News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Browser Sedimentation by Zigurd on Saturday January 28, 2012 @12:47PM (#3522652)
I find myself fumbling with the three scroll bars in GMail: Two are owned by GMail, one for the main pane of the UI, and one for the message pane embedded in it. The browser's scroll bar controls scrolling for the contacts displayed on the right side of the window.

A case can be made for this in that all the scroll bars are closest to the content they scroll. But it also points out the unsatisfactory state of having the browser control some scrolling and the active content inside the browser control some of it. This would never fly in the design of any UI library for creating interactive applications.

Re: Browser Sedimentation by notatoad on Saturday January 28, 2012 @01:38PM (#3522818)
I'm not sure whats going on in your browser, but I've never seen gmail have more than one scroll bar.
Re: Browser Sedimentation by Zigurd on Saturday January 28, 2012 @06:34PM (#3523772)
If you have a thread longer than your window, that's one scroll bar. Gmail creates it.

If you have a reply, for example, in that thread longer than a few lines, it is scrolled within a view in the thread.

If you have your chat contacts displayed in the right pane, the browser window's scroll bar scrolls that pane.

That's the case I'm describing.