News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by echion on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:44AM (#35169053)
> why is it that we allow a bank to not mark-to-market a security for which there is a liquid market?

Because at maturity, the bank gets back its money. So it is perfectly valid to say "in ten years, this $100m bond is worth $100m...and I intend to hold it for ten years, so it's worth $100m [equivalent] today". The "I intend to hold it" is the relevant part of the valuation, though.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by jasode on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:41AM (#35170018)
>So it is perfectly valid to say "in ten years, this $100m bond is worth $100m...and I intend to hold it for ten years, so it's worth $100m [equivalent] today".

But that valuation model is not perfectly valid. It's only partially valid under limited scenarios.

As many comments have already pointed out, the issue is that you have bank customers with demand deposits. The customers can demand withdrawal of their money anytime -- without advanced notice. In other words, SVB is not a hedge fund that has the customers deposits contractually locked up for 10 years.

Therefore, the "10 year bond held to maturity" becomes invalid if the bank has to sell them prematurely at distressed discount prices -- to meet liquidity requirements of demand deposits.

You can't use value securities as "mark-to-intended-optimal-future" as an alternative to "mark-to-market" for purposes of insolvency risk calculations.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:52AM (#35170195)
> But that valuation model is not perfectly valid. It’s only partially valid under limited scenarios.

Its valid under the applicable regulations. However, it is one case where having adequate capital under those rules was not backstopped by available liquidity measures from the Fed.

One thing that seems to be generating less commentary is that, in the wake of the SVB collapse, and virtually simultaneously to the announcement of the systemic risk exception for SVB by the FDIC/Treasury/Fed, the Federal Reserve also announced a generally-available liquidity backstop program for this kind of hold-to-maturity assets.

> You can’t use value securities as “mark-to-intended-optimal-future” as an alternative to “mark-to-market” for purposes of insolvency risk calculations.

To the extent that refers to valuing the class of assets at issue at their par value, and to the extent that that was true last week, its not now.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:01PM (#35172262)
>You can't use value securities as "mark-to-intended-optimal-future" as an alternative to "mark-to-market" for purposes of insolvency risk calculations.

I think this is exactly correct, but I dont think that is the purpose and scenario reported on their financial statements. I think it is fine to report valuation in terms of "mark-to-solvent future", as long as the appropriate data is provided to enable insolvency risk calculations, and the "mark-to-solvent future" model is not presented or confused with a insolvency risk model.

If an investor does not understand how HTM assets are accounted per regulation, but they are accurately reported, confusing the models is an investor error, not a bank reporting error.

My understanding is that banks provide clear reporting, and are transparent with their HTM portfolio.

HTM securities are typically reported as separate noncurrent assets; they have an amortized cost on a company's financial statements.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by jnwatson on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:11PM (#35172412)
Exactly. If you have a portfolio of 100% HTM bonds, your income schedule is completely predictable, down to the cent at every moment in time.

But your deposit demand is unpredictable and must be modeled. I don’t think even Taleb would have the scenario of “on Friday, you’ll lose $40b of deposits.” The bank would have had to be sitting on billions of T-bills, which ain’t gonna happen.

It seems like every bank is a tweet away from destruction.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:52AM (#35169218)
> The "I intend to hold it" is the relevant part of the valuation, though.

Yup, and definitely anticipate there will be major new regulations in this area. A huge part of SVB's book of bonds were categorized as "Hold to Maturity". And, legally, if you mark bonds as HTM, you are not allowed to hedge against their interest rate risk. Basically, the regulations say that if you're hedging against interest rate risk, you don't really intend to hold to maturity, so you need to put them in the "Available for Sale" category.

The fact that SVB had such a huge book of bonds at paltry rates with no/minimal hedging is just awful risk management.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by dragonwriter on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:01PM (#35170364)
> Yup, and definitely anticipate there will be major new regulations in this area.

It already happened. The new regulation is that the Fed now has a liquidity backstop for banks holding this asset class, using cash loans with a set maximum term against the par value.

Apparently the Fed decided “if we treat it this way for capital adequacy, and we provide liquidity backstops for banks for other asset classes based on how they are valued for capital adequacy, maybe we should do the same thing here, since otherwise adequate capital can easily and suddenly become inadequate.”

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by bryananderson on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:15PM (#35171532)
This backstop only applies to existing holdings. Banks can't go out today and load up on hold-to-maturity assets and expect the Fed to backstop them tomorrow with loans at par value. Presumably the next step is to regulate HTM holdings so that this won't be necessary again, or else you're creating a moral hazard.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by daydream on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:14PM (#35170565)
> And, legally, if you mark bonds as HTM, you are not allowed to hedge against their interest rate risk. Basically, the regulations say that if you're hedging against interest rate risk, you don't really intend to hold to maturity, so you need to put them in the "Available for Sale" category.

This seems like an important point that I haven’t seen mentioned elsewhere. Lots of folks have been like “these people are morons they didn’t hedge their crappy bonds.” Can you write more about this?

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by hn_throwaway_99 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:27PM (#35172584)
Well, "these people are morons they didn’t hedge their crappy bonds" is pretty much correct. Here's a good explainer on the topic: https://corporatefinanceinstitute.com/resources/accounting/h... .

But it's not just that they didn't hedge their interest rate risk, it's also that they assumed that their deposit base would continue to stay the same or grow. The problem is that their highly correlated deposit base of tech startups actually all needed to take their money out at the same time when they couldn't get additional funding.

Thus, it's important to understand that banks themselves make the choice of whether a bond goes into the "held to maturity" or "available for sale" bucket. I'm not a bank compliance officer so I don't know the rules about how much they're allowed to put in each bucket, but one problem was that SVB incorrectly estimated how much liquidity they would need because they didn't plan for the risk of their deposits all needing to be drawn down simultaneously.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by landemva on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:33PM (#35175035)
They went overweight in long duration bonds to get a little more yield. Terrible timing when interest rates were at 1000-year lows, but it kept the bonuses flowing and the stock compensation in the green.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by UncleMeat on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:51AM (#35169197)
But the entire point of computing current assets is to understand the effects of rapid withdrawals from the bank. If you are trying to predict the future value of the bank or how much money they will make then looking at the value at maturity makes sense. But the regulatory system doesn't (or shouldn't) care about that. The regulatory system should be concerned with estimating and mitigating the risk of sudden bank failure.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by stanleydrew on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:55AM (#35169269)
I believe this is what various "stress tests" are for. If your bank is a certain size you have to basically do scenario planning for situations like ”what if 25% of your deposits leave overnight and you have to sell securities that you didn't plan to sell?” As I understand the situation, SVB was just under the required size to submit to those stress tests.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by fifticon on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:09AM (#35169503)
to my understanding, they themselves lobbied legislators to put them under that size (by increasing the ceiling).
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by fwlr on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#35170403)
There are smaller tests for liquidity, but the specific major stress test that SVB lobbied themselves out of is the DFAST (the Dodd Frank Act Stress Test) and it does not test liquidity. It takes the scenario of an adverse economic situation and comes up with a bunch of hypothetical numbers you might see for major economic variables - “the unemployment rate will be this, the default rate will be that, etc,” - and then banks have to run their books according to those hypothetical numbers and report back what their capital would look like in that situation. If it looks bad, they have to take action to make their capital more secure. Nowhere does it simulate a situation where depositors leave en masse.

There are liquidity tests and SVB was probably failing them (which is probably why the FDIC was paying close attention to them), but that specific test you’ve heard about is not related.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by insonable on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#35171106)
Domestic-focused banks with over $250B in assets need to comply with the Basel III inspired (I think?) LCR of enough high-quality liquid assets to cover 30 bad days of withdrawals. What is the requirement for banks under $250B? Another Q would be, did they sell their extension-risk suffering bond portfolio because those bonds didn't qualify as HQLA? I mean they'd seem to me to be liquid and high-quality just as they were, but any sales would harm their balance sheet right?
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by insonable on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:20PM (#35170644)
The original asset threshold over which banks were subject to "enhanced prudential standards" in the 2010 Dodd-Frank bill was $50B. In 2018 the requirement was amended to >$250B in assets, or at the discretion of the Fed for banks over $100B. SVB was reportedly at $210B in assets.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by bostik on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:43PM (#35172838)
And SVB were one of the banks lobbying for that amendment. At the time they were falling close to the $50B limit themselves.

So they certainly would have known at the time that being subject to the stricter regulations would have hurt their profitability.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by andrekandre on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:49PM (#35172943)
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by codeflo on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:22AM (#35169718)
> The "I intend to hold it" is the relevant part of the valuation, though.

It’s really not, at least not mathematically. That intentions play a role is purely an artifact of regulations.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by echion on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:33PM (#35174336)
> > relevant

> not mathematically

Agreed. I don't think the GP was asking a mathematical question, so "relevant" meant "to explain why MTM accounting is not the only way".

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by tnel77 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:50AM (#35169176)
Maybe both metrics would be useful. “If we had to sell today, this is our situation. If these bonds are held to maturity, this will be our situation.”

Seems like that would allow an investor to see the state of the bank more clearly.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by echion on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:36PM (#35174368)
Definitely. And SVB's financial reporting / balance sheet showed this problem beforehand, AIUI.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by shapefrog on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:19AM (#35169663)
Except the treasury desk is paying 5% to the person who gave you the $100m to buy the bond that is paying you and interest rate of 1%.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by kmod on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:44AM (#35170075)
Welcome to a non-zero interest rate environment. "$100m equivalent today" is not $100m -- the term to search for is "net present value". These considerations are precisely what marking to market captures
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:53AM (#35170215)
If those assets are in your hold to maturity portfolio, they are still worth $100m. This return is guaranteed unless the Federal Bank defaults on those treasuries.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by bjacokes on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:07PM (#35170463)
You're saying that if a bank paid $100m for low-yielding bonds in 2021 which are now worth $80m, those bonds should be valued at $100m on the bank's balance sheet. What if a different bank pays $80m today for the same bonds? Should they be able to show an immediate $20m increase in their book value because those bonds are "worth $100m"?
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by prewett on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:42PM (#35170990)
The problem is that they are worth $100m if held to maturity (you get your $100m back, ergo their value is $100m if held to maturity), but the current price is $80m, because who wants to buy a bond at 0% when you could get around 5% at the next Treasury auction.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by mikewarot on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:11PM (#35171464)
Not only that, but the value could drop even more if an inflationary spiral happens... Bank prime loan rates have been higher than 20% in the past, which means a $100m bond 5 years out could go as low as $33m in value... a 67% haircut!

Clearly, US Treasuries carry risk that's not been accounted for.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by landemva on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:42PM (#35175127)
> US Treasuries carry risk that's not been accounted for.

US treasury debt is approximately the safest. The risk was that SVB might need cash before the bonds matured. The regulations encouraged SBV to do this. Now the Fed put is re-imagined, and we shuffle on while mumbling 'nobody could have imagined'.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by bjacokes on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:39PM (#35174401)
They're worth $80m today, and then maybe $82m next year, $84m the year after, and so on until they're worth $100m at maturity. (Obviously these numbers depend on current and future interest rates, and you'd be earning some interest in the meantime).

As I was trying to point out to the parent commenter, conflating "$100m today" with "$100m at maturity" leads to clear contradictions, like saying that a bank could earn $20m on paper simply by buying bonds trading below par value. Or to put it another way – if bank A holds $100m face value of 10-year bonds yielding 4%, and bank B holds $100m face value of 10-year bonds yielding 2% (but worth, say, $80m at market price), how can you claim that those banks are on equally good footing?

Valuing liquid bonds at par value is pretty clearly a hack to reduce volatility and increase confidence in banks' balance sheets, even if some people in the comments seem to view it as a more logical way of accounting. (Although to be clear, I don't mind companies doing their own fuzzy math as long as they give investors enough information to do proper due diligence. It's similar to the non-GAAP earnings that a lot of tech companies report.)

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:09PM (#35175415)
>As I was trying to point out to the parent commenter, conflating "$100m today" with "$100m at maturity" leads to clear contradictions, like saying that a bank could earn $20m on paper simply by buying bonds trading below par value. Or to put it another way – if bank A holds $100m face value of 10-year bonds yielding 4%, and bank B holds $100m face value of 10-year bonds yielding 2% (but worth, say, $80m at market price), how can you claim that those banks are on equally good footing?

Equal assets should never be thought to mean equal footing. The banks will show the same number for assets locked up for 10 years, but the banks will also show that they have different returns listed on their finalcial statement for the HTM assets, and different revenue from capital!

You cant and shouldnt expect to bank comparison to be easily reduced to a single measure, or for that measure to tell you something that is captured elsewhere.

It is like expecting an athlete's height to tell you something about their speed or strength.

HTM assets tell you the nominal value of assets they are holding to maturity.

It is not intended to show how much they could raise if they had to liquidate it today. It is not intended to show what that yield is for their bonds.

There are separate line items for that.

If you change the valuation of the bonds to market value, then you lose sight of the mature value of those bonds.

Replacing athlete height with athlete BMI tells you something different.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by flakeoil on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:49PM (#35171099)
This thread with NPV is confusing the liquidity issue with the profit of the bond investment. The issue for this bank was not if this was a good or bad investment in the long run (these bonds might very well turn out to be a good investment the day they are paid back on), the issue here is that the bank's customers wanted to withdraw their money and there was not enough liquidity/cash in the bank so they had to sell something and the best/only thing they could sell was the bonds which right now were worth only $80m and the customer wanted their $100m.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:49PM (#35174514)
Yes and yes, if they are allocated for HTM.

If you put cash in a a CD with a 1 year lock in, do you list it at current value or subtract a withdraw penalty.

Do you subtract early withdrawal penalties when calculating the balance in your 401k?

At the end of the day, a list of your asset values is not the same as how much you could liquidate those assets for today.

That would be a list of liquidatable assets.

HTM assets are called out separately on the balance sheet specifically to highlight that they cannot be easily liquidated.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by pg314 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:13PM (#35170556)
> If those assets are in your hold to maturity portfolio, they are still worth $100m.

They are still worth $100m at maturity. $100m in ten years is (usually) worth less than $100m now. Do you really want to pretend that a ten year bond you purchased when inflation and the interest rate were near zero, is worth the same when inflation and the interest rate go up to say 10%? What about inflation of 100%? In nominal terms you’ll get back your capital, but in real terms you will get back only one thousandth.

To correctly value them now you need to calculate the NPV.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by jameshart on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:22PM (#35170678)
You can’t calculate NPV. You can only estimate it.

You can value something at its current market value, if the asset is one that has such a thing. And fair market value will generally correspond to what you would estimate to be net present value, plus whatever risk premiums and holding costs and so on that the market is accounting for.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by pg314 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:34PM (#35172698)
> You can’t calculate NPV. You can only estimate it.

According to Merrian-Webster [1]:

calculate: 1 b: to reckon by exercise of practical judgment : ESTIMATE

[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/calculate

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by jameshart on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:42PM (#35172824)
Okay, weird bit of pedantry - pretty sure that if a math test asks you to ‘calculate the product of 127 and 954’ you wouldn’t get many marks for answering ‘about 100,000’, but feel free to staple a copy of the dictionary definition to your exam paper and see if that works for you.

But sure, let me clarify it to: you can’t calculate a precise NPV.

You can only estimate one.

Which, when we are trying to do things like ‘calculate the total assets a bank has’, makes the net present value of their assets a not very reliable number to use.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by pg314 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:24PM (#35173439)
> Okay, weird bit of pedantry - pretty sure that if a math test asks you to ‘calculate the product of 127 and 954’ you wouldn’t get many marks for answering ‘about 100,000’, but feel free to staple a copy of the dictionary definition to your exam paper and see if that works for you.

I wasn't taking a math test. I was saying something about NPV using a common meaning of an English word. You chose to ascribe a different meaning to that word, and pedantically - and incorrectly - tried to correct me.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:54PM (#35171172)
In real terms, you will get back exactly a hundred million. In the npv at that date will be exactly 100 million.

$1 after inflation is still $1. It is just that the value of $1 is now different.

As long as you hold to maturity, the number of dollars does not change.

If you report your Holdings in terms of dollars, they are always accurate as long as you hold.

If someone tells you they have $100 maturing in 10 years, it is Trivial for you to do the npv calculation yourself with your speculative model of what inflation will look like over the next 10 years.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by pg314 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:31PM (#35172659)
> In real terms, you will get back exactly a hundred million.

In nominal terms. In real terms you have to adjust for inflation. [1] is a starting point if you want to read more.

> As long as you hold to maturity, the number of dollars does not change.

A dollar now is not the same as a dollar 10 years from now. [2]

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Real_versus_nominal_value_(eco... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Time_preference

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:12PM (#35174087)
I think we are misaligned on the reference time for the real valuation.

If you buy a 10 year bond today, you will get $100m dollars in 2023.

In 2033, that $100m will have a real value of $100m 2033 dollars on your balance sheet.

HTM assets are reported in the nominal purchase price today, which is also the real dollar value if you calculated it on the day of maturity.

I agree that if you estimated the net present value of $100m 2033 dollars, it would be worth less in terms of 2023 dollars.

This brings us back to your earlier question

>Do you really want to pretend that a ten year bond you purchased when inflation and the interest rate were near zero, is worth the same when inflation and the interest rate go up to say 10%? What about inflation of 100%? In nominal terms you’ll get back your capital, but in real terms you will get back only one thousandth.

YES! This way the asset sheet is always correct in how much you will get for the asset. If you have a $100 nominal bond it is worth $100 dollars. That is true today, and that will be true on the day of maturity. It will be true every day in between. The dollar value of the asset remains constant at the time of reporting.

Why would you want to report the net present value of that asset at maturation - which sounds like what you are suggesting?

The point of listing your bonds on your balance sheet isn't to estimate profit or returns, it is to list your current asset allocation.

You have a separate line item for revenue coming from those bonds. You have a separate model entirely for calculating ROI and profitability.

If you made a spreadsheet of your current asset allocation today, how would you list money locked in a 10 yr CD. As the dollar amount in the account, the value if you were forced to pull it out and pay a penalty, or some time shifted valuation?

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by chordalkeyboard on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:14PM (#35173305)
> In real terms, you will get back exactly a hundred million. In the npv at that date will be exactly 100 million.

you wrote 'real terms' when you meant 'nominal terms.'

> $1 after inflation is still $1. It is just that the value of $1 is now different.

That is why we distinguish between 'real value' and 'nominal value.'

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:19PM (#35174174)
>> $1 after inflation is still $1. It is just that the value of $1 is now different.

>That is why we distinguish between 'real value' and 'nominal value.'

What will the real value of a $1 bond be on your balance sheet the day it matures? exactly $1

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by chordalkeyboard on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:40PM (#35174410)
> What will the real value of a $1 bond be on your balance sheet the day it matures? exactly $1

The real value in future-date dollars will be $1. In present-day dollars it is likely to be less, the ability to refer to which distinction is the purpose of the formal difference between nominal and real value.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @05:54PM (#35175257)
I agree. The difference between the two converges to zero as your your comparison time frames go to zero.

Initial time for real dollar caluculation can be anything. You can ask what your real dollar salary is relative to 1950, or relative to 1951, or yesterday.

You can ask what was the real dollar salary in 1951 relative to 1950, or 2051 compared to 2050.

While I meant to write real dollars, I wish I wrote nominal, based on how much confusion it caused.

I still stand by the idea that it is silly, and not very useful to put a future return on investment on an asset list in to 2023 dollars using a 10 year inflation projection.

Then the reported asset would fluctuate based on your model, and you already know exactly where it will end on the maturation date.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by chordalkeyboard on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:24PM (#35175557)
> Initial time for real dollar caluculation can be anything. You can ask what your real dollar salary is relative to 1950, or relative to 1951, or yesterday.

Regardless of which day's dollars we use as a baseline for comparison, a bond issued under at a lower interest rate is discounted relative to the same bond issued later at a higher interest rate. Quibbling about how we express this valuation suggests you don't understand this difference, but this difference is important to understanding the current day banking crisis.

> While I meant to write real dollars, I wish I wrote nominal, based on how much confusion it caused.

You still seem unaware that these meanings and words are a very well understood convention that you violated. The only confusion was the confusion you had in the meanings you assigned to the words.

> I still stand by the idea that it is silly, and not very useful to put a future return on investment on an asset list in to 2023 dollars using a 10 year inflation projection.

The main thing is that these valuation rules exist for reasons and while we could debate which rules are good etc., understanding the basics of bond valuation and the common terminology we use to discuss them is a minimum prerequisite and I'm still working on getting you on board with the basic terminology every one else is using.

There isn't much discussion to be had without a common vocabulary.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @06:52PM (#35175808)
Im fine with your terminology and reference. The current date (or that of reporting) can be the reference time for a real dollar valuation.

I fully understand how bond market prices are impacted by interest rates. What most people seem ignorant of is the fact that bonds are not simply market trades asset, but are also have a value at maturity. Most people don't seem to know that HTM assets are reported separate from securities available for sale, which ARE tracked at market value.

And then there's the even stupider idea that the value of long-term assets should be listed as the maturation date npv, as if you can just look up future inflation rates for the next 10 to 30 years.

It seems obvious to me that if you never intend to sell a bond, the maturity value is a measure of interest.

Do you have anything else to add to the discussion, or was that your only point?

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by chordalkeyboard on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @08:33PM (#35176646)
> It seems obvious to me that if you never intend to sell a bond, the maturity value is a measure of interest.

The reason this matters is because in the case of a bank who needs the funds to operate then they very much might need to sell the bonds, or revalue them at NPV because of statutory requirements.

This entire discussion is because the NPV of HTM assets is now relevant.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:26PM (#35177787)
That doesn't mean it is universally relevant, nor does it mean it is more relevant than the maturity value in the asset table.

Most importantly, Banks already DO report the unrealized losses and Fair market value on HTM securities. Just not in the assists section, but in a dedicated section on the HTM assets. It is not some big secret.

You can even look at it in silicon valley Banks filings if you want(1). They break down the HTM losses and fair market value plain as day starting on page 125.

At the time of filing, the reported a mature value of 91 billion, fair value of 76 million, and unrealized losses of 15 billion. They break it down by the duration of maturity. Everything someone could ask for is there.

It seems to me that this whole question of reporting fair market value instead of maturity in the asset table comes from people who have never read a 10-k filing and think there is some conspiracy.

SVBs situation should have been no surprise to anyone looking. The real conspiracy is their HTM position was common knowledge.

https://www.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/719739/0000719739230...

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by kmod on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:04PM (#35170409)
$100m future dollars, which are less valuable than present dollars.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by daveguy on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:29PM (#35170784)
That's hedging against inflation (which is definitely something they should have been doing for long term bonds). Interest rates directly affect the sale price of a bond, and it could have been hedged against, but it wasn't required. They won't do it unless it's required. Banks over 50 billion need to be regulated again (and they should lower it to 10 billion too).
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:36PM (#35171889)
$100m future dollars are still still $100m dollars. It is the value of the dollar that is changing, not the number of them that you hold.

The day you are paid, you will still get handed exactly $100m million.

Every day between now and then you will still have exactly $100m in bond holdings. How many cheeseburgers you can buy with that number of dollars may change from day to day, but the number of dollars will not.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by morelisp on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:07PM (#35173198)
You don't need to appeal to cheeseburgers to not want to value 100 future dollars at 100 current dollars, if you can buy 100 future dollars for 80 current dollars, which is essentially what happened when rates rose.

(Someone else is offering 100 future for 80 current because they have a forecast about cheeseburgers, sure. But you don't have to agree with that forecast to take their deal; the deal looks even better for you if you don't agree.)

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by s1artibartfast on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:30PM (#35174302)
The whole point of HTM as an asset class is that you dont plan to sell it.

Think of how you would report a non-transferable asset with maturation on your balance sheet?

How would you report savings in a CD with a steep early exit penalty?

Herein lies the difference between a list of assets, and a list of asset liquidation value.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by echion on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:27PM (#35174262)
> the term to search for is "net present value"

I understand NPV. I'd edit my post to put "$100m equivalent [NPV] today" to makes it clearer what was meant by "equivalent", but it's too late, and that's precisely what I nodded to with "equivalent" -- no need for jargon to get the sense across.

> These considerations are precisely what marking to market captures.

Of course. And they are -- in theory -- exactly what GP seemed to be asking about. Valuing an instrument at its NPV (NOT MTM) is perfectly reasonable...as a starting point. GP was questioning that. As everyone has pointed out, and anyone who's bootstrapped a yield curve or traded bonds (I have) knows, there are a ton of nuance and caveats to this, but the GP was not dealing with those and they are not relevant to GP's primary point/question.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by SilasX on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @01:52PM (#35172129)
The problem, though, is that it's not necessarily 100% up to them whether they'll hold it to maturity, since withdrawals can force them to liquidate it. It seems like they should have a ruling forcing the use of some formula that factors in this possibility.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by OJFord on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:32PM (#35177054)
But why is that valid, if it's trading below par?

In the extreme - obviously you can't buy a call option and say 'I intend to hold this until it's $10 in the money, so it's actually worth (time-adjusted) $10'. What's the difference, besides probabilities of outcomes?

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by ars on Thursday March 16, 2023 @01:04AM (#35178293)
Let's extend your example - I have a bond that costs $1 today, but is worth $1,000 at maturity - except that maturity is in 1,000 years.

So, can the bank claim it has $1,000 now?