News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by aendruk on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:39PM (#35214347)
I just wish they’d tested it at my viewport width. The new design gives me clumsy, obfuscating UI elements that would be appropriate for a tiny touch screen, but stretched comically large across half my laptop screen. In a side-by-side comparison with the previous design it looks like they just destroyed the website.
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by paxys on Saturday March 18, 2023 @07:51PM (#35214433)
I like it. It isn't the most aesthetically pleasing site on a wide monitor but narrow column widths are optimal for reading. Plenty of studies have shown that people have difficulty reading beyond 50-60 characters and 9-12 words per line, so I'm happy they put content over design in this case. There's nothing wrong with blank space and wide margins. People will just get used to it. Old wikipedia was impossible to use at a 4K resolution.
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by layer8 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:13PM (#35214575)
One problem is if if you use a narrower browser window in the first place, for exactly the reasons you are citing, then now the TOC is hidden by default, whereas previously you could simply hit the Home key and/or use other normal in-page navigation to get to it.
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by waboremo on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:18PM (#35214603)
Also if you really hate the "wasted space" on the sides and you're on a giant resolution, find the expand button and the content stretches out. It's a horrible reading experience, but nobody can argue about wasted space when it's in expanded mode!
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by aendruk on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:05PM (#35214511)
I agree; you’re responding to something I didn’t say. At my viewport width the text column is wider than before.
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by Wowfunhappy on Saturday March 18, 2023 @08:00PM (#35214484)
Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by aendruk on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:13PM (#35214949)
I don’t know how you’re so sure. That whole page is describing an experience I don’t have.

> the table of contents is located next to the article so that you can see it immediately when you land on the page

No, it’s hidden behind a hamburger menu, no longer immediately visible.

> Why is the table of contents hidden sometimes? this should no longer be the case.

No, now it’s hidden for all articles.

> Why is the article width limited to 960px?

Not applicable; 960px is already the width of my viewport.

> Why is there so much empty space?

This is the reverse of my experience; due to the widening of the main column and removal of the inline table of contents, there is now less empty space.

> Case 7 (default for all below 1000px)

Sounds to me like I got lumped in with the phones.

Increasingly many websites exhibit this mode of failure so it’s not implausible for it to be a common blind spot.

Re:Design notes on the 2023 Wikipedia redesign by swalling on Sunday March 19, 2023 @12:20AM (#35215993)
If there are issues with a specific viewport width you can always file a bug at https://bugs.wikimedia.org/