Also, I would say inflationary token vs deflationary token is not clear what is better because it is actually highly depends on the time in history. lot's of things changed in the last 100 years and we might be entering a world where there is no need for inflationary token - For example let's say the earth is over-populated and there is going to be a decline in birth and total population - this on it's can mean we don't necessarily need an inflationary token as we don't need to build more infrastructure, buy more things and so on....
I don’t love cryptocurrency stuff, I mean it is a bit environmentally wasteful and stupid, but lots of things are wasteful and stupid so it doesn’t give me some visceral negative reaction. I think the folks who really hate it here are just annoyed that there’s all this vaguely tech-flavored scammy behavior going on that, shows up on their favorite news sites (because it is vaguely techy), maybe gets promoted to them, etc etc.
Some of it is regret from selling early (I'd be a billionaire... if I had held), some of it is FOMO, some of it is that crypto is used by criminals (see bitlocker hacks), some of it is seeing people loose everything due to security breaches, and some of it is the attitude of proponents that act like all of the above is an anomaly.
While it might be worth having a discussion about crypto using btc as a currency would be the digital equivalent of bottle caps in a post apocalyptic society. Dogecoin would make a better currency..
You mean aside from capitalising one of the most powerful money making machines in the tech industry, and a global advertising powerhouse that hundreds of millions of people use to find stuff on the internet multiple times every day. Plus Android, gmail, etc, etc. All those took money to develop, which came from early investors.
In theory, early investors allow Google to actually have the cash needed to make the products and services that brought in the real revenue.
An ex of mine would totally agree with you though.
If you think it is just a company, then they are just winners in economy. There is no reason for any of us to lobby for them to get more money. And, none of us lobby for it.
People who held google stock early actually provided a lot of value to society. By either investing in or working for a company that radically transformed how people use the Internet. You can argue early investors into Bitcoin are the same but in a much lesser way than if you aren’t Satoshi and didn’t contribute to the core development or advocacy of Bitcoin. Most hodlers just bought it and held on and did nothing.
The unfairness of this is so rankling that it’s hard to imagine that Bitcoin as reserve currency settles into an accepted equilibrium without significant violence on a global scale.
Yes it is.
Imagine an economy with both ultra high interest rates and very high deflation at the same time. Let's say CPI growth somehow falls to - 20% and the Fed decides to hike interest rates to + 20%* (and has no way to tweak or stop this policy anymore) what do you think would happen?
> why HN is so anti-crypto
Because it would not work as a replacement for $/€/etc. due to very objective and clear reasons anyone with an even cursory understanding of modern economics would understand.
> let's say the earth is over-populated
Let's say a nuclear holocaust occurs and everybody starts using bottle-caps as currency. Of course you're suggesting we should start using bottle caps (a close 100% accurate physical equivalent of bitcoin in post-apocalyptic society which posses no mean to make more caps) before the nuclear holocaust for some reason...
People who held bitcoin from early on supported the growth of bitcoin by holding up it's value through the wild gut-wrenching rollercoaster ride that it has gone through. They should be rewarded for the risk they're taking on, having invested significant amount of their net worth in the face of harsh criticism such as yours.
Bitcoin and "crypto" are completely different beasts. Cryptos are unregistered securities masquerading as Bitcoin 2.0.
For the record, I agree that early Bitcoiners took an incredible risk on a highly volatile asset and they should be rewarded for such.
As I see it, this latest banking crisis is showing the world that there is more than one type of risk. Bitcoin has market risk but not counter-party risk.
As for bank deposits, while they have minimal market risk, they have significant counter-party risk.
The world is waking up to the fact that bank deposits are an unsecured loan to a risky counter-party that uses those deposits for highly leveraged speculative bets.
People never considered these risks before. A bank is a bank is a bank. And in the developed world, inflation is low. Now you have a situation where both narratives are being challenged. The system is under lots of strain.
Theoretically, yes, albeit with spherical cows in a vacuum models of how economies actually function.
Practically, keys get lost, so it's deflationary even if it totally replaced existing currency and everything else became steady state.
> They should be rewarded for the risk they're taking on, having invested significant amount of their net worth in the face of harsh criticism such as yours.
If "harsh criticism" was sufficient reason to deserve money, I'd still use my Twitter account to have angry conversations about things that don't matter.
There never has been a fixed supply world reserve asset, even gold has always been inflationary. I think it will usher in a "Golden" age for humanity where goods and services consistently increase in quality and value, while constantly reducing in cost. I'm very excited to step into the bold orange world.
P.S. I'm a bitcoiner not a cryptocurrency advocate.
Because then investment ceases to be about trying to capture a share of the growing pie, and more a zero sum game which the small minority of people holding most of the financial wealth have little incentive to participate in, and so the mechanism by which stuff gets cheaper over time, priced in Bitcoin, isn't economic growth but just increasing desperation of people without Bitcoin to obtain it.
So all the worst parts of capitalism and none of the actual good parts, though I appreciate the idea is more appealing to people who imagine themselves as being the minority of idle rich.
For related reasons, the world would not adopt a deflationary currency for very long...
Imagine an economy with both ultra high interest rates and very high deflation at the same time. Let's say CPI growth somehow falls to - 20% and the Fed decides to hike interest rates to + 20%* what do you think would happen? Well take the Great Depression and multiple it by N (no idea, I'd assume N >= 20 though).
Sound great?
How does close to zero capital investment into the economy sound? No loans, no VCs, no new factories/offices/shops/etc. no new anything... Investing into anything would be both very risky and likely still have a negative return compared to just hoarding money.
> I think it will usher in a "Golden" age
I think it would usher societal collapse and the end of human civilization (I seriously do.. of course I'm close to 100% certain that it can never happen, then again I'm not great at predicting the future).
*I would assume the numbers would be higher with btc.. but whatever
I don't think so. There will definitely be companies and startups that yield better returns than bitcoin. Especially when bitcoin stabilizes at a very high value, holders will start speculating.
You can have a deflationary system and the effects will be the same. People will always be looking for a stable store of value and a yield with variable risk. Instead of increasing/decreasing the money supply through interest rate, the price of Bitcoin goes up and down.
Solving a stable store of value problem (through Bitcoin, completely decentralized) is a 100bn/1Trillion market. And also will be a legitimate use case for Bitcoin and Cryptocurrencies.
Something like that is really not avoidable if btc replaces $/€/etc.
> debt away and print money as needed.
Which on balance has been a positive development compared to the system that preceded this (permanent boom and bust cycles prior to 1930 accompanied by extreme price swings in either direction)
Look at the 'USD inflation since 1800' chart. Would you really prefer the worth of your saving to swing up and down by 10% or more every few years compared to the relatively stable inflation after 1980s?
https://www.officialdata.org/us/inflation/1800?amount=1#:~:t....
Bitcoin is flexible. If there is a certain demand or necessity, people can build on top of it.
Yes. 2-10000x (or whatever, depending on how rich you are) less than they do now. If hoarding money always provides a better return than investing or borrowing it why do anything else besides spending the bare minimum?
> Bitcoin is flexible
How exactly? AFAIK it has close to zero flexibility compared to Fiat money.
I'm sorry but overall I really don't understand what are you trying to say. Supply of money in relation to economic growth matters and it matters a lot. It's not just about 'means of payments' that is the easiest part.
> If there is a certain demand or necessity
Well there is no way to increase the supply of bitcoin? Is there?
Exactly. As the economy grows BitCoin will increase in value because its supply is fixed (not even gold or silver were even remotely as bad and when they were used as currencies).
Imagine a financial system with huge * huge interests rates * and and * huge deflation *. You can't because no central bank is run by people who are stupid and insane enough to try that? Well...
Something like that is 100% guarantee is btc becaomes a global currencies.
> They should be rewarded for the risk they're taking on, having invested significant amount of their net worth in the face of harsh criticism such as yours.
No they shouldn't. They contributed nothing to the society or economic growth. Even people investing in Credit Suisse should better rewarded than them from that perspective. Of course if there are other people willing to pay them huge amounts of money (yes money, not bitcoin) for their token well... it's their business).
> Bitcoin and "crypto" are completely different beasts. Cryptos are unregistered securities masquerading as Bitcoin 2.0.
Many other cryptos, well pretty much every one that doesen't have a fixed supply, like DogeCoin for instance would make much, much better global currencies than bitcoin.
Perhaps they would invest their bitcoins far better than the current status quo and create a star-trek style post scarcity economy.
Very basic understanding of modern economics and monetary systems would be more than enough to figure that out.
> post scarcity economy
In fact it would maximize scarcity (imagine the Fed hiking interest rates to + 20% while inflation becomes negative, say - 20%. What do you think would happen?)
We really need to crack down on amassing wealth.
Ok, so a few folks will amass a lot of wealth based on luck and not merit. Those already exist in current financial system, both locally and globally. Plenty of dictators have control over natural resources worth trillions.
There are numerous issues with bitcoin replacing USD, I'm just surprised why you think that few nerds becoming billionaires is a major issue.
> so a few folks will amass a lot of wealth based on luck and not merit
You severely underestimate how concentrated bitcoin ownership is. A couple of hundred people would control a significant proportion of the global economy just because they were lucky. Why would you want some random people controlling the majority of the global economy? I mean things are very far from perfect now in my opinion but at least most billionaires have earned their wealth through actual work in one way or the other and can be generally expected to behave rationally.
The main issue in this case though is that bitcoin is deflationary. Obviously it's flawed but with Fiat money you're forced to either spend or invest your money returning it into the economy (also it's simply not physically feasible to hoard several billion (let alone trillion) of $ i a vault...).
If you don't utilize your money somehow it will lose value continuously due to inflation. Bitcoin on the other hand will increase in value when the economy is growing (which is why using a commodity like gold which is still a magnitude or so so superior to bitcoin in this regard is and was a bad idea unless there are no stable governments). So hoarding money will become the safest and relatively best investment This means that these few folks will remain billionaires for ever and their wealth will keep increasing without them actually doing anything...
There would be no or very few bank loans given out (imagine HUGE INTEREST RATES + HUGE DEFLATION, obviously not something that can exist now as long the people charger are not more than mildly insane...) venture capital, really any investment, which to be fair makes my last point moat cause there would be very little (or like negative) growth anyway in a such an economy.
> I'm just surprised why you think that few nerds becoming billionaires is a major one
So you want to take one of the biggest flaws of the current system and dial it up to 1000? Great idea...
Why don't you share the numbers then, what is significant in your mind? I can make the exact same claim about the current state of affairs.
As far as I know, there are no privately owned wallets holding more than 0.5% of BTC.
IIRC there are no numbers. Because nobody really knows who owns what. Also if you had huge amounts of bitcoin why on earth would you hold all of it in single wallet? Makes no sense...
> privately owned wallets holding more than 0.5% of BTC.
Which is an astronomically huge amount for a private individual to own in case BTC replaces dollars. Even if we only count actual dollars bills in circulation that 0.5% of that would be 10.5 billion. What private person could have that much cash stored somewhere? And most importantly why?
If we include entire M1 supply (bills + deposits) 0.5% would be equal to 100 BILLION dollars. That's not an amount that can exist in a single place in USD, no single person does or ever did own such an amount in liquid assets which he could sell transfer the proceeds to someone in a short period of time. That's not really possible.
You seem to be confusing three similar, but fundamentally different things: physical cash, liquid assets, and being able to transfer in short period of time.
Just because billionaire's assets are illiquid, it doesn't mean they can't transfer $10B in a short period of time. It simply means that portion of value will be lost during that transfer.
> What private person could have that much cash stored somewhere? And most importantly why?
Elon had $20B in cash (i.e. liquid assets) after selling 10% of his Tesla shares. He lost some value in the process, but afterwards he had $20B of liquid assets, which debunks your statement.
Arguably, same will happen to $10B of BTC, given that such transaction(s) would be public and will raise concerns.
And that's just Elon Musk, we're not even talking about western adversaries, like Putin or Xi, who have access to even more assets.
And if we're thinking of BTC simply replacing physical cash, then you can even build fractional reserve system on top of it.
Also, we seem to be discussing a magical world where BTC became the major currency overnight, with no time for financial system to adapt. If we go back to the real world, I could totally entertain a thought experiment of BTC replacing USD. Not that I support it, but again, few lucky billionaires is the least of my concerns, given that we already have those in the current system.
True that the thing. Bitcoing is so fundamentally unfit to be a currency that any attempt to make it such would fail long before any of these issues would become relevant.
> again, few lucky billionaires is the least of my concerns, given that we already have those in the current system
So take one of the biggest issues with the current system, make it 10+ times worse and see what happens...
Basically people who held significant amounts of bitcoin from early on would become billionaires (if not trillionaires...) by having provided zero value to the economy. As awful and unfair what we have currently is it's still several magnitudes superior in almost any conceivable way than a global financial system based on bitcoin.
I can imagine some sort of a crypto currency possible becoming dominant in the future. But Bitcoin itself is pretty much the worst option I can imagine.