Re:20 Years of Nix
by earthling8118 on Sunday March 19, 2023 @01:56PM
(#35221682)
I don't think it's very valid to compare the two. It is a little bit just to compare the experiences using them bit they aren't meant to solve the same set of issues. In fact, they are better together in my experience. I use nix to manage my terraform configurations with a lot of success. It reduces my boilerplate and helps me build abstractions on top of HCL.
If you ever decide to take a stab at nix again, consider looking at https://github.com/ipetkov/crane and using flakes. I've got it down to the point that I can get a new rust project set up with nix in about 30 seconds with linting, package building, and test running all in the checks
Crane is one of the libraries(?) I came across. Couldn’t get it to work on an existing multi-crate workspace project. The crane documentation as-is didn’t provide enough context to debug the errors I saw in the process of trying to muddle through. And then looking further afield ran into all the documentation, bootstrapping issues I alluded to above. Although I don’t doubt I could start a new project the point was to add new capability to existing work, for me.
It’s a shame. The promise of Nix/NixOS is really interesting — being able to deterministically create VMs with a custom user land is desirable to me — but in practice I can’t even get a simplistic project to compile, let alone something elaborate. Terraform is jank but it’s not a whole language that needs to be learned, seemingly, before the official docs start to become coherent in their underlying context.