to abuse those extra features that most users don't actually want enabled.

Your car probably wants to use some relatively pedestrian things like HTTPS, but do you think it should have any capability of doing GOPHER, SMBS, SFTP, POP3, LDAP, IMAP, TELNET, TFTP, SCP or any of the other stuff curl supports out of the box?

We can hope that the version of curl used for the car was compiled without support for some of these protocols. I don't even know if we have a good way to verify that. More likely is that whatever the stock configuration (all the protocols) is what is being used in most applications.

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by thunky on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:49AM (#35230733)
> No way would I run software in my car that someone hacked together in 3 days

So no Tesla for you then.

Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by alias_neo on Monday March 20, 2023 @09:47AM (#35231431)
I was updating my car a few months ago and found it runs Linux for the user-facing systems, and of course uses libcurl, according to the open source licenses.
Re:I Could Rewrite Curl (2021) by em-bee on Monday March 20, 2023 @08:20AM (#35230458)
or wget https://example.com/foo.txt

like those 99% i never had a use for curl because wget covers all my use cases including some that curl doesn't.

but where curl is a swiss-army-knife, wget is a simple hunters or sailors knife. it cuts, and that's all it does.

everyone who complains about curl is not taking advantage of its features and should be using wget instead of complaining.