News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by mpalmer on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:46AM (#35196388)
I'd like to see posts on LLMs written from a different perspective. For me, the surprise comes not from the sudden emergent capability of language models, but that the understanding (and synthesis!) of ideas encoded in language has succumbed to literally nothing more than statistical analysis. Or at least come that much closer to doing so.

That it bears so close a resemblance to actual thinking says more about the importance of language to cognition than the other way around.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by throwbadubadu on Friday March 17, 2023 @10:50AM (#35197833)
Interesting take.. especially as I often wondered, watching and loving animals, if not our ""intelligence separation"" from them is not to a large degree because of the language.. (and the wisdom storage and transfer that comes with it).
Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by guns on Friday March 17, 2023 @12:25PM (#35199217)
This is what Stephen Wolfram concludes in a recent article about ChatGPT:

> The specific engineering of ChatGPT has made it quite compelling. But ultimately (at least until it can use outside tools) ChatGPT is “merely” pulling out some “coherent thread of text” from the “statistics of conventional wisdom” that it’s accumulated. But it’s amazing how human-like the results are. And as I’ve discussed, this suggests something that’s at least scientifically very important: that human language (and the patterns of thinking behind it) are somehow simpler and more “law like” in their structure than we thought.

https://writings.stephenwolfram.com/2023/02/what-is-chatgpt-...

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by criddell on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:09PM (#35202232)
I wonder if different languages lead to different capabilities? If I ask the same question in English, Japanese, and German, will I reliably get “better” answers from one language over another.
Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by whimsicalism on Friday March 17, 2023 @04:23PM (#35202387)
The models transfer knowledge between languages, so probably some difference in capabilities but not a ton in core capabilities.

It can solve a physics problem in Telugu close to as well as in English.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by Animats on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:01PM (#35204532)
> (at least until it can use outside tools)

This is key. ChatGPT/GPT-4 alone are limited to reformulating what they know from their training data. Linked to search engines, databases, and computational tools such as Wolfram Alpha, they acquire much more capability. We're already seeing that with Microsoft Bing.

(Update: what happens as large language models learn Excel? Especially since Microsoft is already connecting them to Excel.)

What's striking is how fast this field is advancing. Huge advances over months, not years or decades.

We now have a much better idea of how intelligence evolved. It's mostly just more neurons. One of the great philosophical questions has, inadvertently, been answered.

Is the Singularity happening right now?

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by petilon on Friday March 17, 2023 @08:22PM (#35204670)
> ChatGPT/GPT-4 alone are limited to reformulating what they know from their training data.

That's not true. They are extrapolating. If they weren't, they wouldn't have the problem known as "hallucination".

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:52AM (#35209131)
>> Is the Singularity happening right now?

No, but it seems everyone loves to LARP it anyway.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by electrondood on Saturday March 18, 2023 @04:56PM (#35213016)
> Linked to search engines, databases, and computational tools such as Wolfram Alpha, they acquire much more capability.

I see this as analogous to the human brain; there are different structures which are particularly good at specific tasks/functions. They all work together.

The only difference between a human brain and an ANN is a difference of degree. A neuron and an artificial neuron are functionally identical. I think as we start interconnecting these models we see surprising emergent properties.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by LeanderK on Friday March 17, 2023 @12:56PM (#35199699)
I think the task of predicting the next word can be misunderstood. The better you want to be the more you have to "understand" how the previous words interacted. From the style of writing to the current topic discussed, the task gets increasingly complex if you want to be really, really good. How could the next sentence start? Will the author end the sentence here or keep going? These questions are very complex.

This does not mean that we humans might predict all the time, in fact I would argue that LLMs only predict during training. They generate otherwise. We might also learn by trying to predict. I can imagine babies doing it.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by svachalek on Friday March 17, 2023 @01:27PM (#35200119)
I had the same thought watching my son as a baby. So much of his day seemed to be focused on predicting what happens next, and he got so much joy when he succeeded. So many life skills are predicated on knowing that if I do this, that will happen, which gets me closer to my goal. I started to wonder if intelligence and prediction are really the same thing.
Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by whimsicalism on Friday March 17, 2023 @03:58PM (#35202059)
I find the phrase "statistical analysis" a frustrating one nowadays as it seems to have become a signal for "I hold a particular philosophy of the mind".

I don't understand this use of "statistical" as a diminutive to describe these models.

Why can't incredibly complicated behavior be emergent from matrix multiplication subject to optimization in the same way that our biological matter has developed complicated emergent properties also being subject to optimization?

The loss function is very different, the optimization techniques as well, but the fundamental idea of complex behavior emerging out of a substrate subject to optimization seems common. I haven't seen a single good answer to that

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by mpalmer on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:05PM (#35202902)
I can't say that my philosophy affected my choice of words in the way that you mean. I'm just expressing wonder at how well the abstraction performs.
Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by Jensson on Friday March 17, 2023 @05:14PM (#35202993)
> I find the phrase "statistical analysis" a frustrating one nowadays as it seems to have become a signal for "I hold a particular philosophy of the mind".

LLMs are trained to reproduce human text, that is different from for example AlphaGo that is trained to win Go games. Trained to reproduce data is what we mean with a statistical model, trained to win is how we got superhuman performance before, while trained to reproduce data performs worse than the original creators of the data.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by pixl97 on Saturday March 18, 2023 @10:13AM (#35209284)
This is reductive in the sense is that things like AlphaGo were bad at Go for a very long time, and then with more compute power and algorithm changes suddenly they were far better. And the problem space for go is absolutely huge it is still an insignificant portion of the problem space for knowledge.
Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by DanHulton on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:59PM (#35204025)
Well, to a degree, because we just don't do science like that.

You're the one supposing a thing, so the burden of proof is on you. You need to demonstrate that the "incredibly complicated behaviour" that you're referring to (I assume this is longhand for "thinking", but please correct me if I'm wrong) is indeed emerging from matrix multiplication. Especially given that what you're suggesting is unexpected, given the known way these models work and the explanations that have been put forth already that extrapolate from the known way these models work.

If science were so credulous as to accept the first proffered theory about a new development, well, we wouldn't have these interesting AI models in the first place!

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by YeGoblynQueenne on Saturday March 18, 2023 @09:56AM (#35209155)
Perhaps that's because you haven't asked a single good question?

What do matrix multiplication and optimisation have to do with the way the human mind, or the human brain work? That they have anything to do at all, is your assumption, that you seem absolutely convinced about- and then you go asking people why can't it be true? You say why it is true. It's your assumption.

Matrix multiplication and optimization are human mathematical techniques. They have about as good a chance of being something that exists in nature independently of humans as Magic: the Gathering and Call of Duty. They might be useful models to help us understand how things work, but to assume they are how things work is a huge leap of faith.

Ask the right questions and then an answer may even suggest itself. Ask questions that follow from your preconceived answers and you're in a world of fantasy.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by felipeerias on Friday March 17, 2023 @06:02PM (#35203490)
Some anthropologists suggest that our main evolutionary advantage was not so much our individual ability for reasoning, but our collective capacity to accumulate, evolve and transmit cultural knowledge over the centuries and millennia.

Skills like fire or language, for example, had a major influence in the development of our species and are mainly culturally transmitted: trying to reason your way into creating one or the other from scratch is a surprisingly difficult task.

If that point of view is true, then it shouldn’t be surprising that a large part of what we consider human-like behaviours should be tractable simply by analysing large amounts of data. AI systems are not modelling cognition, but culture.

Re:The Unpredictable Abilities Emerging from Large AI Models by BeFlatXIII on Sunday March 19, 2023 @07:49AM (#35218072)
To use my favorite Stephen Hawking quotation (that's also been sampled by Pink Floyd), "for millions of years, mankind lived just like the animals, then something happened that unleashed the power of our imagination: we learned to talk."