News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:57AM (#35168401)
Stablecoins are conspicuous in their absence in patio11's post. Personally, I believe that patio11's loathing of crypto has made him incurious about its potential. But that's not the point here. The point is that stablecoins are about to become a Very Good Deal for ordinary people:

In the near future, stablecoins like USDC will become immune to bank runs because the US Dollar reserves backing them will be held in vehicles that don't loan out the reserves and hold short-duration treasuries directly with the Treasury Department.

At the same time, any person or entity with USDC in their wallet has instant, 24/7 access to global markets at their sole discretion, without intermediaries.

On Ethereum today, anyone can buy Coinbase stock, treasuries, an S&P 500 index, and real estate.

In short, the UX of stablecoins is becoming vastly superior to bank deposits because you'll be immune to bank runs, control your own money, and have instant access to global markets, including for low-risk yield on your stablecoins, such as in treasuries or over-collateralized lending.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by pjc50 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @09:58AM (#35168419)
This is essentially fanfiction, as stablecoins so far have been very opaque about what they do with their reserves. Especially Tether.

(largely because the mechanics of holding $60bn in treasuries would attract some questions about KYC which stablecoins are unable to answer)

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:00AM (#35168449)
You're right that internationally-run Tether (USDT) is the largest stablecoin and has opaque reserves.

However, American-run USDC is growing faster and has excellent transparency:

https://www.circle.com/en/transparency

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by overthrow on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:17AM (#35168663)
It's also worth noting that the US government itself sometimes uses USDC when there is no better option. If there were any doubts of USDC's legitimacy, the government would be trying to shut it down (see: USDT), not using it for transfers.

https://www.nasdaq.com/articles/us-government-enlists-usdc-f...

https://www.circle.com/blog/circle-partners-with-bolivarian-...

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by rabf on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:17AM (#35169622)
Circle and Tether can freeze their stablecoins for AML/KYC and to stop criminal exploits on chain, and have done this many times in the past. Also to change to regular fiat you will be doing that via a regulated entity which will have done the appropriate AML/KYC checks on you.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by misssocrates on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:37PM (#35170911)
The fanfiction is that banks can be trusted. USDC and Tether have a better track record than even big banks like SVB.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by pjc50 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:40PM (#35170957)
What's Tether's holding breakdown? How do you know they're not exposed to the same bond duration issue?
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by swores on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:59PM (#35171251)
Tether has existed for under a decade, USDC is less than 5 years old, and SVB died after 39 years.

Yes technically "still alive" is better than "just died", but can you really call it a "better track record" when Tether is so opaque that we wouldn't be able to spot if it was about to die until it actually happens? If Tether died tomorrow it would undeniably have a worse track record than SVB, if it dies in a decade then it survived half as long as SVB.

Unless you have some insight into the actual behind the scenes finances of Tether I don't see how you can make that judgement.

And as to this claim from your GP's comment:

> In the near future, stablecoins like USDC will become immune to bank runs because the US Dollar reserves backing them will be held in vehicles that don't loan out the reserves and hold short-duration treasuries directly with the Treasury Department.

Circle (USDC) literally had $3.3B cash deposited at SVB, and presumably more accounts at other banks, so they're exposed directly to potential problems caused by those banks. More importantly they could decide tomorrow, assuming they haven't already, to make the exact same poor choices as any bank could.

There's nothing stopping them moving 95% of their assets tomorrow into 10 year treasury bonds other than that it would be a bad idea, but both they and banks are equally motivated to avoid bad ideas, so it seems to be an unwarranted hope that those in charge of Circle will make better decisions than those in charge of any bank, rather than any specific feature of USDC that makes it impossible for them to make the exact same mistake SVB made?

And that's even before considering that if it had been USDC rather than SVB that made the mistake already, FDIC wouldn't have come running in to fix anything as they try to with failed banks.

Am I missing something about USDC that actually makes it a safer bet, other than apparently having more faith in their management team than in the management teams of various banks?

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by snarf21 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:04AM (#35168498)
Except that 99.9% of people will buy "stable" coins on Coinbase. Not your keys, not your crypto. If Coinbase gets leveraged or goes the way of SFB, you have literally the same non-immunity as a bank run except you also don't get FDIC backstops.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:08AM (#35168549)
You're right, stablecoins held custodially in an entity could be subject to similar contagion.

Yet, non-custodial holding is becoming much easier and safer.

Crucially, wallets are improving a lot, and a spectrum of custodial options is developing, with rich tradeoffs in eg. safety and self-sovereignty.

For example https://www.coinbase.com/blog/how-smart-cryptography-makes-c...

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by brvsft on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:06AM (#35168525)
SFB? You mean SVB? SBF?
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by snarf21 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:19AM (#35168688)
Sorry, I meant SBF but transposed.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by mtoner23 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:00AM (#35168451)
USDC may have instant 24/7 access to global markets. But why did the price of USDC drop to 90 cents this weekend. It isn't immune bank runs.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:04AM (#35168502)
You're right, last weekend, USDC dropped to a low of ~$0.88.

However note

- SVB was closed on a Friday (as is the FDIC's custom). This meant that USDC could not process redemptions over the weekend as banks were closed, and this created fear in the market.

- USDC had 8% of their reserves trapped in SVB. The fair market value of USDC would have been $0.92 if all SVB deposits were lost, which was never likely.

- crucially, USDC operator Circle has acknowledged the need to transition to a "full reserve" model where reserves aren't subject to bank runs. https://twitter.com/jerallaire/status/1635548066185871360

- over the weekend, USDC did lose its $1 peg and trade as low as ~$0.88. However, all USDC holders were able to maintain access their USDC to do whatever they wanted with it, which is a lot better than SVB depositors frozen and waiting to see what happened.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by lordfrito on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:16AM (#35168654)
> stablecoins are about to become a Very Good Deal for ordinary people

> the UX of stablecoins is becoming vastly superior to bank deposits because you'll be immune to bank runs, control your own money, and have instant access to global markets, including for low-risk yield on your stablecoins, such as in treasuries or over-collateralized lending

I disagree, but OK

> over the weekend, USDC did lose its $1 peg and trade as low as ~$0.88

Hmmm doesn't seem like a Very Good Deal for an ordinary person.

> However note

Oh, now I see what you're doing. It's a Very Good Deal, except reasons

> However, all USDC holders were able to maintain access their USDC to do whatever they wanted with it

So it might have dropped 12%, but they still had access. That's a win to you?

Your definition of stable is vastly different than mine.

My FDIC backed bank account is guaranteed not to lose value.

I don't understand the cognitive dissonance on display here.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:58AM (#35170317)
For your objection to refute my thesis, you'd need to explain how a world with stablecoins that are immune to bank runs, where those stablecoins are held in next-gen wallets and can be swapped into any asset in the world 24/7 any time you want at the click of a button, is not a superior UX vs. today's bank deposits.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by lordfrito on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:44PM (#35171020)
> you'd need to explain how a world with stablecoins that are immune to bank runs...

Wait... I need to explain this? I don't even believe in it.

I'm not really interested in arguing theoretical constructs. You yourself admitted that just last weekend a stablecoin dropped to 88 cents on the dollar (while my bank dollars were still worth one dollar each).

Before I prove anything, why don't you start by proving (heck just demonstrate) a long term stable stablecoin. Just saying it's stable doesn't make it so.

I have dollar deposit protections now. Love or hate the fed, at least you're dealing with a known quantity, and a boatload of laws that are actually (historically demonstrable) enforceable.

There are no regulations or protections in the crypto space, only a bunch of hollow promises.

Until the crypto community can actually demonstrate long term stability (and stable audited reserves) of any so called "stable" coin, I'm not interested in discussing financial theocraticals, let alone moving my dollars out of my FDIC insured bank accounts.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:22PM (#35172517)
Over the weekend, before an FDIC settlement was announced, uninsured SVB deposits were reportedly trading between $0.75 and $0.90 among private sellers.

In other words, both USDC and uninsured SVB deposits had the same market response over the weekend. But every USDC holder had unfettered access, whereas only large SVB depositors were able to access the informal market of private sellers.

I want you to remember this interaction because by the end of the decade, there will be over $1 trillion of USD stablecoins in circulation (in today's dollars), and at least one of the five largest banks in America will run a major stablecoin product of some kind, such as their own stablecoin, redemptions for an existing coin, or consumer on/off-ramps to the crypto financial system.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by lordfrito on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @03:39PM (#35173622)
> before an FDIC settlement was announced, uninsured SVB deposits were reportedly trading between $0.75 and $0.90

The key point is that those were uninsured deposits.

Anyone under FDIC protection was fine.

At best a stablecoin is like an uninsured bank deposit. No thanks, I'll stick to FDIC coverage.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by selimthegrim on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:34PM (#35174342)
> theocraticals

This is an excellent Freudian slip

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by lordfrito on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:40PM (#35174404)
Whoopsie! Good catch.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by halfnormalform on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:06PM (#35174007)
In order to refute your thesis, we have to explain why your imaginary situation is not superior to reality? How about it's completely made up?
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by lifty on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:03AM (#35168495)
They held cash at SVB. They will probably smarten up and start holding short term treasuries and avoid as much as possible bank liabilities. Just a guess.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by rabf on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:12AM (#35169536)
Tha majority of their reserves were in short term tresuries, only a fraction of thier reserves were stored in 4 different banks as cash in order to be able process redemtions.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by lifty on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:24AM (#35169742)
So I guess for them the only option for their short term redemption buffer is to keep money in the 4 systemically important banks. There are no other options. Relevant note, FED won't approve full reserve banks (several tried) as they might suck too many deposits out of the rest of the banks, posing a risk to the other banks.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by polux33 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:56AM (#35170281)
The price on the "secondary market" dropped below 90 cents on the dollar.

Circle before and after the SVB crisis (which happened during a friday night and through the weekend) continued to issue/redeem their tokens at par with the dollar.

It is market sentiment which temporarily devalued USDC.

You would have obtained exactly the same thing if US dollars held in SVB bank accounts were denominated in a virtual currency named "USD-SVB" and a 24/7 blockchain operating the transactions.

Before/After the crisis each USD-SVB would be reedemable for $1 but DURING the crisis I bet you my house those USD-SVB would have fallen like a rock on the dollar.

I know it's good to be anti-crypto on HN but please, try to not completely close your mind to the subject

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by bix6 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:14AM (#35168615)
Vastly superior except there is zero insurance, reserves are held within the traditional banking system and it can depeg at any time…
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by KaiserPro on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @10:44AM (#35169044)
> Stablecoins are conspicuous in their absence in patio11's post.

Stablecoins are just fractional reserve banking but with a thin veneer of tech, and a massive narrative to differentiate them from standard fiat currency.

You're far better off just buying commodities directly, at least where your value is located is much more transparent.

Stablecoins are basically "trust me bro its worth this much, and will never drop, just don't trade too much and make me defend the peg."

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by spir on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @02:24PM (#35172546)
The reason this is not true is because the best stablecoins, like American-run USDC, have excellent transparency and are backed 1:1 in cash and short-duration treasuries, with no fractional reserve system.

https://www.circle.com/en/transparency

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by michael1999 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:53AM (#35170226)
A bank deposit is a stablecoin.

SVB blew up because it was a bad stablecoin.

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by michael1999 on Thursday March 16, 2023 @11:59AM (#35183675)
All stablecoins are inevitably fallible stablecoins. Wealth is social, and can not be "stored" outside a social context.
Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by jameshart on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @11:58AM (#35170316)
How do you create an institution which can guarantee that it will always be able to take the results of its short term treasuries maturing, and convert that back into more short term treasuries, forever?

That sounds like the financial equivalent of a perpetual motion machine.

If an institution has no choice but to buy short term treasuries, why wouldn’t sellers increase the price that institution has to pay?

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by notShabu on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @12:03PM (#35170405)
A good point is individuals could be better off if they could open an account at the Fed and have access to "real" dollars rather than the numbers that are just bank IOUs

Stablecoins are closer in this direction than banks but only if they actually maintain 1:1 reserves. One advantage is that b/c they are protocols there is less need to seek returns to make payroll, rent, and profit. Another is more transparency.

But also... at this point such a stablecoin is basically a CBDC...

Re:Banking in Uncertain Times by ranger207 on Wednesday March 15, 2023 @04:00PM (#35173911)
Patrick didn't talk about stablecoins, but Matt Levine did in Monday's newsletter[0].

Fundamentally, Tether and banks have the same problem: does everyone believe that that bank still has enough money to pay you your deposits? If not, then bank run. Does everyone believe that Tether has enough money to back each coin with $1? If not, then run on Tether. Banks are regulated, so there's supposed to be a bunch of people keeping track of the bank's reserves to see if they have enough money to back deposits. Tether "solves" the problem by not telling anyone what their reserves are, so nobody can figure out if Tether truly has the money to back each coin at $1 or not.

[0] https://archive.is/l4nLU