Me: Hello, I am asking you a logic question. Please explain what "it" is in the following sentence
Me: "The X doesn't fit in the Y because it is too small"
G4: In the sentence "The X doesn't fit in the Y because it is too small," the pronoun "it" refers to "X." The sentence is stating that "X" cannot fit inside "Y" due to its size being too small.
Me: "This is incorrect, please give step by step logic on why you came to this conclusion"
G4: Apologies for the confusion. I will provide a step-by-step logic for my interpretation:
The sentence is: "The X doesn't fit in the Y because it is too small." We need to identify what "it" refers to in the sentence. There are two nouns in the sentence: X and Y. The sentence structure is such that the reason for X not fitting in Y is provided after the word "because." The sentence states that something is "too small," which is the reason for the lack of fit. Since the reason for the lack of fit is being given, we can infer that the pronoun "it" should be referring to one of the two nouns. However, upon closer examination, my previous interpretation was incorrect. Revisiting the analysis, the correct interpretation should be as follows:
In the sentence "The X doesn't fit in the Y because it is too small," the pronoun "it" actually refers to "Y." The sentence is stating that "X" cannot fit inside "Y" because "Y" is too small to accommodate "X."
My initial interpretation was wrong because I didn't consider that "it" could refer to "Y" and that the sentence is explaining why "X" cannot fit in "Y."
There's no question that ChatGPT could pass the Turing test (assuming it's told to try and to not to say it's a computer).
So, from one standpoint we've made it. But I'm in the camp that says this really isn't the AGI I thought we were going to get. Semantics matter now, and we need better definitions of what we're trying to do now.
I believe an important part of the AGI problem has been solved (or is at least downhill from here). What to do about the other parts? Let's better define what we do and don't have.
That and come up with better tests to replace the now outdated Turing test.
ChatGPT is, an artificial generalized intelligence. But is that a useful label?
I imagine we'll be needing to find a way to better define and quantify intelligence (which has been a vexing issue for a long time)
This isn't the only erroneous bar either. Somehow, the synonymity to human intelligence is taking very weird importance. We have people inventing their imaginary/magical definitions of reasoning and understanding (that they can't test for) just so LLMs won't qualify.
GPT-4 is absolutely a general intelligence.
This is the only possible outcome. Or at least from my interpretation is that science fiction has jaded us with the thinking that AI will be anything like a person at all. The human mind is a particular set of filters controlled by our wetware input devices and a somewhat narrow survivability window. The software we're building has a completely different set of 'mind' conditions so it's a mathematical certainty we're going to build mind that works very different from ours.
As you say we need better sets of definitions on what general intelligence even means. For example, what are the limits of human intelligence to ensure we're not missing broad categories of potential intelligence when testing AIs.
These LLMs are trained for one skill: given the previous N tokens, what's the next token. From this single skill, they can generalize to many many many many useful use-cases. Is that general enough?
Or do we need to wait for the goalposts to move again and then blow past that limit too? Stop arguing semantics and start building cool shit.