News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:53AM (#35220214)
Many us legislators are openly admitting it is a proxy war. See Rep. Dan Crenshaw-TX comments on Ukrain support. He calls it a good deal that we get to fight a major geo-political adversary without any American deaths by just supplying Ukraine with weapons. He is not the only one. That is by definition a proxy war. Fighting a war on the cheap that isn't designed to ultimately win anything, meanwhile sending 200,000 of those Ukrainians to their deaths is despicable in my opinion.

I am not on Putin's side on this, but this is not 1945. Russia does have some vital national interests in the reason, since its right on their border and they have a long historical relationship with Crimea. The prime minister of Israel claims they had a deal worked out, but the Biden administration nixed it. This is a result of strategic planning within the State Dept. to have this fight.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @11:55AM (#35220239)
I will also note that the cash burn rate for this war in Ukraine is now exceeding that of Afghanistan in the early years. It is more money after nothing, because they won't even define what victory means. Just more war slogans.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by Zak on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:19PM (#35221256)
I think the Ukrainian government has defined victory as driving the Russian military out of all Ukrainian territory, including Crimea.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by cynicalsecurity on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:03PM (#35220307)
Britain has historical roots to the US territory, going back to centuries ago. According to your logic, a British invasion and occupation of US would be justified.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:14PM (#35220443)
Do you have a non-stupid comment?

Ukraine is right on the russia's border. Their economies and cultures are intertwined. And their have been hostilities between the two since 2014 when the US formented a revolution there. I am not shilling for Russia, but a peace agreement requires all parties to put everything on the table and deal openly. This could have happened.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mopsi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:21PM (#35220526)
> And their have been hostilities between the two since 2014 when the US formented a revolution there.

This is just another conspiracy theory. In 2014, a pro-Russian president of Ukraine backed down from a very favourable trade deal with the EU due to Russian pressure at the last minute, people came to streets to protest, he ordered snipers to shoot unarmed protestors, after which the unrest only grew, he fled the country in panic and Russia used the unrest as a cover to invade Ukraine.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:06PM (#35221091)
The manipulations within the state dept. by Victoria Nuland are well known. She was literally caught on the phone planning who was going to be pushed as the next leader. By labelling it a conspiracy, you are simply trying to disparage a very valid possibility. Conspiracies are nothing more than multiple people collaborating to make something happen. It does happen, and they should not be dismissed out of hand.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:11PM (#35221159)
> by Victoria Nuland ... literally caught on the phone planning

This false conspiracy theory is discussed at length here

https://www.thebulwark.com/what-really-happened-in-ukraine-i...

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by bakuninsbart on Sunday March 19, 2023 @02:50PM (#35222196)
The Association Agreement also included sections on political and security cooperation. More importantly, Ukraine was pretty evenly split on Maidan and the signing of the Association Agreement. [0] This split, also seen in elections was largely geographic. [1] Unsurprisingly, toppling the (democratically elected) president tore the country apart, and independent on which government you personally prefer, I think it is really hard to argue that Ukraine wasn't the victim of Big Power politics in this case.

[0] https://archive.kyivpost.com/article/content/ukraine-politic...

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_Ukrainian_parliamentary_e...

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:17PM (#35220470)
> Ukraine is right on the russia's border. Their economies and cultures are intertwined

So, according to your logic, a British invasion and occupation of USA would not be justified, but a British invasion and occupation of The Republic of Ireland would be?

> 2014 when the US formented a revolution there.

Propaganda nonsense. https://www.thebulwark.com/what-really-happened-in-ukraine-i...

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:32PM (#35220691)
The Bulwark is a neocon publication by Bill Kristol. He still refuses to apologize for the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan. He is part of the war machine that is perfectly happy to see perpetual war.

He was a solid republican, but he was all too happy to ditch everything he said he believed in to embrace the cultural issues of the left. The only thing he kept the same was his hawkish views on foreign policy. That shows a lot about him right there. He is an untrustworthy source for anything.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:35PM (#35220715)
I already know who Bill Kristol is, thanks. I'm not a fan of their political project, my point is that even they don't buy this "coup" nonsense.

I do not think either that they "ditched everything he said he believed in" when their political party changed and they did not, that's rather a specific framing of an extremist faction of that party.

No doubt you prefer noted thinker, Dan Crenshaw.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:53PM (#35220951)
Huh? Dan Crenshaw has been all in on this war in Ukraine. He even openly admitted that it was a golden opportunity because we could fight a major geopolitical adversary on the cheap by just sending weapons with no American casualties - completely minimizing any Ukrainian casualties.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:51PM (#35220919)
That's the point. The people behind The Bulwark don't believe "this coup nonsense" because they are pushing for war there. All the writers there are always pushing for military solutions to everything.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by SideburnsOfDoom on Sunday March 19, 2023 @05:25PM (#35223806)
> The Bulwark don't believe "this coup nonsense" because they are pushing for war there.

It could be that. Or maybe, they don't believe it because the facts don't support it, and they believe in truth as a thing that is worthwhile regardless of if it personally benefits them or not.

You have a very transactional view of truth. And frankly that says more about you than anything else.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by caskstrength on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:44PM (#35221558)
As a Ukrainian I find your comments in this thread insulting. You should educate yourself a little about history of Ukraine before you start spewing such nonsense. I would suggest you to start with this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bJczLlwp-d8&list=PLh9mgdi4rN...

Now, I will assume you are just a misguided westerner who watches too much Fox news and indulge you:

> Ukraine is right on the russia's border.

So? How about US invading Mexico, occupying and annexing its lands, killing bunch of civilians while simultaneously demanding Mexico to "respect" US "sphere of influence", speak English, stop "threatening" it by committing to neutrality, etc.

> Their economies and cultures are intertwined.

Let them rape and indiscriminately kill bunch of civilians in some Bucha or other towns because of similar languages and economical ties? How does that make any sense to you? Also, claiming that Ukraine doesn't have its own historical roots and cultural identity is one of the Russian propaganda talking points.

> And their have been hostilities between the two

"Hostilities"? Excuse me? Russia occupied and annexed parts of Ukraine repeatedly but you dubbing it "hostilities" make it sound like some kind of a border skirmish where both parties are culpable which couldn't be further from the truth.

> since 2014 when the US formented a revolution there

Another Russian propaganda talking point. People were fed up with Yanukovich and decided to remove him from power. Support from US was inconsequential.

> I am not shilling for Russia

Yes you are! Openly and brazenly.

> peace agreement requires all parties to put everything on the table and deal openly

Well, yes, Russia would love Ukraine to put its lands "on the table", commit to neutrality, make Russian language the second national language and a lot more. And what exactly are the offering in return? To maybe stop attacking Ukraine for some time? Am I missing something?

> This could have happened.

It still can. Ukraine has been offering to solve the conflict through diplomacy as soon as Russia withdraw its forces. It is not like Ukraine is going to push into Russian territory to occupy Moscow and kill Putin. You understand that, do you?

Look, if you just prefer US to stop spending money on Ukraine you could just say so. Yes, this will lead to bunch of Ukrainians killed, raped or tortured in concentration (excuse me, "filtration"!) camps and you will feel somewhat bad for saying that, but at least it would be truthful. No need to play Tucker Carlson here with "border skirmishes" and "hostilities".

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by yesenadam on Sunday March 19, 2023 @03:50PM (#35222839)
Thank you so much for this comment. Until I read it, I was regretting having submitted this story, after seeing it marred by starkd's sickening 27-comment barrage of Russian propaganda and insults.

> How about US invading Mexico, occupying and annexing its lands

Hmm I think they already did that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mexican%E2%80%93American_War

TLDR: Map of Mexico in 1824 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Mexico_1824_(equirectangu...

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by caskstrength on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:45PM (#35223384)
> Hmm I think they already did that

I know. It seems US and Mexico have been having hostilities and border disputes for some time now, so annexing some more of Mexico's lands would seem like reasonable and expected course of action.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by ScoobleDoodle on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:26PM (#35220604)
“Vital national interest” as a pretext to invade another country and take their territory is a laughable definition. Laughable if it wasn’t causing so much death and destruction.

A deal along the lines of Trump’s: appease Russia by giving them what they want? Thankfully Biden is president and gives such nonsense no harbor.

Your logic is absurd, let me demonstrate: I have a vital interest in your bank accounts; it will allow me to feed many poor people and retire early. Please share the access info. And continuing with your logic I should be allowed to take it whether you share the details or not.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:13PM (#35221187)
Ukraine is right on Russia's border. Russia has occupied Crimea at various times in its history going back to Catherine the Great. Both regions are mixed economically and culturally. So, Russia has an interest in the regino, as much as the US has various national security interests all over the world. To say they have absolutely no interest is an arrogant attitude to say the least.

Maybe you should just sit this one out.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mopsi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:00PM (#35220281)
> The prime minister of Israel claims they had a deal worked out, but the Biden administration nixed it.

No he doesn't. https://www.businessinsider.com/israel-bennett-walks-back-cl...

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:04PM (#35220318)
Yeah, noticed "walks back". He just said he is now "unsure". Why did he say it in the first place? Sounds like the US put the squeeze on him, so he "walked it back". Nevertheless, there was SOMETHING on the table that could have been the basis for talks. They ruled it out of hand.

Business Insider is a rag, not credible.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mopsi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:05PM (#35220341)
His words were initially taken out of context; he meant that allies stopped pressuring Ukraine into a peace deal after mass graves were uncovered in Bucha. That's the only source for this conspiracy theory.

It goes against your whole narrative of how the US is forcing Ukraine into a war.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:21PM (#35220527)
There was still a basis on which talks could have been opened up. The fact they were entirely nixed shows they are not interested.

200,000 Ukrainian deaths when they can't even define what victory looks like beyond slogans. They are trying to fight a war on the cheap so long as no American casualties happen, but they are perfectly fine so long as they are Ukrainian casualties. At least, they could at least define what victory looks like and provide the means to do so.

Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mopsi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:34PM (#35220707)
There's nothing to negotiate at this point. Either Russia moves its guns and tanks and soldiers out of the whole Ukraine like they retreated from around Kharkiv, or Russia gets defeated on the battlefield. Anything else would leave Ukrainians in occupied territories to be wiped out by Russians. Russian hopes of a favorable peace deal is nothing but a coping mechanism, just like top Nazis hoped to reach a peace deal in 1945. Better prepare your cyanide pill.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by starkd on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:57PM (#35220988)
And that completely ignores how the world really works. You are perfectly content to risk WWIII. It is not 1945 anymore. You are risking a nuclear conflict that would be absolutely horrific.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by mopsi on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:12PM (#35221163)
What difference would a nuclear strike make anymore, several Ukranian cities have already been hit with more TNT equivalent than Hiroshima and Nagasaki and wiped from the earth: https://twitter.com/OstapYarysh/status/1632282407578611712
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by yesenadam on Sunday March 19, 2023 @04:13PM (#35223051)
Geez, that is just chilling, horrifying.
Re:Alternative facts: How the media failed Julian Assange by jcranmer on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:55PM (#35220968)
> There was still a basis on which talks could have been opened up. The fact they were entirely nixed shows they are not interested.

It is important to note that the party least interested in a workable peace deal at this point is Russia. After all, they annexed last October a large swath of Ukrainian territory in such a rushed manner they couldn't even properly explain what they annexed. Given that Russia seems uninterested in any peace deal which does not include Russian annexation of at least some portions of Ukraine, any argument that what Russia really cared about was NATO enlargement is laughably incorrect.