News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:On switching to Arch Linux by astrodust on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:06AM (#3518732)
Distributions like this can't be taken seriously. They're for the outcasts of the neckbeard crowd.

Cynically I suppose that the people involved in making this software aren't encouraged to improve ease of use because then they couldn't be "helpful" in the IRC channel used for support.

Is something like this the reason so many open-source projects so vehemently opposed to usability?

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by tammer on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:31AM (#3518832)
Disclaimer: I've been an incredibly happy Arch user for two years now (have it on all my home systems) which may indicate my bias.

Whether I'm an "outcast" or a "neckbeard" is entirely for others to decide. What I can tell you is that based on your comment, you simply have never experienced the joy of building something from scratch.

Rather than defend Arch explicitly, I'd like to use an example.

I like bicycles. I cycle 20 miles daily on my work commute and use my bike as my only form of transportation for running errands and getting around town.

The most "usable" route of transitioning to a car-free lifestyle would have to be going to a bike shop and buying one that fits. Now of course there's nothing wrong with this approach.

However, using this approach, when something goes wrong (as inevitably will happen with all machines, mechanical or digital) my reaction would most likely be be to look down at the problem, scratch my head, then walk my ass to the bike shop.

The approach I prefer is to build my bike from scratch. Acquire the perfect frame, the ideal wheelset, a rack that saves me some extra grams over what comes default on most transpo bikes.

Then all the tools.

When something goes wrong with my bike, I know exactly what's wrong. I know what shortcuts I took, what configuration I chose, and most importantly, I've got all the tools necessary to fix the problem.

Further, I know my bike is as fast and efficient as possible (given all necessary trade offs) because I was able to choose the ideal components.

tl;dr: I use Arch because time spent tinkering is time spent learning and optimizing. For more info I suggest anyone interested read The Arch Way: https://wiki.archlinux.org/index.php/The_Arch_Way

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by sivers on Friday January 27, 2012 @12:11PM (#3519018)
Thanks for this comparison. I hadn't noticed the similarities, but I'm the same way.

VERY happy Arch user for 2 years now. And also planning on building my own bicycle from scratch for the same reasons you named.

I wonder if this is one of those spectrums like Introvert ←→ Extrovert.

People who study the roots ←→ People who just pick the fruit.

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by colbyolson on Friday January 27, 2012 @05:14PM (#3520431)
I don't mean to hijack OPs response, but it reminded me of Robert M. Pirsig's book, Zen and the Art of Motorcycle Maintenance: An Inquiry into Values.

From Wikipedia: "In the book, the Narrator describes the "Romantic" approach to life of his friend John Sutherland, who chooses not to learn how to maintain his expensive new motorcycle. John simply hopes for the best with his bike, and when problems do occur he often becomes frustrated, and is forced to rely on professional mechanics to repair it. In contrast, the "classical" Narrator has an older motorcycle which he is usually able to diagnose and repair himself through the use of rational problem solving skills."

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zen_and_the_Art_of_Motorcycle_M...

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by anigbrowl on Friday January 27, 2012 @02:11PM (#3519651)
However, using this approach, when something goes wrong (as inevitably will happen with all machines, mechanical or digital) my reaction would most likely be be to look down at the problem, scratch my head, then walk my ass to the bike shop.

You could just learn to maintain/repair the store bike, which has after all been designed to work by someone, and probably does most of the time. I've ridden bikes for years and only replaced things as they wear. Not that there's anything wrong with building your bike from scratch, but it's not an automatic guarantee of superiority.

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by haha_rioja__ on Saturday January 28, 2012 @06:40PM (#3523797)
You could just learn to maintain/repair the store bike

Personally, I find Ubuntu like a store-bought bike that uses a bunch of non-standard parts. You may have a complete tool kit, but you don't have the right tool for this bike.

Or: when I troubleshoot Ubuntu, I learn Ubuntu. When I troubleshoot Arch, I learn Linux.

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by tammer on Friday January 27, 2012 @08:13PM (#3520983)
You're entirely correct, and I regret that the negativity in the above comment brought that statement from me.

In actuality, there's no superior way of learning, and no superior way of getting into cycling! Take the tone of my comment as a reaction.

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by nkassis on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:23AM (#3518804)
Some people like to know how things work, they like to take things apart and rebuild them. Linux From Scratch (the distro) might be the extreme of this but Arch seems to strike a decent balance.

Also, you do get more vanilla software from these distro. It's a lot less likely that someone modified the software to work with their distro idiosyncrasies. Sometimes that's a big plus.

I used Gentoo around 2002-2005 or so and I learn a great deal of what I know about Linux through the experience. I now run Ubuntu or Debian cause there are other things I want to learn about ;p

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by swasheck on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:38AM (#3518874)
Hooray for ad-hominems and sweeping generalizations!

I've found the Arch community to be EXTREMELY helpful because they are encouraged by people who want to know what's going on and not just taking whatever is pre-packaged into the distro and shoved down their throats.

The beauty of Linux is that there's something for everyone. We could speak with equal pejoratives about distributions that do everything for the user but the reality is that Arch is around because there is a community who wants it --- and they're not the "necbeard crowd."

What OS do you use? I'm sure we could hurl insults at you, too. That wouldn't be a constructive conversation, though.

Here I go again ... feeding trolls. Sorry folks.

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by oinksoft on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:09AM (#3518751)
I disagree with that, certainly there's space for a slackware-like distro with a decent package manager. Debian, RHEL, etc. are excellent, but there's no denying that they do some things in their own special ways, for better or worse. But with most sysadmins used to some combination of FreeBSD, Debian, and RHEL, I doubt very many would spring at the idea of something new with no discernible benefits.

Like you said, most people using Arch are those who want a great deal of control over their desktop machine, but without the compilation and general cruft of Gentoo. And those will be the ones putting Arch on servers, I believe.

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by jcurbo on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:28AM (#3518818)
Any distribution is going to form it's own 'way' though. It's a natural side effect of having a packaging system in the first place - you have to start standardizing some things. Take filesystem organization for instance - after many distros fought over this for years we got the FHS. But there are still thousands of open source projects out there that each do things their own way and if you install a bunch of them on one system you're going to have a mess unless there is some standardization. Debian has its own way of doing things but it was developed over time, just like Arch is developing ways of doing things now.
Re:On switching to Arch Linux by ff0066mote on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:41AM (#3518884)
Perhaps the "neckbeards" and "outcasts" you refer to prefer to fix the motorcycle when it breaks, instead of paying somebody else to it?

http://google.com/search?q=zen+and+the+art+of+motorcycle+mai...

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by lnteveryday on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:23AM (#3518803)
I find my system quite usable.

Most arch users attempt to solve their own problems before asking another.

What do you expect to get out of your system? Maybe Arch just isn't tailored for your needs (but you could certainly configure it to meet your needs with a pinch of effort).

Re:On switching to Arch Linux by nwj on Friday January 27, 2012 @11:50AM (#3518934)
astrodust, do you really honestly believe that people mostly use arch because they want to stroke their (neckbeard) egos and lord it over everybody else?

Maybe it is more likely that they use arch because it's the tool that meets their needs and that they enjoy using...