News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by mgkimsal on Saturday January 28, 2012 @09:17AM (#3522105)
“If they aired a day later,” she says, “illegal pirating would be going on.”

Probably, for different reasons, but likely not anywhere as near as it is today. If you knew stuff would be on in the UK on Th night, and you could see it uncut and unreformatted 26 hours later, you'd be far less likely to have initially bothered to go search it out.

I submit that the awareness and convenience of online 'piracy' of TV shows has been driven, in large part, by the frustration people felt by knowing they'd have to wait months in the first place. Now that there's a whole generation of people who already know how to 'pirate', they're not going to turn back (certainly not without a fight - SOPA, etc) but the content industry has themselves to blame for this again.

We gave up on BBC America back around 2004/2005 because they insisted on showing repeats instead of decent shows, and not explaining themselves. There was one week where they showed a combined 96 hours of "ground force", "changing rooms" and one other insipid home reality show. 96 hours of repeats of just 3 shows. Meanwhile EastEnders was scaled back and they showed less of that, and kept falling further behind. Eventually, after about a year or so of EastEnders in 2004, in to 2005, they started showing repeats of EastEnders from 2004 in place of the then-current episodes. It was as if they thought people wouldn't notice (or care) about getting repeats of a year-old ongoing soap episode. We quit even trying to support BBC America at that point, and turned to full scale torrents of any UK shows we wanted.

In the absence of being able to simply pay a UK TV license fee directly to the appropriate office, we'll just pirate. I realize that $300 still wouldn't cover all the potential ads and such ITV gets, but it'd be a strong start.

Make the BBC channels, ITV, and a couple other UK channels available as a UK package on DirecTV or Dish, charge $49/month, and I'd happily pay, assuming they were uncut feeds.

Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by corin_ on Saturday January 28, 2012 @09:37AM (#3522153)
> Make the BBC channels, ITV, and a couple other UK channels available as a UK package on DirecTV or Dish, charge $49/month, and I'd happily pay, assuming they were uncut feeds.

From the other side of the pond, I'd like to repeat that sentiment in reverse.

Please don't forget, Americans, that we have just the same problem waiting for American shows, which there are many more of, and therefore also many more great shows.

American sport TV is generally already great from the leagues themselves, with MLB TV, NFL GamePass and whatever the names are for NBA/NHL... but general entertainment/drama/comedy/etc, it's pirate a few hours later or a long, long wait.

Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by subpixel on Saturday January 28, 2012 @10:44AM (#3522312)
I disagree. I don't own a TV anymore, and probably never will.

I want to pull up the shows I want, when I want, and watch them where I want.

To do this, I rely on the following services, in order:

1. Hulu (I'm happy to deal with ads)

2. Network streams (ditto ads)

3. The Pirate Bay (when not available through other means)

4. Another site dedicated to current/past British TV

Re #4 - there's no way, just no way I'm going to wait months to watch a show on PBS that aired on the BBC/ITV/Ch4 yesterday.

IMHO, the most lucrative path for the industry to follow would be a subscription model that's tied to usage.

* Users buy credit, and that credit is used as they download content.

* Current content is more valuable - so the current season of a series costs $X/GB, last season costs $Y/GB, etc.

* Every channel/network is in business for themselves (e.g. cut out Apple/Amazon/DirectTV altogether)

I'm not holding my breath for that scenario though.

Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by corin_ on Saturday January 28, 2012 @10:48AM (#3522330)
1. Hulu isn't available in the UK 2. Neither are (legal) streams from US networks
Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by e40 on Saturday January 28, 2012 @09:26AM (#3522129)
Agreed. As it is, DirecTV wants me to pay $85/mo for essentially 4-5 channels. I don't want:

* those other 996 channels

* your DVR to keep adding back stations once I remove them from the hunt list

* your crappy DVR software--TiVo was fine and you replaced it with shit

What I want is a way to pay a reasonable price for the few shows I watch. I can't do that. So, what I do instead is torrent the few shows I watch.

People will pirate until the experience you give them as paying customers is equal to or better than their pirating experience.

Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by tristan_louis on Saturday January 28, 2012 @12:50PM (#3522658)
Here's an explanation of why you pay so much:

http://www.tnl.net/blog/2011/11/06/live-tv-streams-challenge...

Re:Is it OK to steal “Downton Abbey”? by e40 on Tuesday February 07, 2012 @10:23AM (#3562079)
"Today, cus­tomers are pay­ing a pre­mium for chan­nels they may or may not watch. By offer­ing stream­ing for a fee, con­tent owner could open up a dia­logue with end cus­tomers that lets the free mar­ket decide which chan­nels live and which ones die. But today, those same com­pa­nies are using near-monopoly fran­chises in one field (dis­tri­b­u­tion) to sub­si­dize another… and inter­net live stream­ing of their sta­tions could threaten that monopoly."

So, over time they'll lose out to piracy and go bust. If they can't see the handwriting on the wall, then they deserve it. I'll just have to find other ways to get money to the people that produce the content (buying episodes of Community on Amazon, for example).